War and Peace as States of Existence: A Philosophical Inquiry

War and Peace are often perceived as mere events or historical periods, yet a deeper philosophical lens reveals them as profound states of human and societal existence. This article delves into the notion that these fundamental conditions transcend simple conflict or its absence, representing dynamic, intertwined aspects of our being that shape our understanding of life and death, drive change, and define the very nature of our collective and individual state. Drawing from the enduring wisdom housed within the Great Books of the Western World, we explore how these concepts are not static endpoints but rather continuous, evolving dimensions of the human experience.

The Inescapable Dance: War and Peace Beyond Event

From the earliest philosophical inquiries, humanity has grappled with the inherent tension between conflict and concord. It is a simplistic view to consider war merely as battle and peace solely as its cessation. Instead, we are invited to consider them as fundamental modes of being, deep-seated conditions that influence everything from individual psychology to the structure of nations.

War as a Primal State: The Crucible of Existence

Many thinkers, particularly those reflecting on the "state of nature," have posited that conflict is not an aberration but often a foundational state. Thomas Hobbes, for instance, famously described life in the state of nature as "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short," a perpetual "war of all against all." This perspective suggests that the inclination towards conflict, competition, and the struggle for survival is deeply ingrained, making war a default state that requires constant effort to overcome.

  • Characteristics of the War State:
    • Insecurity: A pervasive sense of threat to life and property.
    • Competition: Resource scarcity or perceived threats drive aggressive pursuit of interests.
    • Instability: Constant flux and the potential for rapid, destructive change.
    • Existential Stakes: The immediate proximity of death as a constant possibility.

Peace as an Achieved State: The Cultivation of Order

Conversely, peace is rarely depicted as a natural given but rather as a cultivated, often fragile, state. It is an achievement, a testament to human reason, cooperation, and the establishment of robust social and political structures. Thinkers like John Locke and Immanuel Kant argued for the creation of civil societies and international laws to move beyond the natural state of potential conflict, striving for a perpetual peace that safeguards life and liberty.

  • Characteristics of the Peace State:
    • Security: Freedom from immediate threat, allowing for long-term planning.
    • Cooperation: Collaborative efforts for mutual benefit and progress.
    • Stability: Predictable order that facilitates growth and development.
    • Flourishing Life: Conditions conducive to the preservation and enhancement of life.

The Dynamic Interplay: Change and the Cycles of Existence

The most crucial aspect of viewing War and Peace as states of existence is recognizing their inherent dynamism. They are not fixed points but rather phases in a continuous process of change. History, as chronicled in the Great Books, is replete with examples of societies transitioning between these states, often in cyclical patterns.

(Image: A monochromatic etching depicting a classical allegorical scene. On one side, a chaotic skirmish of armored figures with broken spears, symbolizing War and destruction. On the other, a serene landscape with figures engaged in agriculture and scholarly pursuits under a benevolent sun, representing Peace and prosperity. A central, veiled figure with outstretched hands stands between them, embodying the perpetual human choice or the inevitable flux between these states.)

This constant flux underscores a fundamental philosophical truth: permanence is an illusion. The very essence of existence is change. Peace can breed complacency, leading to the conditions for war, just as the devastation of war can forge a powerful desire for enduring peace. The interplay of life and death is central to this cycle; war brings death, while peace offers the chance for life to thrive, only for the shadow of conflict to loom once more.

Philosophical Reflections on Change

  • Heraclitus: "Panta rhei" – all things flow. This ancient Greek dictum perfectly captures the ceaseless change between states of being, including war and peace.
  • Hegel: His dialectical process of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis can be seen in the historical unfolding of war leading to new forms of peace, which in turn generate new conflicts.
  • Tolstoy: In War and Peace, he meticulously details how grand historical movements and individual lives are inextricably bound to these alternating states, highlighting the profound impact on human destiny and moral choices.

Life and Death: The Ultimate Stakes

At the heart of the distinction between the states of War and Peace lies the fundamental dichotomy of life and death. War, by its very definition, is an enterprise of destruction, a confrontation with mortality on a grand scale. It forces humanity to confront its own fragility, the impermanence of existence, and the ultimate sacrifice. Peace, conversely, is the condition under which life can flourish, culture can develop, and individuals can pursue happiness and self-realization without the immediate threat of annihilation.

The choice, or often the unwitting drift, between these states profoundly impacts the value placed on life itself. In war, individual life can become a mere statistic, a pawn in a larger game. In peace, each life holds intrinsic value, a component of the collective good. Understanding this profound connection is crucial for any philosophical inquiry into human nature and societal organization.

Conclusion: The Enduring Quest for Harmony

Ultimately, viewing War and Peace as fundamental states of existence, rather than isolated events, compels us to recognize the continuous struggle within ourselves and our societies. The pursuit of peace is not merely the absence of conflict but an active, ongoing effort to maintain a delicate balance, to foster conditions where life can thrive, and to navigate the inevitable currents of change. The lessons from the Great Books of the Western World consistently remind us that these states are fluid, intertwined, and deeply reflective of human nature's capacity for both profound destruction and boundless creation. Our philosophical journey is, in essence, an eternal quest to understand and perhaps, to guide this inescapable dance towards greater harmony.

YouTube: "Hobbes state of nature philosophy"
YouTube: "Kant perpetual peace philosophy"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "War and Peace as States of Existence philosophy"

Share this post