The Steady Hand: Why Temperance is the Unsung Virtue of Political Leadership

In an age often characterized by extremes and instant gratification, the ancient virtue of temperance stands as an indispensable quality for effective political leadership. Drawing from the profound insights of the Great Books of the Western World, this article explores how temperance—the mastery of one's desires and impulses—is not merely a personal moral attribute but a fundamental pillar for stable government, preventing the excesses of vice and fostering the prudence necessary for wise governance.

For millennia, philosophers have grappled with the ideal qualities of those who govern. From Plato's philosopher-kings to the ethical frameworks of Aristotle, the consensus points to a leadership rooted in virtue. Among these cardinal virtues, temperance often receives less fanfare than courage or justice, yet its quiet strength is arguably the bedrock upon which all other political virtues are built. Without it, even the noblest intentions can devolve into detrimental vice, leading to instability, corruption, and ultimately, the erosion of public trust in government.

What is Temperance? A Philosophical Definition

At its core, temperance (from the Latin temperantia, meaning "moderation" or "restraint") is the virtue that enables an individual to exercise control over their appetites, desires, and passions. It is not about asceticism or the suppression of all desire, but rather about ordering these desires according to reason. As illuminated in Plato's Republic, temperance represents the harmonious ordering of the soul, where reason guides the spirited and appetitive parts. It is the self-mastery that prevents one from being enslaved by their impulses, whether they be for wealth, power, pleasure, or even anger.

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, further refines this concept, positioning temperance as a mean between two extremes of vice: insensibility (a deficiency of pleasure) and self-indulgence (an excess of pleasure). A temperate person knows how to enjoy life's goods appropriately, neither shunning them entirely nor succumbing to their allure indiscriminately.

(Image: A classical Greek marble bust depicting a serene, thoughtful figure with a calm expression, possibly a philosopher or statesman, symbolizing self-control and wisdom.)

Temperance vs. Vice: The Political Spectrum

The absence of temperance in leadership invariably leads to vice, manifesting in various destructive forms. Consider the political landscape:

  • Excessive Ambition: A leader driven by an unrestrained lust for power may resort to authoritarianism, suppressing dissent and undermining democratic institutions. This is a direct manifestation of intemperance regarding power.
  • Greed and Corruption: The insatiable desire for wealth, often seen in grand corruption scandals, stems from a lack of temperance regarding material possessions. Leaders succumb to the temptation of illicit gains, betraying their public trust.
  • Rashness and Impulsivity: Decisions made without careful consideration, driven by anger, fear, or a desire for immediate gratification, reflect a lack of emotional temperance. Such actions can lead to disastrous policies, both domestically and internationally.
  • Populist Demagoguery: While seemingly about connecting with the people, unchecked populism can be intemperate in its pursuit of popularity, leading to policies that pander to short-term desires rather than long-term societal well-being.

Conversely, a leader embodying temperance exhibits a measured approach, understanding the limits of their power and the importance of responsible stewardship.

The Interplay with Prudence

Temperance rarely acts in isolation; it is deeply intertwined with other cardinal virtues, most notably prudence (or practical wisdom). Prudence is the intellectual virtue that enables one to deliberate well about what is good and advantageous for oneself and for humanity, leading to right action.

How Temperance and Prudence Work Together:

  1. Clear Judgment: A temperate leader, free from the blinding fog of excessive desire or passion, can exercise prudence with a clear mind. They are not swayed by personal gain or emotional outbursts, allowing for rational assessment of complex situations.
  2. Long-Term Vision: Temperance fosters patience and foresight. Rather than succumbing to the immediate gratification of short-term political wins, a temperate leader, guided by prudence, will prioritize sustainable policies that benefit future generations.
  3. Measured Action: When a prudent course of action is determined, temperance provides the self-control necessary to execute it consistently, resisting temptations to deviate for personal or political expediency.
  4. Resource Allocation: In government, fiscal prudence dictates responsible spending. Temperance ensures that leaders resist the vice of lavish spending or the temptation to fund projects merely for personal prestige.

Without temperance, prudence can be distorted by self-interest; without prudence, temperance might lack direction, becoming mere abstention rather than purposeful restraint.

Historical Perspectives from the Great Books

The Great Books of the Western World offer invaluable insights into the enduring relevance of temperance in leadership:

  • Plato's Republic: Plato argues that a just state mirrors a just soul. Just as the soul achieves harmony when reason governs the appetites, so too does the state thrive when its rulers possess temperance. The "guardians" must demonstrate self-control to avoid corruption and ensure the common good. Temperance, for Plato, is the agreement between the naturally superior and inferior parts of the soul (or state) as to which should rule.
  • Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics: Aristotle's doctrine of the golden mean is foundational to understanding temperance. He posits that virtue lies in finding the appropriate middle ground between extremes. A temperate leader, therefore, is one who navigates the complexities of power, wealth, and public opinion with moderation, avoiding the vice of excess or deficiency. Practical wisdom (phronesis or prudence) is essential for discerning this mean.
  • Cicero's On Duties: The Roman orator and statesman emphasized decorum (propriety) and moderation as crucial for public life. He stressed that a leader's actions must be consistent with their dignity and the welfare of the state, requiring significant self-restraint.

Manifestations of Temperance in Government

The virtue of temperance translates into concrete actions and policies within government:

  • Fiscal Responsibility: Prudent budgeting, avoiding excessive debt, and making thoughtful decisions about public expenditure instead of succumbing to populist demands for unsustainable spending.
  • Judicial Restraint: A respect for the law and established processes, resisting the temptation to overreach or abuse executive or legislative powers.
  • Measured Diplomacy: Approaching international relations with calm deliberation, avoiding rash pronouncements or aggressive posturing that could escalate conflicts.
  • Ethical Conduct: Upholding high standards of personal and professional integrity, resisting temptations for personal gain, and demonstrating impartiality.
  • Emotional Resilience: Maintaining composure under pressure, making decisions based on facts and reason rather than anger, fear, or frustration.

The Dangers of Intemperance in Leadership

When leaders lack temperance, the consequences can be severe:

  • Corruption and Nepotism: Unchecked desires for wealth or power lead to the abuse of office for personal or familial gain, eroding public trust and diverting resources from public good.
  • Authoritarianism: The insatiable desire for control can lead to the suppression of dissent, the erosion of democratic norms, and the concentration of power in a single individual or party.
  • Policy Instability: Decisions driven by short-term political expediency, emotional reactions, or personal vendettas rather than prudence lead to inconsistent and ineffective governance.
  • Societal Division: Leaders who exploit divisions for personal gain, rather than seeking unity, exhibit a lack of temperance in their rhetoric and actions, exacerbating societal tensions.
  • Loss of Public Trust: A perception of intemperate behavior—whether it's lavish spending, erratic decision-making, or ethical lapses—undermines the legitimacy of government and fosters cynicism among citizens.

Cultivating Temperance in Leaders

While some may possess a natural inclination towards self-control, temperance is largely a cultivated virtue. It requires self-awareness, reflection, and a commitment to moral excellence. Education, mentorship, and a political culture that values integrity and restraint over ambition and excess are vital in fostering this essential quality in future leaders.

Conclusion

The virtue of temperance, though often understated, is a critical component of effective and ethical political leadership. As explored through the lens of the Great Books of the Western World, it is the self-mastery that allows leaders to govern not by impulse or personal desire, but by reason and for the common good. By restraining the vice of excess and cultivating a disposition for moderation, leaders can exercise prudence, ensure stable government, and build societies founded on justice and trust. In an increasingly complex world, the steady hand of temperance remains an enduring beacon for those who aspire to lead.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Republic Temperance Virtue, Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Golden Mean Politics"

Share this post