The Virtue of Temperance and Health: A Classical Perspective
Summary: In an age often defined by excess and instant gratification, the ancient virtue of Temperance offers a timeless philosophical framework for understanding and achieving true health. This article explores how Temperance, rooted in classical thought from the Great Books of the Western World, serves not merely as a call for moderation, but as a foundational Virtue essential for the harmonious flourishing of the Body and mind, acting as a profound form of philosophical Medicine against the debilitating effects of Vice.
The Enduring Wisdom of Temperance: A Philosophical Prescription for Well-being
From the sun-drenched stoas of ancient Greece to the quiet studies of medieval scholars, the concept of Temperance (or sophrosyne in Greek) has resonated as a cornerstone of human excellence. It is more than just 'being moderate'; it is a profound state of self-mastery, a rational governance over one's desires and appetites. For those of us who delve into the Great Books of the Western World, the recurring emphasis on this Virtue reveals a deep understanding of human nature and the prerequisites for a life well-lived. In a world increasingly prone to extremes, understanding Temperance offers a vital philosophical lens through which to view our own health and well-being.
Temperance stands as a bulwark against the forces of Vice, which, unchecked, can erode not only our moral character but also our physical vitality. It is a concept that bridges the ethical and the biological, demonstrating how our choices, governed by reason or swayed by impulse, directly impact the intricate balance within the Body.
Defining Temperance: The Harmony of Self-Control
To truly grasp Temperance, we must look beyond its superficial interpretations. Plato, in his Republic, posits sophrosyne as a harmony, a beautiful agreement between the better and worse parts of the soul, where reason (the ruling part) guides the spirited and appetitive elements. Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, describes it as a mean concerning pleasures and pains, particularly those related to touch and taste – the fundamental bodily appetites.
It is the intelligent restraint, the knowing when and how much, that distinguishes Temperance from mere abstinence or asceticism. It is not the denial of pleasure, but its proper ordering, ensuring that desires serve the higher goals of reason and human flourishing rather than dictating them. The Vice of excess, such as gluttony or profligacy, and the Vice of deficiency, such as insensitivity or apathy, both represent a failure of Temperance.
Key Characteristics of Temperance:
- Self-Mastery: The ability of reason to govern desires and impulses.
- Harmony: An inner balance between the soul's various parts.
- Rational Ordering: Not denial, but the proper placement of pleasures and pains.
- The Golden Mean: Avoiding both excess and deficiency in appetites.
The Body as a Temple: Temperance as Philosophical Medicine
The ancient philosophers understood that the Body is not separate from the mind or soul, but an integral component of the human person. Consequently, the health of the Body is inextricably linked to the cultivation of Virtue. Temperance, in this context, acts as a form of philosophical Medicine, guiding us in the care of our physical selves.
Consider our relationship with food. Intemperance manifests as overeating, consumption of unhealthy foods, or neglecting proper nutrition – all Vices that lead to bodily ailments. A temperate individual, however, approaches eating with mindfulness, recognizing the Body's needs for nourishment and energy, not merely for fleeting pleasure. This isn't about rigid diets, but about a sustained, rational engagement with what we consume.
(Image: A classical Greek statue of a serene, well-proportioned figure, perhaps Hygieia or a similar deity, holding a staff entwined with a snake or a bowl, symbolizing health and balance, set against a backdrop of ancient philosophical texts.)
Similarly, Temperance extends to other bodily functions:
- Sleep: Too little sleep leaves the Body depleted; too much can lead to lethargy. Temperance guides us to adequate rest for rejuvenation.
- Exercise: A temperate approach avoids both sloth (deficiency) and obsessive overtraining (excess), seeking a balanced regimen that strengthens and maintains the Body's capabilities.
- Sensory Pleasures: Whether it's the enjoyment of music, art, or even more fundamental physical comforts, Temperance ensures these enhance life without becoming masters of it.
The ancients, particularly figures like Galen whose works were foundational for centuries and are included in the Great Books, viewed Medicine holistically, often linking physical health to moral and psychological states. Temperance is the internal physician, constantly striving for a healthy equilibrium within us.
Virtue and Vice: The Health Continuum
The relationship between Virtue and Vice and health is not merely metaphorical; it is deeply practical. When we succumb to Vice in our appetites, the consequences are tangible:
| Vice Manifestation | Impact on Health (Body) | Philosophical Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Gluttony | Obesity, diabetes, heart disease, digestive issues. | Loss of self-control; appetites rule reason. |
| Lust/Promiscuity | STIs, emotional distress, psychological instability. | Disordered desire; pursuit of fleeting pleasure over enduring well-being. |
| Sloth/Idleness | Muscle atrophy, cardiovascular weakness, mental stagnation, depression. | Neglect of the body's needs and capabilities; evasion of responsibility. |
| Intoxication | Liver damage, addiction, cognitive impairment, impaired judgment. | Surrender of reason; deliberate harm to the body and mind. |
Conversely, cultivating Temperance leads to a flourishing state, where the Body functions optimally, supporting the mind's clarity and the soul's tranquility. It is the foundation for a life of vigor and resilience, allowing us to engage fully with the world and pursue higher intellectual and spiritual goods.
Cultivating Temperance in a World of Excess
In our modern society, where instant gratification is often the norm and advertising constantly appeals to our basest desires, cultivating Temperance requires conscious effort and philosophical grounding. It begins with self-awareness, a clear-eyed assessment of our habits and desires.
Steps to Embrace Temperance:
- Self-Reflection: Regularly examine your consumption habits – food, media, leisure. Are they serving your long-term well-being or momentary impulses?
- Mindful Consumption: Practice intentionality in eating, drinking, and entertainment. Savor experiences rather than merely consuming them.
- Habit Formation: Aristotle emphasized the importance of habituation. Start small: choose to eat one healthy meal, take a short walk, or limit screen time. Consistency builds character.
- Reason as Guide: Engage your rational faculty. Ask yourself: "Is this choice truly beneficial for my Body and mind, or is it merely a fleeting pleasure that will lead to future discomfort or regret?"
- Community and Example: Seek out communities or individuals who embody temperate living. Their example can provide inspiration and support.
Temperance is not about deprivation, but about liberation – liberation from the tyranny of unexamined desires. It is the freedom to choose well, to live deliberately, and to nurture the Body as an essential partner in a life of reason and purpose.
Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of a Balanced Life
The wisdom enshrined in the Great Books of the Western World consistently reminds us that true health extends beyond the absence of disease. It encompasses a holistic well-being where the Body, mind, and soul are in harmonious alignment. The Virtue of Temperance is the key to this alignment, acting as a powerful philosophical Medicine that guides us away from the destructive paths of Vice and towards a life of balance, self-mastery, and enduring vitality. By embracing Temperance, we not only safeguard our physical health but also cultivate the inner strength and clarity necessary to live a truly flourishing human life.
YouTube: "Plato temperance sophrosyne"
YouTube: "Aristotle virtue ethics health"
📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics
Video by: The School of Life
💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Virtue of Temperance and Health philosophy"