The Ethical Duty of Temperance and Ethical

The Unyielding Mandate: Temperance as an Ethical Duty

The concept of temperance, often relegated to a mere suggestion for personal prudence, stands, upon deeper philosophical scrutiny, as an ethical duty of profound importance. It is not simply about moderation in consumption or restraint in passion, but rather a foundational virtue essential for both individual flourishing and societal harmony. To neglect temperance is to court vice, a descent into imbalance that erodes character and undermines the very fabric of a just existence. This article explores temperance not merely as a desirable trait, but as an imperative, drawing insights from the enduring wisdom enshrined within the Great Books of the Western World.

Temperance in the Classical Tradition: A Virtue of Self-Mastery

From the earliest philosophical inquiries, temperance has been recognized as a cornerstone virtue. The ancient Greeks, in particular, elevated it beyond simple abstention, seeing it as a state of inner balance and rational control.

Plato's Harmony of the Soul: In his seminal work, The Republic, Plato posits that a just individual, much like a just state, achieves harmony when each part performs its proper function. Temperance (sophrosyne) is the agreement among the soul's three parts—reason, spirit, and appetite—that reason should rule. It is the virtue that ensures the appetitive part, prone to excess and desire, submits willingly to the guidance of reason. Without this internal submission, the soul falls into disarray, leading to irrational actions and a life dictated by fleeting impulses rather than considered judgment. For Plato, temperance is not just a personal choice but a necessary condition for psychological and moral health, a pre-requisite for genuine freedom.
Aristotle's Golden Mean: Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, further refines the understanding of temperance as a mean between two extremes of vice. He defines it as the virtue concerned with pleasures and pains, particularly those related to touch and taste (food, drink, sex). The temperate person finds the appropriate mean, neither indulging excessively (intemperance or profligacy) nor being insusceptible to pleasure (insensibility). It is a disposition to choose the right amount, at the right time, towards the right objects, and for the right reasons. For Aristotle, ethical virtues are habits formed through practice, and temperance is a prime example of how consistent, rational choices lead to a virtuous character.

From Virtue to Duty: The Ethical Imperative

While Plato and Aristotle primarily framed temperance as a virtue, its implications extend inevitably into the realm of duty. When a virtue is so intrinsically linked to the well-being of the individual and the community, its cultivation becomes not merely advisable but obligatory.

The ethical duty of temperance arises from several considerations:

Duty to Self: Each individual has a duty to cultivate their own highest potential. Intemperance—whether in thought, word, or deed—hinders rational thought, enslaves the will to base desires, and prevents the pursuit of higher goods. To allow one's appetites to dictate one's life is to fail in the duty of self-governance and self-respect, diminishing one's capacity for true freedom and happiness.
Duty to Others: Our actions, particularly our excesses, do not occur in a vacuum. Intemperance often leads to behaviors that harm others, whether through neglect of responsibilities, financial ruin, or emotional instability. A person lacking temperance may be unreliable, unjust, or even dangerous. Therefore, cultivating temperance is an ethical duty towards the community, ensuring one remains a responsible, contributing member rather than a burden or a source of harm.
Duty to Reason and Truth: The philosophical tradition, especially that stemming from the Great Books, places a high value on reason. Temperance allows reason to govern, enabling clear judgment and the pursuit of truth. To surrender to irrational impulses is to betray this fundamental human capacity and thus neglect a profound ethical duty to one's own intellect.

(Image: A classical Greek sculpture depicting a serene, balanced figure, possibly a philosopher or a deity associated with wisdom or self-control, set against a backdrop of ancient ruins or a clear, thoughtful sky. The figure's posture conveys inner calm and disciplined thought, with subtle iconography suggesting moderation.)

Distinguishing Virtue from Vice: The Spectrum of Temperance

To understand temperance as an ethical duty, it is crucial to delineate it from its associated vices. Aristotle's framework of the Golden Mean provides an excellent lens for this distinction:

Trait Category	Deficiency (Vice)	Virtue (Temperance)	Excess (Vice)
Pleasure	Insensibility (Apathy)	Temperance (Moderation)	Intemperance (Profligacy)
Spending	Stinginess (Meanness)	Liberality (Generosity)	Prodigality (Wastefulness)
Anger	Lack of Spirit (Pusillanimity)	Mildness (Even-temperedness)	Irascibility (Hot-headedness)
Food/Drink	Asceticism (Extreme Denial)	Temperance (Prudent Enjoyment)	Gluttony (Overindulgence)

This table illustrates that temperance is not an absence of desire or pleasure, but rather their rational and appropriate management. Both deficiency and excess represent a failure in ethical duty, leading to a distorted and imbalanced character.

The Practical Application of Temperance

The ethical duty of temperance manifests in various aspects of modern life, far beyond merely abstaining from alcohol or food. It encompasses:

Financial Prudence: Managing resources responsibly, avoiding reckless spending or avarice.
Emotional Regulation: Controlling outbursts of anger, envy, or fear, responding thoughtfully rather than reactively.
Intellectual Humility: Recognizing the limits of one's knowledge, avoiding dogmatism, and being open to new ideas.
Time Management: Prioritizing tasks, avoiding procrastination, and balancing work with rest and recreation.
Digital Discipline: Moderating screen time, discerning valuable information from trivial distractions, and avoiding the vice of constant connectivity.

In each of these domains, the temperate individual exercises self-control, guided by reason, fulfilling their ethical duty to themselves and to the wider community.

Conclusion

The ethical duty of temperance is not a relic of ancient philosophy but a timeless and pressing imperative. It is the virtue that empowers us to master our passions, to live in harmony with ourselves, and to contribute constructively to the world around us. Neglecting this duty inevitably leads to vice, disrupting personal well-being and fostering societal discord. By embracing temperance, we affirm our commitment to reason, self-mastery, and the pursuit of a genuinely good life, echoing the profound wisdom passed down through the ages in the Great Books of the Western World.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance explained""