The Unseen Hand: The Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice

Desire, often viewed with suspicion or as a mere biological imperative, plays an absolutely foundational role in the development of both virtue and vice. It is not an inherently moral force, but rather a powerful engine that, when directed by a cultivated will and reason, can propel us towards flourishing and excellence, or, left unchecked, can lead to moral decay and suffering. The Great Books of the Western World offer a consistent, albeit nuanced, exploration of this dynamic, revealing desire as a central battleground for the human spirit.

The Primal Urge: Understanding Desire's Foundation

At its core, desire is an inclination, an appetitive movement towards something perceived as good, beneficial, or lacking. From the simplest biological cravings for food and shelter to the most complex aspirations for knowledge, love, or justice, desire is the fundamental impetus for action. It is the "wanting" that precedes "doing." The ancients, particularly Aristotle, recognized that these urges are a natural part of human existence, neither good nor bad in themselves. They are simply part of our constitution.

The Dual Nature: Desire as a Double-Edged Sword

The moral compass of desire is not fixed; it is highly contingent upon its object and, more crucially, upon the faculty that apprehends and directs it – the will. This duality is perhaps the most critical insight gleaned from centuries of philosophical inquiry.

  • Desire for Virtue: When directed towards noble ends, desire becomes an indispensable ally in the pursuit of virtue.

    • Desire for knowledge: Propels intellectual growth and understanding.
    • Desire for justice: Motivates action against inequity and oppression.
    • Desire for companionship: Fosters love, friendship, and community.
    • Desire for excellence: Drives self-improvement and mastery.

  • Desire for Vice: Conversely, when desire is untamed, misdirected, or fixated on base or excessive ends, it becomes a potent source of vice.

    • Desire for excessive pleasure: Leads to gluttony, debauchery, and addiction.
    • Desire for power: Can manifest as tyranny, oppression, and cruelty.
    • Desire for material wealth: Often results in greed, avarice, and exploitation.
    • Desire for recognition: May devolve into vanity, envy, and deceit.

It is evident that the object of our desire, and the intensity with which we pursue it, are paramount in determining its moral valence.

The Guiding Hand: Reason and the Will

The classical tradition, from Plato to Aquinas, consistently emphasizes the role of reason and the will in shaping our desires.

Plato's Tripartite Soul

In Plato's Republic, the soul is famously divided into three parts:

  1. The Rational Part (Logistikon): Seeks truth and wisdom.
  2. The Spirited Part (Thymoeides): Seeks honor, courage, and righteous indignation.
  3. The Appetitive Part (Epithymetikon): Seeks bodily pleasures and material gains (where most raw desires reside).

For Plato, virtue – particularly the overarching virtue of justice – arises when the rational part, supported by the spirited part, governs and harmonizes the appetitive desires. When the appetites are allowed to run wild, unguided by reason, the result is internal discord and vice.

Aristotle and the Cultivation of Character

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, provides a practical framework for understanding the role of desire in virtue. He argues that virtue is a hexis, a settled disposition of character, achieved through habituation. This means training our desires to feel the right way, at the right time, towards the right objects, and to the right extent.

For Aristotle, a truly virtuous person doesn't just act virtuously; they desire to act virtuously. The person who abstains from excess but still craves it is not as virtuous as the one whose desires are aligned with temperance. This alignment is not automatic; it requires the continuous exercise of practical wisdom (phronesis) and the will. The will is the faculty that assents to or resists desires, that chooses which desires to pursue and how, based on rational deliberation.

The Will: Arbiter of Our Moral Destiny

The will stands as the crucial arbiter in the dynamic interplay between desire and morality. While desires may arise spontaneously, it is the will that determines whether they are indulged, resisted, or transformed.

Aspect of Desire Role of the Will in Virtue Role of the Will in Vice
Origin Acknowledges natural inclination. Submits passively to impulses.
Evaluation Assesses desires through reason. Ignores rational judgment.
Direction Guides desires towards noble ends. Allows desires to dictate action.
Moderation Cultivates temperance and self-control. Indulges in excess or deficiency.
Transformation Refines crude desires into aspirations. Permits desires to corrupt values.

Without a strong, rationally informed will, even the noblest intentions can be shipwrecked by powerful, undisciplined desires. Conversely, a robust will can redirect potentially destructive desires into constructive channels, transforming them into forces for good.

(Image: A detailed classical marble sculpture depicting Hercules at the Crossroads, with two allegorical female figures representing Virtue and Vice. Hercules stands in a moment of contemplation, his gaze perhaps fixed between the arduous, upward path of Virtue and the alluring, downward path of Vice, each figure subtly gesturing towards their respective ways. The scene is rich with symbolic tension, embodying the human struggle to choose between competing desires and moral paths.)

From Passion to Purpose: Transforming Desire

The philosophical tradition does not advocate for the eradication of desire—an impossible and arguably undesirable feat—but rather its transfiguration. This involves:

  1. Self-Awareness: Understanding the nature and intensity of one's own desires.
  2. Rational Deliberation: Applying reason to evaluate the objects and consequences of desires.
  3. Habituation: Through repeated virtuous acts, training the appetites to desire what is good and shun what is harmful.
  4. Moral Imagination: Envisioning the long-term consequences of indulging or restraining particular desires.

This conscious effort, driven by the will, is the path to aligning our inner impulses with our highest ideals, thereby cultivating genuine virtue.

Conclusion: The Indispensable Role of Desire

In sum, desire is far more than a simple biological reflex; it is a fundamental aspect of human experience with a profound role in shaping our moral character. It is the raw material from which both virtue and vice are forged. The crucial determinant lies in the will—that uniquely human faculty which, guided by reason, can either master our desires, directing them towards eudaimonia (human flourishing), or succumb to their unbridled force, leading to a life of moral disarray. The wisdom of the Great Books of the Western World continually reminds us that the journey towards virtue is, in large part, a journey of understanding, shaping, and ultimately ennobling our desires.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics desire virtue explanation""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Tripartite Soul and Justice in the Republic""

Share this post