Ways to Say "Should"
There is good reason to believe that moral entities do not exist objectively, because it is a matter of empirical fact that people disagree about them in a way that they do not disagree about physical reality.
There is good reason to believe that moral entities do not exist objectively, because it is a matter of empirical fact that people disagree about them in a way that they do not disagree about physical reality.
The Ascent from Opinion to Knowledge: A Planksip Perspective In the grand tapestry of human thought, few distinctions are as fundamental, yet as frequently blurred, as that between opinion and knowledge. At planksip.org, we often grapple with the very essence of how we come to understand the world. This...
The Philosophical Meaning of Revolution Revolution, often depicted as a cataclysmic rupture in the fabric of society, carries a profound philosophical weight far beyond its immediate political or social consequences. At its core, a revolution is a radical re-evaluation of the fundamental principles governing human association, a dramatic questioning of...
The Experience of Sense and Knowledge Summary: Our journey into understanding the world begins not with grand theories, but with the immediate, visceral impact of our senses. This article explores the profound and often perplexing relationship between sensory experience and the formation of knowledge. From the raw data of perception...
The Celestial Bridge: Unpacking the Profound Connection Between Angel and God Summary: This article explores the intricate philosophical and theological Connection between Angels and God, drawing from classical Western thought found within the Great Books of the Western World. It posits angels not merely as celestial beings, but as essential...
The Indispensable Canvas: The Role of Labor in the Life of Man The role of labor in the life of man is far more profound than mere economic activity; it is a fundamental force that shapes our existence, identity, and relationship with the world. From the primal necessity of survival...
The Enduring Quest for Order: A Philosophical History of Constitutional Law The grand narrative of human civilization is, in many respects, a continuous search for legitimate Government and a just society. At the heart of this quest lies constitutional law – a body of principles that defines the very structure of...
The Universal Nature of Beauty: A Philosophical Exploration Is beauty truly in the eye of the beholder, or does it possess an inherent, universal quality that transcends individual perception and cultural differences? This enduring philosophical question lies at the heart of our understanding of aesthetics. While our personal experiences of...
The Unseen Hand: Unraveling the Relation Between Cause and Change The world around us is a ceaseless flow of events, a symphony of becoming. From the rustle of leaves to the grand cosmic dance, change is the only constant. But what propels this incessant transformation? What principle underpins the shift...
The Endless Horizon: Unpacking the Ethical Consequences of Immortality Summary: The human yearning for immortality, deeply embedded in myth and philosophy, often overlooks the profound ethical quandaries it would introduce. Far from a simple liberation from life and death, an endless existence would fundamentally reshape our understanding of personal identity,...
The Logic of Hypothesis Testing: A Philosophical Inquiry The human quest for understanding is, at its core, a relentless process of proposing and testing ideas. From the most mundane daily decisions to the grandest scientific theories, we are constantly engaged in hypothesis formation and evaluation. This article delves into the...
The Inductive Heartbeat of Medical Science Summary: The Unseen Foundation of Medical Progress In the vast and intricate tapestry of medical science, the thread of induction is not merely present; it is foundational. From the earliest observations of ancient healers to the sophisticated clinical trials of modern pharmacology, the use...
The Unfathomable Expanse: Grappling with the Problem of Infinity in Space The concept of infinity has long captivated and confounded human thought, particularly when applied to the very fabric of our existence: space. Is space truly boundless, stretching on forever, or does it have an end? This isn't...
The Enduring Role of Prophecy in Religion and the Pursuit of Knowledge Prophecy, in its myriad forms, has played a foundational and often controversial role in shaping human religion and our understanding of knowledge. From ancient oracles to scriptural revelations, it has served as a perceived conduit between the divine...
The Subtle Threads: Unraveling the Distinction Between Art and Poetry The realms of human creativity are vast and wondrous, often blurring lines between categories we strive to define. Among the most fundamental yet frequently conflated are Art and Poetry. While all poetry is undeniably a form of art, understanding the...
The Measured Hand: Temperance as the Cornerstone of Prudent Wealth Management In an age often defined by the relentless pursuit of more, the ancient virtue of temperance offers a profound and urgently needed counter-narrative, particularly in the realm of wealth management. Far from advocating for asceticism or deprivation, temperance champions...
The Ever-Unfolding Scroll: Navigating the Idea of Progress in Science The idea of progress in science is one of humanity's most compelling and enduring narratives. It suggests a linear, upward trajectory of knowledge, understanding, and capability, promising a future ever-improving upon the past. This article delves into the...
The Rhetoric of Oligarchy The exercise of power, especially by the few over the many, is rarely a matter of brute force alone. Instead, it is often a sophisticated dance of persuasion, manipulation, and the careful cultivation of belief. This supporting article delves into the rhetoric of oligarchy, examining how...
The Intricate Dance: Unveiling the Connection Between Desire and Pleasure This article explores the fundamental connection between desire and pleasure, examining how these two powerful forces shape human experience. Drawing insights from the Great Books of the Western World, we delve into the philosophical understanding of desire as the primary...
The Unpredictable Tapestry: Navigating the Element of Chance in World Events The grand narrative of human history often appears as a meticulously woven tapestry, each thread seemingly placed with intention, leading inevitably to the next. Yet, upon closer inspection, a more complex picture emerges: one where the element of chance...
The Crucible of Conscience: Education's Indispensable Role in Instilling Duty Education is far more than the mere transmission of facts; it is the profound and transformative process through which individuals come to understand, internalize, and actively embody their duty to themselves, their communities, and the established societal law....
The Unfolding Mystery: A Journey Through the Nature of Time and Eternity Summary: This article delves into the profound philosophical and scientific inquiries surrounding the Nature of Time and Eternity. Drawing insights from the Great Books of the Western World and contemporary Physics, we explore how thinkers from antiquity to...
The Enduring Question: Defining Courage Courage, at its core, is far more complex than mere bravery. This article delves into the philosophical definition of courage, exploring its ancient roots in the Great Books of the Western World, particularly through the lenses of Plato and Aristotle. We will uncover how courage...
The universe, in all its bewildering complexity, often presents us with a profound paradox: how can the multitude of distinct things we perceive be, at the same time, part of a unified whole? This is the essence of The Philosophical Problem of One and Many, a fundamental question that has...
The Historical Change in Democracy: A Philosophical Odyssey Summary: The Evolving Face of Self-Governance Democracy, as a concept and a form of government, has undergone profound change throughout its history. Far from a static ideal, its meaning, practice, and philosophical underpinnings have been continuously contested, refined, and reshaped across millennia....
The Enduring Architecture of Thought: Unpacking the Logic of Universal and Particular In the vast edifice of human thought, few distinctions are as foundational and enduring as that between the Universal and the Particular. These concepts form the very bedrock of Logic, providing the framework through which we structure our...
The Unseen Architect: How Experience Shapes the Habits of Our Mind Summary: Our lives are largely a tapestry woven from habits, often operating beneath the surface of conscious thought. This article explores the profound philosophical relationship between experience and the formation of habit, arguing that repeated engagement with the world...
The Unfolding Tapestry: Medicine, Knowledge, and the Human Condition The journey of medicine is not merely a chronicle of scientific breakthroughs; it is a profound philosophical expedition, inextricably linked to the very Progress of human Knowledge. From the earliest incantations against disease to the intricate complexities of modern biotechnology, the...
The Enduring Riddle: Confronting the Opposition of Good and Evil in the World The opposition of Good and Evil is not merely a philosophical abstraction; it is the very bedrock upon which much of human experience, history, and moral inquiry is built. From ancient mythologies to modern ethical dilemmas, humanity...
Chains of Contradiction: The Ethics of Slavery and the State in Western Thought The institution of slavery, a stain on human history, presents one of the most profound and enduring ethical challenges to the concept of the state and its claims to justice. From the ancient polis to the modern...
The Guiding Hand: The Role of Prudence in Family Decisions Summary: In the intricate tapestry of family life, prudence emerges as an indispensable virtue, serving as the compass that guides sound decision-making. Far from mere caution, prudence—or phronesis as Aristotle termed it—is the practical wisdom that enables individuals...
The Unseen Hand: Unpacking the Theological Concept of Providence (Fate) In the grand tapestry of human thought, few concepts intertwine as profoundly and perplexingly as "Providence" and "Fate." While often used interchangeably in casual discourse, their philosophical and theological distinctions are vast, revealing different worldviews concerning...
The Enduring Blueprint: Plato's Idea of Form in Animal Classification The seemingly straightforward act of classifying an animal – identifying it as a lion, a robin, or a salmon – belies a profound philosophical lineage stretching back to ancient Greece. This article explores how Plato's Idea of Form,...
The Indispensable Hand: Why Labor Remains the Cornerstone of Wealth Summary: The creation of wealth is not a mere contingency of fortunate circumstances or natural abundance; it is, at its core, a profound necessity born from human labor. From the earliest philosophical reflections to contemporary economic thought, the act of...
The Unseen Architect: How Imagination Forges Art The act of creation, in its most profound sense, is an act of imagination. Far from a mere flight of fancy, imagination stands as a cornerstone of human cognition, serving as the unseen architect that shapes our understanding of the world and, crucially,...