The Virtue of Temperance and Health and Temperance

The Measured Life: Temperance, Health, and the Flourishing Body

Summary: Temperance as the Foundation of Well-being

This article explores the classical virtue of temperance, not merely as an antiquated moral concept, but as a foundational principle for holistic health and well-being. Drawing from the wisdom of the Great Books of the Western World, we examine how self-mastery over bodily appetites—a balance between virtue and vice—is inextricably linked to physical vitality, preventative medicine, and the flourishing of the body. Temperance, understood as the intelligent regulation of desires, emerges as a timeless guide for living a full and healthy life.

Defining Temperance: A Virtue of Self-Mastery

To speak of temperance is to delve into one of the four cardinal virtues, a cornerstone of ancient Greek philosophy and subsequent Western thought. It is not, as often misunderstood, a call to asceticism or joyless abstinence. Rather, temperance is the virtue of moderation, of self-control, particularly concerning the pleasures of the body—food, drink, and sensual gratification. It is the ability to govern one's desires and appetites with reason, ensuring they serve our higher good rather than enslaving us.

Beyond Abstinence: The Golden Mean

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, eloquently articulated temperance as a "mean" between two extremes. On one side lies intemperance (excess), a vice characterized by an insatiable pursuit of pleasure, leading to indulgence and harm. On the other, though less common, is a kind of "insensibility" (deficiency), a vice of being completely unresponsive to natural and healthy pleasures. Temperance, therefore, is not about denying pleasure but about experiencing it in the right measure, at the right time, and for the right reasons. It is the intelligent application of limits.

Virtue and Vice: The Spectrum of Desire

Understanding temperance requires placing it within the broader framework of virtue and vice. Every human desire, when left unchecked, can lead to vice. Hunger becomes gluttony; thirst, drunkenness; natural attraction, lust. Temperance acts as the internal governor, allowing us to enjoy the good things of life without allowing them to master us. It is the rational part of the soul asserting its rightful authority over the appetitive part, leading to inner harmony and external balance.

The Body's Wisdom: Temperance and Physical Health

The connection between temperance and the body's health is profound and was deeply understood by ancient thinkers. They recognized that an undisciplined pursuit of bodily pleasures inevitably leads to physical ailments and a diminished quality of life.

Appetites, Excess, and Deficiency

Consider the most fundamental bodily appetites: hunger and thirst. While essential for survival, their unregulated indulgence can be detrimental. Excessive eating leads to obesity, digestive issues, and a host of chronic diseases. Excessive drinking damages the liver, impairs cognitive function, and contributes to addiction. Temperance, by guiding us to eat when hungry and stop when satisfied, to drink in moderation, and to seek proper rest, directly supports the body's natural equilibrium.

The Ancient Connection to Medicine

Long before modern pharmacology, ancient medicine often focused on diet, lifestyle, and balance—principles intrinsically linked to temperance. Hippocrates, often considered the father of Western medicine, emphasized the importance of a balanced regimen and moderation in all things. The idea that "food is medicine" or "let thy food be thy medicine" implies a careful, temperate approach to consumption. An intemperate lifestyle was seen not just as a moral failing but as a direct cause of illness. The temperate person, by exercising self-control over their physical inputs and outputs, engages in a form of preventative medicine, nurturing their body to operate optimally.

Historical Echoes: Temperance in the Great Books

The concept of temperance resonates throughout the Great Books of the Western World, underscoring its enduring significance across millennia.

From Plato's Republic to Aristotle's Ethics

Plato, in his Republic, posits temperance as a virtue crucial not only for the individual but for the harmonious functioning of the state. He saw it as a kind of agreement or concord between the different parts of the soul—the rational, the spirited, and the appetitive—each fulfilling its proper role. For Plato, a temperate individual possesses inner order, a prerequisite for justice and true freedom. Aristotle, as mentioned, refined this understanding, placing temperance firmly within his doctrine of the golden mean, making it a practical virtue attainable through habit and choice.

The Stoic Perspective

Later, the Stoics further championed self-control and moderation, viewing temperance as essential for tranquility and resilience in the face of life's challenges. For them, mastering one's desires and passions was paramount to achieving ataraxia (freedom from disturbance) and living in accordance with nature. Their emphasis on rational self-governance deeply aligns with the core tenets of temperance, extending its application beyond mere physical pleasures to emotional regulation.

(Image: A classical Greek marble bust depicting a calm, composed face with serene features, possibly of a philosopher or deity, symbolizing self-control and inner peace. The background is subtly textured, evoking ancient wisdom.)

Practical Temperance: Cultivating a Healthy Life

Embracing temperance in our daily lives is not about austerity, but about conscious choice and mindful living. It's a continuous practice that yields profound benefits for our physical and mental health.

Mindful Consumption: Food and Drink

Eat when hungry, stop when full: Listen to your body's signals rather than external cues or emotional urges.
Quality over quantity: Prioritize nourishing, wholesome foods in appropriate portions.
Mindful drinking: Enjoy alcoholic beverages in moderation, or choose non-alcoholic alternatives.
Savoring: Experience food and drink fully, appreciating flavors and textures, rather than rushing.

Rest and Activity: The Rhythms of the Body

Temperance extends beyond consumption to how we manage our energy and physical activity. It calls for a balanced approach to:

Sleep: Ensuring adequate rest without excessive idleness.
Exercise: Engaging in regular physical activity without pushing the body to injury or exhaustion.
Leisure: Enjoying recreation and relaxation in moderation, balancing it with productive work.

Conclusion: The Enduring Relevance of a Balanced Life

The virtue of temperance, as illuminated by the Great Books of the Western World, offers more than just a moral imperative; it provides a practical pathway to robust health and a flourishing life. By understanding and practicing self-mastery over our bodily appetites—navigating the delicate balance between virtue and vice—we engage in a profound form of preventative medicine. It allows us to honor our body as a vessel for a well-lived life, rather than a source of endless gratification. In an age of excess and instant gratification, the ancient wisdom of temperance remains an indispensable guide to cultivating a truly healthy, balanced, and meaningful existence.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Temperance explained""