The Virtue of Temperance and Health: A Path to Flourishing

Temperance, often overshadowed by its more dramatic counterparts like courage or justice, stands as a foundational virtue, quietly orchestrating a harmonious existence. At its core, temperance is the virtue of moderation, self-control, and prudence in the face of desire and pleasure. This supporting article explores the profound connection between temperance and our overall health, revealing how this ancient wisdom, deeply embedded in the Great Books of the Western World, offers a timeless blueprint for a well-ordered body and mind, acting as both a preventative medicine and a key to genuine flourishing. We will examine temperance not merely as an absence of excess, but as an active cultivation of balance, a crucial distinction in the ongoing dance between virtue and vice.

The Ancient Wisdom of Self-Mastery

From the dialogues of Plato to the ethical treatises of Aristotle, the concept of temperance (sophrosyne in Greek) was central to the ideal of human excellence. For these thinkers, a temperate individual was one whose rational faculty held sway over their appetites and passions.

Plato's Tripartite Soul:
Plato, in his Republic, famously likened the soul to a charioteer (reason) guiding two horses: one noble and spirited (thumos), and one unruly and appetitive (epithumia). Temperance, in this schema, is the agreement between all parts of the soul about who should rule—reason. Without this internal harmony, the body and mind descend into chaos, driven by insatiable desires.

Aristotle's Golden Mean:
Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, defined temperance as a mean between two extremes: insensibility (a deficiency of pleasure) and self-indulgence or intemperance (an excess of pleasure). It's not about denying pleasure altogether, but about experiencing it in the right amount, at the right time, and for the right reasons. This careful calibration is what allows us to truly enjoy life's offerings without succumbing to their potential for harm.

  • Insensibility: A lack of appropriate response to pleasure, often leading to a diminished experience of life.
  • Temperance: The harmonious balance, allowing for appropriate enjoyment and self-control.
  • Self-Indulgence: An uncontrolled pursuit of pleasure, leading to excess and often detriment.

Temperance: The Virtue and Its Vices

The distinction between virtue and vice is nowhere more evident than in the realm of temperance. While temperance fosters order, health, and freedom, its opposing vices—intemperance and insensibility—lead to various forms of suffering and enslavement.

Virtue/Vice Description Impact on Health (Body & Mind)
Temperance Self-control, moderation, rational governance of desires. Promotes physical health, mental clarity, emotional stability, freedom.
Intemperance Excessive indulgence in pleasures (food, drink, sex, wealth, power). Leads to addiction, obesity, disease, anxiety, regret, loss of control.
Insensibility An extreme lack of engagement with pleasure, often leading to apathy or asceticism. Can result in depression, social isolation, anhedonia, physical neglect.

Intemperance, the more common and outwardly destructive vice, directly undermines our health. Gluttony burdens the body with disease; excessive drink impairs judgment and vital organs; unrestrained lust can lead to emotional turmoil and physical ailments. These are not merely moral failings but practical failures in self-management that have tangible, detrimental effects on our well-being.

Temperance as Preventative Medicine

Historically, the connection between philosophy and medicine was far more integrated than it is today. Ancient physicians, influenced by philosophical thought, understood that true health was not just the absence of disease, but a state of dynamic balance within the individual. Temperance was seen as a primary form of preventative medicine.

Consider the Hippocratic oath's emphasis on lifestyle and moderation. The advice to "let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food" inherently calls for temperate eating habits. A temperate person naturally avoids excesses that strain the body's systems, whether it's overeating, lack of sleep, or relentless pursuit of external gratification.

By exercising temperance, we are actively:

  • Regulating Diet: Choosing nourishing foods in appropriate quantities, avoiding harmful excesses.
  • Managing Consumption: Moderating intake of alcohol, caffeine, or other substances.
  • Balancing Activity: Ensuring sufficient rest and appropriate physical exercise, avoiding both sloth and overexertion.
  • Cultivating Emotional Control: Learning to manage anger, fear, and desire, which are often precursors to stress-related illnesses.

This proactive approach to health, rooted in self-discipline, minimizes the need for reactive medicine because it addresses the root causes of many ailments.

The Body: A Vessel to Be Stewarded

Philosophical traditions have long grappled with the nature of the body. While some traditions have viewed the body as a prison or a source of temptation to be transcended, the more balanced view, particularly in classical thought, sees it as an essential component of the human person—a vessel to be stewarded with care.

Temperance is the virtue that enables this proper stewardship. It teaches us to listen to the body's true needs rather than its fleeting desires. It's not about ascetic denial but about discerning what truly serves our long-term health and flourishing. A temperate person understands that the body is the instrument through which we engage with the world, learn, create, and experience joy. Neglecting or abusing it through intemperance cripples our capacity to live a full and meaningful life.

(Image: A serene, classical Greek statue, possibly of a philosopher or a contemplative figure, with a calm expression and balanced posture, perhaps holding a scroll or a simple vessel, symbolizing wisdom and moderation. The background is a soft, sunlit ancient academy or a tranquil garden.)

Cultivating Temperance in a Modern World

In an age of instant gratification and pervasive advertising that constantly encourages excess, the cultivation of temperance is more challenging—and perhaps more critical—than ever. From endless scrolling on digital devices to readily available unhealthy foods, the temptations for intemperance are legion.

Practical steps towards temperance include:

  • Mindful Consumption: Paying attention to what and how much we consume, be it food, media, or material goods.
  • Setting Boundaries: Establishing clear limits for activities that can easily become excessive.
  • Practicing Delayed Gratification: Learning to resist immediate urges for greater long-term benefit.
  • Reflecting on Desires: Understanding the true source of our desires and whether they align with our deeper values.

By consciously choosing moderation, we reclaim agency over our lives, moving from being slaves to our appetites to masters of our own destiny.

Conclusion: A Foundation for Flourishing

The virtue of temperance, as illuminated by the Great Books of the Western World, is far more than mere abstention; it is an active, rational engagement with our desires, leading to self-mastery and inner peace. Its profound impact on our body and mind makes it an indispensable component of health, acting as a powerful preventative medicine against the myriad ills born of excess. In a world often driven by instant gratification and unchecked appetite, embracing temperance is not a step backward into austerity, but a courageous leap forward into a life of genuine freedom, balance, and enduring well-being. It is the quiet architect of flourishing, allowing us to build a life that is not just long, but truly good.

YouTube:

  1. "Aristotle's Ethics: The Golden Mean and Virtue Theory"
  2. "Plato's Republic: The Tripartite Soul Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Virtue of Temperance and Health philosophy"

Share this post