The Virtue of Temperance over Pleasure

Summary: The virtue of temperance isn't about denying ourselves pleasure entirely, but rather about mastering our desires to live a balanced, rational, and truly flourishing life. Far from being a mere abstention, temperance is a cornerstone of self-mastery, allowing us to navigate the powerful currents of pleasure and pain with wisdom, rather than being swept away by unbridled desire. This article delves into how philosophers from the Great Books of the Western World illuminate temperance as a superior path to genuine well-being, contrasting it sharply with the pitfalls of vice.

The Allure and the Abyss: Understanding Pleasure's Grip

Pleasure. It’s an immediate, undeniable force in human experience. From the simplest sensory gratification to the profound joys of achievement and connection, we are hardwired to seek it out and to recoil from its counterpart, pain. But what happens when our pursuit of pleasure becomes an untamed desire, an insatiable hunger that dictates our choices and defines our existence? This is where the ancient wisdom of temperance offers a profound counter-narrative to the modern obsession with instant gratification.

Desire: The Engine of Our Appetites

At the heart of our relationship with pleasure lies desire. It is the impulse that drives us towards what we perceive as good or away from what we perceive as harmful. While desire itself is neutral, its management is crucial. Unchecked desire can quickly morph into vice, leading us down paths of excess and ultimately, dissatisfaction. Think of the glutton who can never truly enjoy a meal, or the thrill-seeker who constantly escalates risks, always chasing a more intense, fleeting high. This relentless pursuit often leads to a diminished capacity for true enjoyment and a perpetual state of longing.

Temperance: A Virtue of Self-Mastery and Rational Control

Temperance (Greek: sophrosyne) is not asceticism; it is not the complete rejection of pleasure. Rather, it is the virtue of moderation, self-control, and prudence in relation to our bodily appetites and pleasures. It's about knowing how much, when, and why to indulge, guided by reason rather than impulse. A temperate person enjoys pleasure, but never allows pleasure to master them.

Key Characteristics of Temperance:

  • Self-Control: The ability to resist immediate gratification for a greater, long-term good.
  • Moderation: Finding the appropriate mean between excess and deficiency in all things related to physical appetites.
  • Rational Guidance: Subordinating impulsive desires to the dictates of reason and wisdom.
  • Inner Harmony: Achieving a state where the soul's different parts (reason, spirit, appetite) work in concert, rather than in conflict.

Virtue and Vice: The Dichotomy of Choice

The philosophical tradition often frames human action within the spectrum of virtue and vice. Where temperance stands as a virtue, its opposing vice is intemperance or self-indulgence. This dichotomy highlights the fundamental choice we face in how we engage with pleasure and pain.

Feature Temperance (Virtue) Intemperance (Vice)
Relationship to Desire Governs desires; reason is master. Enslaved by desires; appetite is master.
Goal Inner harmony, true flourishing (eudaimonia). Fleeting gratification, often leading to dissatisfaction.
Outcome Freedom, clarity, lasting well-being, peace. Addiction, regret, loss of control, suffering.
Perspective Long-term good, holistic well-being. Immediate pleasure, short-sighted, impulsive.

A Philosophical Journey Through the Great Books

The wisdom of temperance echoes throughout the Great Books of the Western World, providing a consistent argument for its indispensable role in a well-lived life.

Plato's Tripartite Soul and the Charioteer

In Plato's Republic, temperance is depicted as the harmonious agreement among the different parts of the soul: reason, spirit, and appetite. He famously uses the analogy of a charioteer (reason) guiding two horses—one noble and spirited, the other unruly and appetitive. Temperance is the successful management by the charioteer, ensuring that the appetites do not run wild and drag the soul off course. For Plato, an intemperate life is a chaotic one, where the baser desires usurp the rightful rule of reason, leading to internal discord and unhappiness. In the Gorgias, Socrates argues that an insatiable person is like a leaky jar, never truly filled or satisfied.

Aristotle's Golden Mean: The Right Amount

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, places temperance squarely within his doctrine of the Golden Mean. He argues that virtue lies in finding the appropriate middle ground between two extremes of vice. For temperance, this means avoiding both excessive indulgence (intemperance) and an unnatural insensitivity to pleasure (which he acknowledges is rare). A temperate person, according to Aristotle, "delights in the right things and at the right time." It's not about feeling no pleasure, but about feeling the right amount of pleasure, from the right sources, in the right way. Temperance, for Aristotle, is crucial for eudaimonia, or human flourishing, as it allows reason to guide our choices towards the good life.

The Stoic Path: Mastering Inner Fortitude

The Stoics, such as Seneca and Epictetus, approached temperance from a slightly different angle, emphasizing control over what is within our power and indifference to what is not. For them, excessive attachment to external pleasures makes us vulnerable to fortune and disturbs our inner peace. Desire for things outside our control is a source of suffering. Temperance, in the Stoic view, is about cultivating an inner fortress, an equanimity that is not swayed by the fleeting nature of pleasure or the sting of pain. It is about aligning oneself with reason and nature, finding contentment in what is, rather than chasing after what might be.

Cultivating Temperance in a Pleasure-Driven World

In a society often geared towards maximizing consumption and immediate gratification, the virtue of temperance might seem counter-cultural. Yet, its philosophical foundations offer a powerful argument for its enduring relevance. Cultivating temperance is a practice of self-awareness, discipline, and a conscious choice to prioritize long-term well-being over short-term impulses. It's about recognizing that true freedom comes not from having everything we desire, but from desiring things rightly. It’s a journey of self-mastery that promises a richer, more meaningful engagement with life's pleasures and pains.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting Plato's charioteer allegory, with a serene, cloaked figure representing reason guiding two horses—one spirited and controlled, the other wild and pulling against the reins—across a landscape towards a distant, harmonious city.)

The Rewards of a Temperate Life

Embracing temperance leads to a profound sense of inner peace and genuine contentment. It frees us from the tyranny of insatiable appetites, allowing us to appreciate pleasures more deeply when they are enjoyed in moderation. It enhances our judgment, strengthens our willpower, and ultimately contributes to a more virtuous and fulfilling existence. Rather than being enslaved by the pursuit of fleeting gratification, the temperate individual lives a life guided by reason, leading to lasting joy and true freedom.

YouTube Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Republic Tripartite Soul and Justice"

Share this post