The Evolution of Moral Customs and Evolution

The Shifting Sands of Right and Wrong: An Exploration of Moral Customs

Moral customs, often perceived as immutable pillars of society, are in fact dynamic constructs, perpetually shaped and reshaped by historical forces, social needs, and philosophical inquiry. This article delves into the evolution of these customs and conventions, examining how our understanding of virtue and vice undergoes significant change across generations, drawing insights from the rich tapestry of Western thought. From ancient Greece to the Enlightenment and beyond, philosophers have grappled with the fluidity of human morality, revealing that what is considered "right" today may have been "wrong" yesterday, and vice versa.

I. Defining the Moral Landscape: Custom, Convention, and Conscience

To understand the evolution of moral customs, we must first define them. Moral customs and conventions are the unwritten rules, shared beliefs, and habitual practices that guide the behavior of individuals within a particular society or community. They are distinct from universal moral laws, if such exist, in that their authority often stems from tradition, social consensus, and practical utility rather than absolute truth. As thinkers like the Sophists debated in ancient Greece, the distinction between nomos (law/custom) and physis (nature) highlights this very point: are our morals naturally endowed, or are they products of human agreement and habit?

For many philosophers found within the Great Books of the Western World, societal norms, ethical codes, and even the very concept of virtue and vice are inextricably linked to their historical and cultural context. They are not static decrees from on high but living traditions that adapt to the changing realities of human existence.

II. The Engines of Change: Why Morals Evolve

The notion that moral principles can undergo profound change might seem unsettling, yet history provides abundant evidence. The mechanisms driving this evolution are multifaceted, ranging from material conditions to intellectual revolutions.

Factors Driving Moral Evolution

| Category | Description | Examples will current moral customs be sufficient for future challenges? This question leads us to ponder the very evolution of ethics itself.

III. Voices from the Great Books: Philosophers on Moral Evolution

The idea that morality is not a fixed construct but something that evolves with human society has deep roots in Western philosophy.

Aristotle and the Habituation of Virtue: While Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, presents virtues like courage, temperance, and justice as stable dispositions, he also emphasizes that these virtues are cultivated through habituation within a community. The specific acts considered courageous or just, and the expression of these virtues, are culturally bound. A phronimos (person of practical wisdom) must discern the virtuous path within the changing customs and conventions of their specific polis. Thus, while the core virtues might be constant, their practical application and societal manifestation evolve.
Hume's Sentiment and Custom: David Hume, in his Treatise of Human Nature, argued that morality is rooted not in reason but in sentiment and sympathy. Our moral judgments arise from feelings of approval or disapproval, which are shaped by our social interactions and established customs. For Hume, these sentiments and customs naturally change over time as human experience broadens and our capacity for sympathy evolves. The utility and agreeableness of actions, perceived through custom, drive moral approbation.
Locke's Social Contract and Rights: John Locke's Two Treatises of Government posits that legitimate government arises from a social contract designed to protect individuals' natural rights. This foundational idea implies a mechanism for moral change: if existing customs and conventions or governmental structures fail to uphold these natural rights, they can and should be altered. The ongoing re-evaluation of laws and societal norms to better secure liberty and property is a clear example of moral evolution driven by a principled understanding of human rights.
Mill and Utilitarian Progress: John Stuart Mill, a staunch advocate for utilitarianism and individual liberty, articulated a vision of moral progress in works like On Liberty and Utilitarianism. For Mill, the standard of morality is the greatest good for the greatest number. This principle inherently demands a continuous re-evaluation and evolution of moral rules and societal customs to maximize overall happiness and well-being. As societies advance in knowledge and understanding, so too must their ethical frameworks adapt to achieve better outcomes, making change not just possible, but necessary for moral evolution.

(Image: A classical Greek philosopher, perhaps Aristotle, engaged in earnest discussion with students in an ancient stoa, with a faint, overlaid modern cityscape visible in the distant background, symbolizing the enduring questions of ethics and virtue across millennia of societal evolution.)

IV. Virtue and Vice in Flux: Reinterpreting Right and Wrong

Perhaps the most striking evidence of moral evolution is found in how definitions of virtue and vice have transformed across history. What was once considered praiseworthy can become condemned, and vice-versa.

Slavery: For millennia, chattel slavery was an accepted custom across many civilizations, from ancient Egypt and Greece (as discussed in Aristotle's Politics) to the Roman Empire and beyond. It was often justified by philosophical arguments about natural hierarchies or economic necessity. Today, it is universally condemned as a profound vice, an egregious violation of human dignity. This represents a monumental change in global moral consciousness.
Usury: Lending money at interest, or usury, was considered a serious vice and often forbidden by religious and philosophical teachings for centuries, notably in medieval Christian thought (e.g., Aquinas in Summa Theologica). It was seen as exploiting the needy. With the evolution of economic systems and the rise of capitalism, it transformed from a vice into an accepted, indeed essential, economic practice, now regulated rather than outlawed.
Chivalry vs. Modern Equality: The medieval virtues of chivalry, while promoting protection of the weak and honor, were often rooted in highly patriarchal customs and conventions that limited women's roles and agency. While aspects of courtesy remain valued, the modern virtue of gender equality has necessitated a radical change in how we understand and apply ideals of respect and protection, moving away from paternalism towards mutual recognition of equal worth.

These examples underscore that virtue and vice are not static categories but are continually re-interpreted through the lens of evolving societal values, scientific understanding, and philosophical insights. The process of discerning new virtues and identifying emerging vices is an ongoing societal dialogue, often culminating in legal reforms and shifts in public opinion.

V. The Ongoing Journey: Embracing Moral Dynamism

The evidence from the Great Books and human history overwhelmingly suggests that moral customs and conventions are not fixed. They are in a constant state of evolution, shaped by a complex interplay of environmental, social, technological, and intellectual forces. Embracing this dynamism is crucial, for it allows us to critically reflect on our present virtues and vices, question inherited norms, and consciously strive for a more just and humane future. The responsibility falls to each generation to engage with this ongoing philosophical project, navigating the inevitable change with wisdom and foresight.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Evolving Nature of Morality Philosophy"