The Necessity of Courage in War and Necessity and Contingency

The Indispensable Virtue: The Necessity of Courage in War

In the grim calculus of armed conflict, few virtues prove as indispensable as courage. It is not merely a desirable trait, a fortunate contingency that may or may not manifest; rather, it is a necessity, a fundamental pillar upon which the very possibility of effective defense, strategic execution, and the ultimate pursuit of peace rests. From the ancient battlefields described by Thucydides to the complex moral dilemmas faced by modern soldiers, the philosophical tradition, particularly within the Great Books of the Western World, consistently underscores courage as a foundational duty, not only for the individual combatant but for the collective spirit of any society confronting the horrors of war. Without it, even the most meticulously planned strategies crumble, and the will to persevere dissolves into despair.

The Philosophical Foundations of Courage

To truly grasp the necessity of courage, we must first distinguish it from mere absence of fear or reckless abandon. Philosophers throughout history have delved deep into its nature, revealing its complex layers.

Courage Beyond Brashness: A Virtue of Reason

For thinkers like Plato and Aristotle, courage (ἀνδρεία, andreia) was not simply a visceral reaction but a cardinal virtue, deeply intertwined with reason and wisdom.

Plato's Perspective: In dialogues such as Laches and The Republic, Plato explores courage as the knowledge of what truly ought to be feared and what ought not. It's not the absence of fear, but the ability to stand firm in the face of genuine danger, guided by rational understanding of what is good and just. A truly courageous person fears dishonor and injustice more than death itself.
Aristotle's Golden Mean: Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, positions courage as a mean between two extremes: the excess of rashness and the deficiency of cowardice. The courageous person acts appropriately, weighing the danger and acting for a noble cause. Their actions are voluntary, deliberate, and motivated by a sense of duty and honor, rather than blind impulse or fear of shame.

This understanding elevates courage from a simple emotion to a deliberate, cultivated disposition—a necessity for ethical action, especially when lives are on the line.

The Indelible Mark of Necessity

Why is courage a necessity rather than a mere advantage? Because war, by its very nature, confronts individuals and societies with existential threats, profound suffering, and moral dilemmas that demand more than just tactical skill.

Overcoming Fear: Fear is a natural human response to danger. Courage is the capacity to act despite this fear, to overcome the paralyzing instinct for self-preservation when a greater good or duty calls.
Sustaining Resolve: In prolonged conflicts, weariness, despair, and the constant threat of death can erode morale. Courage provides the inner fortitude to sustain effort, to endure hardship, and to maintain the fighting spirit.
Moral Integrity: Courage often involves standing up for what is right, even when it is dangerous or unpopular. This moral dimension ensures that actions in war are not merely pragmatic but also aligned with a just cause, preventing descent into barbarity.

War: The Ultimate Crucible of Courage

The battlefield strips away pretenses, exposing the core of human character. Here, the abstract philosophical concept of courage becomes a lived, visceral reality.

The Demands of Duty and Sacrifice

In military contexts, courage is often framed as a duty. Soldiers are expected to face danger, to hold their ground, and to execute orders that may put their lives at risk. This duty is not merely a contractual obligation but often a profound moral commitment to comrades, country, and the ideals they represent.

Personal Sacrifice: Courage in war frequently entails the ultimate sacrifice of one's life. This willingness to prioritize the collective good over individual survival is a testament to the profound ethical dimension of military duty.
Leadership in Adversity: Leaders, especially, require immense courage to make difficult decisions under pressure, to inspire confidence in their troops, and to bear the heavy burden of responsibility for the lives under their command.

Generated Image

The Collective Heartbeat of Resolve

While courage is an individual virtue, its impact in war is profoundly collective.

Mutual Support: The courage of one soldier can inspire others, creating a ripple effect of bravery throughout a unit. Conversely, a lack of courage can quickly spread panic and demoralization.
Strategic Impact: The collective courage of an army can turn the tide of battle, enabling forces to hold crucial positions, launch decisive attacks, or endure prolonged sieges. It transforms mere numbers into an effective fighting force.

Courage, Necessity, and Contingency: A Philosophical Interplay

The relationship between courage, necessity, and contingency is critical to understanding its role in war and peace.

Is Courage Contingent or Necessary?

One might argue that courage is a contingent trait, appearing only when circumstances demand it. However, a deeper philosophical examination reveals its necessity.

Contingent Manifestation: The opportunity to display courage is certainly contingent upon circumstances (e.g., war, crisis).
Necessary Potential: The capacity for courage, however, is a necessary human potential that must be cultivated. Societies that fail to instill this potential in their citizens, especially those designated to protect them, invite inevitable disaster when faced with conflict.
The Necessity of Cultivation: Courage is not merely "found" in the heat of battle; it is forged through discipline, training, moral education, and the adherence to a code of duty. This cultivation is a societal necessity for survival.

The Necessary Consequences of Its Absence

The absence of courage leads to predictable and often catastrophic outcomes.

Individual Failure: Cowardice leads to desertion, dereliction of duty, and the inability to protect oneself or others.
Collective Collapse: A widespread lack of courage within a military force inevitably leads to defeat, subjugation, and the loss of sovereignty. The necessity of courage becomes starkly evident when considering the alternative—the complete unraveling of order and purpose.

Courage, War, and the Pursuit of Peace

The ultimate paradox of courage in war is that it is often employed as a means to achieve peace.

Fighting for Peace

The decision to engage in war, even a just one, is a tragic necessity. When diplomacy fails and aggression threatens fundamental values, courage becomes the instrument by which a society defends itself and strives to restore order.

Deterrence: The known courage of a nation's defenders can act as a deterrent, preventing conflict.
Restoration of Order: Courageous action in defense or offense, when morally justified, aims to neutralize threats and create the conditions for a stable and lasting peace. This echoes Augustine's view that even war can be waged with a desire for peace.

Beyond the Battlefield: Civic Courage

While courage is acutely highlighted in war, its necessity extends to peacetime. Civic courage—the willingness to speak truth to power, to uphold justice, to challenge corruption, and to defend democratic principles—is vital for maintaining a healthy society. This form of courage ensures that the hard-won peace is not undermined by internal decay.

Conclusion: An Enduring Necessity

The philosophical journey through the nature of courage, from Plato's rational virtue to Aristotle's golden mean, reveals an enduring truth: it is an absolute necessity in the context of war. Far from being a mere contingency, courage is a cultivated disposition, a profound duty, and the very bedrock upon which societies defend themselves, overcome fear, and ultimately strive for the restoration of peace. Its absence guarantees failure, while its presence, though never guaranteeing victory, offers the only hope for preserving what is good and just. The lessons from the Great Books of the Western World resonate clearly: to neglect the cultivation of courage is to invite catastrophe and to betray the very essence of human dignity in the face of adversity.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

📹 Related Video: PLATO ON: The Allegory of the Cave

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato Aristotle Courage Virtue Ethics War""

📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics