The Perpetual Dance: War and Peace as Fundamental States of Existence

Summary: Beyond their conventional definitions as geopolitical conditions, "War and Peace" represent fundamental, often intertwined states of existence, deeply embedded in both the human experience and the very fabric of the cosmos. Drawing insights from the Great Books of the Western World, this article explores how conflict and harmony are not merely events but persistent modes of being, characterized by constant change, and inextricably linked to the cycles of life and death.

The Inescapable Duality: War and Peace Beyond the Battlefield

From the clashing of empires to the quiet contemplation of a sage, the concepts of War and Peace resonate through every facet of existence. They are not merely historical epochs or political doctrines, but rather profound philosophical categories that describe the fundamental conditions under which all things, from subatomic particles to human civilizations, operate. As Daniel Fletcher, I find it compelling to consider these not as temporary interruptions of a baseline reality, but as primary states of being, constantly vying for dominance, intermingling, and transforming one into the other. This dynamic interplay, a perpetual dance of opposition and resolution, is the engine of all change.

War as a Primal State of Being

To speak of War as a state of existence is to acknowledge the inherent struggle, tension, and competition that define much of reality. Heraclitus, a profound voice from the Great Books of the Western World, famously declared that "War is the father of all things," suggesting that strife and opposition are not merely destructive but are the very forces that bring things into being and drive their evolution.

Consider these manifestations of "war":

  • Cosmic Conflict: The gravitational pull and repulsive forces that shape galaxies, the constant creation and destruction of stars.
  • Biological Struggle: The relentless competition for resources, the predator-prey dynamic, the fight for survival that underpins all life and death on Earth. Every organism exists within a delicate balance, constantly fending off threats, adapting, or succumbing.
  • Internal Strife: The psychological battles within the individual – conflicting desires, moral dilemmas, the struggle for self-mastery. Plato, in The Republic, conceptualizes justice within the soul as a harmony among its parts, implying that injustice is a form of internal war.
  • Societal Discord: As Thomas Hobbes articulated in Leviathan, the "state of nature" is a "war of all against all," where human beings, driven by self-preservation and competition, live in perpetual fear. The formation of society, for Hobbes, is an escape from this primal state of war, though its specter always looms.

This state of war is not always violent in the conventional sense. It can be a persistent tension, a simmering disagreement, a constant push and pull that prevents static equilibrium. It is the friction that generates heat, the resistance that builds strength.

Peace as an Ideal and a Fleeting Reality

Conversely, Peace as a state of existence embodies harmony, equilibrium, and the absence of overt conflict. It is often sought as an ideal, a respite from the arduousness of struggle, and a condition conducive to flourishing. Yet, like war, peace is rarely static; it is a dynamic balance, often achieved through effort and maintained through vigilance.

Aspects of the state of peace include:

  • Cosmic Harmony: The stable orbits of planets, the intricate balance of ecosystems, the moments of cosmic expansion and order.
  • Biological Equilibrium: The symbiotic relationships between species, the periods of growth and reproduction when conditions are favorable, the natural cycle of renewal and decay where new life and death are integrated into the broader system.
  • Inner Tranquility: The state of mental calm, self-acceptance, and psychological integration. Philosophers like Aristotle, in exploring eudaimonia (human flourishing), describe a life lived in accordance with virtue as one marked by a profound sense of inner peace.
  • Societal Order: The functioning of just laws, cooperative endeavors, and the mutual recognition of rights that allows communities to thrive. The ideal polis envisioned by Plato and Aristotle sought to create a just and harmonious society, a state of collective peace.

Peace is often the desired outcome of war, the resolution of conflict. But it is also the fertile ground from which new challenges, and thus new forms of "war," can emerge.

The Unceasing Cycle of Change: From War to Peace and Back Again

The most crucial insight into these states is their inherent dynamism. Change is the constant, the bridge between war and peace. Neither state is permanent; they are phases in an endless cycle.

(Image: A stylized depiction of two intertwined figures, one in dynamic motion with sharp angles symbolizing conflict, the other in flowing, calm lines symbolizing harmony. They are shown in a continuous loop, suggesting transformation, with a subtle background showing cosmic elements and human figures struggling and resting.)

  • From War to Peace: Conflict often leads to exhaustion, negotiation, or resolution, ushering in a period of peace. A personal struggle might resolve into a newfound understanding, a societal upheaval into a new order.
  • From Peace to War: Periods of peace can lead to complacency, the accumulation of grievances, or the rise of new ambitions, eventually sparking new conflicts. Economic stability might breed new forms of competition, or internal harmony might be disrupted by external threats.

This perpetual flux is what gives existence its vibrancy and complexity. It is the very essence of life and death – the birth of a new organism is a struggle, its life a continuous adaptation, its death a transformation into new forms. The Great Books of the Western World are replete with narratives and philosophical arguments detailing this relentless ebb and flow: from the epic battles in Homer to the political intrigues in Machiavelli's The Prince, where a ruler must constantly navigate between maintaining order (peace) and engaging in necessary conflict (war).

Philosophical Reflections from the Great Books

The profound exploration of War and Peace as states of existence is a recurring theme across the Great Books of the Western World. Key thinkers offer diverse perspectives:

  • Heraclitus: Emphasizes change and strife ("War is the father of all things") as fundamental to reality, suggesting that opposition is necessary for existence.
  • Plato: In The Republic, he seeks to define justice as a state of internal and external harmony (peace), contrasting it with the disunity and conflict (war) that characterize injustice.
  • Aristotle: Explores the conditions for a good life (eudaimonia) and a well-ordered polis, both of which strive for a state of flourishing peace, achieved through virtue and rational governance.
  • Thucydides: His History of the Peloponnesian War offers a stark, realistic account of the causes and consequences of war, illustrating its destructive power and the human frailties that perpetuate it.
  • Thomas Hobbes: In Leviathan, he posits a "state of nature" as a constant war of all against all, arguing that society and government are necessary to secure peace and prevent a reversion to chaos.
  • Niccolò Machiavelli: The Prince delves into the practicalities of power, often advocating for a pragmatic approach that embraces conflict (war) when necessary to maintain the state and secure its stability (a form of peace).

These diverse perspectives collectively underscore that War and Peace are not merely external events, but deeply rooted, dynamic states that define the very essence of our existence, constantly shaped by and shaping the forces of change and the fundamental realities of life and death.

Further Exploration

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Heraclitus Philosophy of Change and Conflict""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Hobbes Leviathan State of Nature Explained""

Share this post