The Guiding Hand: How Prudence Perfects Temperance
Summary: While temperance is often understood as mere self-restraint, its true power as a virtue is unlocked and perfected by prudence. Prudence, the intellectual virtue of practical wisdom, acts as the indispensable guide, enabling temperance to navigate the complexities of desire, pleasure, and appetite not through rigid denial, but through intelligent, context-sensitive moderation, ensuring a truly flourishing and virtuous life. Without prudence, temperance risks becoming a misguided asceticism or an ineffective struggle, failing to achieve its ultimate purpose.
(Image: A classical Greek statue depicting a seated figure, perhaps Athena or a philosopher, with one hand gently resting on a smaller, standing figure who holds a bridle or reins, symbolizing the intellectual guidance of wisdom (Prudence) over the control of impulses and desires (Temperance). The larger figure's gaze is thoughtful and discerning, while the smaller figure appears balanced and poised, not repressed but directed.)
1. Introduction: Beyond Mere Abstinence
In our modern discourse, temperance is frequently reduced to a simple act of saying "no" – abstaining from excess, be it food, drink, or other pleasures. While this restraint is certainly a component, the classical understanding of temperance, deeply rooted in the Great Books of the Western World, reveals a far richer, more nuanced virtue. It is not merely a suppression of desires but their right ordering. But how does one determine the "right ordering"? How does one know what constitutes "enough" or "too much" in a world of infinite variables? The answer, as the ancient philosophers understood, lies in the indispensable intellectual virtue of prudence.
2. Temperance Unveiled: The Virtue of Right Measure
From Plato’s Republic to Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics and Aquinas’s Summa Theologica, temperance (sophrosyne in Greek, temperantia in Latin) stands as a cardinal virtue. It is primarily concerned with the appetitive part of the soul, governing our desires for bodily pleasures, such as food, drink, and sexual gratification.
- Classical Definition: Temperance is the virtue that disposes us to moderate our appetites and passions in accordance with reason. It seeks a mean between excess and deficiency.
- Its Domain: It helps us manage the allure of immediate gratification, ensuring that our pursuit of pleasure serves our greater good and rational nature, rather than enslaving us.
- Virtue and Vice:
- Excess (Vice): Intemperance (e.g., gluttony, lust) is the uncontrolled indulgence of appetites, leading to harm and irrationality.
- Deficiency (Vice): Insensibility (e.g., extreme asceticism, frigidity) is the undue suppression or complete lack of natural and healthy desires, which can also be contrary to human flourishing.
Temperance, therefore, is not about denying pleasure entirely, but about enjoying it rightly, at the right time, in the right measure, and for the right reasons. This is where prudence enters the scene.
3. Prudence: The Architect of Right Action
Often translated as "practical wisdom", prudence (phronesis in Greek) is the intellectual virtue that enables us to deliberate well about what is good and bad for human life, and to act effectively on that deliberation. Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, elevates prudence as the virtue concerned with how to live well in general, not just in specific areas.
- Key Aspects of Prudence:
- Deliberation (Euboulia): The capacity to inquire and reason well about means to an end.
- Judgment (Synesis/Gnome): The ability to correctly assess a situation and discern the appropriate course of action.
- Execution: The resolve to act upon the reasoned judgment.
Prudence is the "charioteer of the virtues" because it guides all other moral virtues. It doesn't just tell us what is good, but how to achieve it in the concrete circumstances of life. It’s the faculty that applies universal principles to particular situations, making it the bedrock of all moral action. Without prudence, courage can become recklessness, justice can become rigidity, and temperance can become misguided self-denial.
4. The Indispensable Partnership: Prudence and Temperance in Action
The true power of temperance emerges when it is guided by prudence. Prudence provides the intelligence, the discernment, and the foresight necessary for temperance to be truly effective and beneficial. It transforms temperance from a blunt instrument into a finely tuned mechanism for self-governance.
Prudence as the Navigator for Temperance:
- Identifying the Golden Mean: Prudence helps define what "moderation" truly means in specific contexts. The mean is not a fixed mathematical point but a relative one, depending on the individual, the situation, and the purpose. Prudence discerns this mean.
- Foreseeing Consequences: A prudent individual considers the long-term effects of their choices. Temperance, informed by prudence, isn't just about avoiding immediate excess but about making choices that contribute to enduring health, well-being, and character.
- Contextual Application: What is temperate in one situation might be intemperate or insensible in another. Prudence allows for flexible, intelligent application of moderation, adapting to unique circumstances rather than adhering to rigid rules.
- Avoiding Extremes: Prudence steers temperance away from both the obvious vice of excess and the less obvious vice of deficiency (insensibility). It ensures that one doesn't deny legitimate pleasures that contribute to a balanced life, nor indulge in those that detract from it.
Table: Prudence Guiding Temperance in Everyday Life
| Area of Life | Temperance (without Prudence) | Temperance (with Prudence) |
|---|---|---|
| Eating | Rigid dieting, deprivation, or impulsive overeating | Mindful eating, balanced nutrition, eating for health and enjoyment in moderation |
| Spending | Hoarding, excessive frugality, or impulsive splurging | Wise investment, responsible consumption, budgeting for needs and reasonable wants |
| Speech | Silence, blunt honesty, or gossiping/idle chatter | Tactful communication, thoughtful expression, speaking truthfully and appropriately |
| Pleasure | Complete denial of enjoyment, or unbridled indulgence | Enjoyment in moderation, appropriate timing, seeking wholesome and fulfilling pleasures |
5. The Pitfalls of Untethered Temperance
When temperance operates without the guiding hand of prudence, it can easily devolve into a vice itself, or at least become ineffective.
- Rigidity and Fanaticism: Temperance untempered by wisdom can lead to an unyielding, unthinking asceticism. This can result in self-denial that is not only unnecessary but harmful, denying legitimate human needs and joys, leading to a life that is austere rather than truly good.
- Misguided Self-Denial: Without prudence, one might deny oneself things that are genuinely beneficial or contribute to human flourishing, simply out of a generalized impulse for "moderation."
- Ineffectiveness: Lacking the wisdom to apply moderation effectively in complex situations, one might struggle to maintain temperance, or apply it in ways that fail to address the root causes of intemperate behavior.
6. Conclusion: A Harmonious Pursuit of Virtue
The relationship between prudence and temperance is not merely complementary; it is symbiotic. Temperance provides the will to moderate, while prudence provides the intelligence to know how and when to moderate. It is prudence that elevates temperance from a simple act of restraint to a profound expression of rational self-governance.
To cultivate a truly virtuous life, therefore, requires a conscious effort to develop both. We must strive not just for self-control, but for the practical wisdom that directs that control towards genuine human flourishing. In this pursuit, we move beyond merely avoiding vice to actively shaping a life of excellence, guided by the discerning light of prudence.
📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics
Video by: The School of Life
💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Temperance," "Aquinas Cardinal Virtues Prudence""