When First We Practice to Deceive!
Duality is in the Eye of Deceiving Her
Setting: A serene, timeless garden where three figures sit on a simple stone bench near a placid reflecting pool. The air is still, and the light is soft, as if caught between dawn and dusk.
Sophia: (Gazing into the reflecting pool) Tell me what you see. You each look upon the same water, yet the reflection is shaped by the one who looks.
Bertrand: (Scoffs lightly, adjusting his collar) I see a reflection of the world’s most frustrating paradox. I see a society where those most lacking in reason are the most passionate in their convictions. They charge forward, absolutely certain of their footing, while the truly intelligent are moored by the weight of their own questions, hesitant to take a single step for fear it is the wrong one. The world is dragged along by the loudest and least-informed voices.
Sophia: You see a chasm, then? Between certainty and doubt. You present it as a flaw in the world’s design—the foolish leading the wise.
No cord nor cable can so forcibly draw, or hold so fast, as love can do with a twined thread.
— Robert Burton (1577-1640)
Robert: (His voice soft, yet resonant) Perhaps the instrument of measure is wrong. Bertrand, you speak of being dragged along, of force. But I have found that the most powerful compulsions are not those of overt strength. You cannot truly bind a person with chains or rope; those can be seen, fought against, and broken. The most profound and lasting connection, the one that truly holds a person captive, is a bond woven from something as simple as affection. It has no visible strength, that twined thread of love, yet it can draw and hold with a force no cable can ever match.
Sophia: (A faint smile touches her lips) And now Robert presents another chasm. One between the brute force of a cable and the gentle strength of a thread.
She turns her gaze from one man to the other.
Sophia: Both of you bring me these pairs, these opposites, as if to ask which is true. The cocksure fool or the doubtful intellectual? The iron chain or the silken thread? You lay them at my feet and in doing so, you attempt to deceive me.
Bertrand and Robert exchange a puzzled glance.
Bertrand: Deceive you? How? I am merely stating an observation.
Sophia: The deception is in the duality itself. You ask me to choose, but the truth is not on either side of the chasm you have created. It is the chasm. Bertrand, the absolute certainty of the fool you describe is a kind of brute force, is it not? A rigid cable of belief they use to pull others along. But like any taut cable, it is brittle. It allows no room for nuance, and under the slightest unexpected strain, it snaps.
The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.
— Bertrand Russell (1872-1970)
She turns to Robert.
Sophia: And the thread you champion, Robert… it holds precisely because it is not rigid. It has give. It is complex, woven from countless smaller fibers. Is the hesitation of the intelligent man not also a kind of thread? He weaves it from questions, from possibilities, from empathy. His doubt is not a weakness; it is a profound and flexible strength that connects him to the truth in a way certainty never could.
She gestures back to the reflecting pool, where a light breeze now ripples the surface, blurring the clear reflections of the sky and trees.
Sophia: You see? The world is not a choice between the cable and the thread. It is about understanding that the strongest things are those that appear delicate. The fool’s certainty is a hollow performance of strength. The wise man’s doubt is the quiet, resilient core of it. The lover’s bond is not an alternative to force; it is a perfected form of it. To present them as opposites is the grand illusion. Duality, gentlemen, is the elegant lie you tell yourselves, and in turn, you try to tell me. The real wisdom is seeing the thread inside the cable, and the cable’s true purpose fulfilled in the thread.
The planksip Writers' Cooperative is proud to sponsor an exciting article rewriting competition where you can win part of over $750,000 in available prize money.
Figures of Speech Collection Personified
Our editorial instructions for your contest submission are simple: incorporate the quotes and imagery from the above article into your submission.
What emerges is entirely up to you!
Winners receive $500 per winning entry multiplied by the article's featured quotes. Our largest prize is $8,000 for rewriting the following article;
Heraclitus
At planksip, we believe in changing the way people engage—at least, that's the Idea (ἰδέα). By becoming a member of our thought-provoking community, you'll have the chance to win incredible prizes and access our extensive network of media outlets, which will amplify your voice as a thought leader. Your membership truly matters!