The Universal Principle of Desire: A Quest for Understanding

At the very core of human experience, beneath the myriad choices and actions that define our lives, lies a fundamental, pervasive force: desire. This article explores "The Universal Principle of Desire," positing it not merely as a collection of individual whims, but as a foundational principle that underpins all motivation, aspiration, and striving. Drawing insights from the Great Books of the Western World, we will delve into how philosophers have grappled with desire's nature, its universal manifestations versus its particular expressions, and its intricate relationship with the will—the faculty through which we aim to fulfill our deepest yearnings. Understanding this principle offers a profound lens through which to view ethics, human nature, and the very meaning of existence.

Desire: The Engine of Existence

What propels us forward? What ignites our passion, fuels our ambition, and even stirs our most basic needs? The answer, in its broadest sense, is desire. From the simplest craving for sustenance to the most complex yearning for truth, beauty, or justice, desire acts as the relentless engine of human existence. It is the initial spark, the internal gravitational pull that sets us on a course.

Philosophers across millennia have recognized this intrinsic drive. Plato, in works like The Symposium, speaks of Eros (desire) as a divine force that moves us from the love of particular beautiful bodies to the love of all beauty, and ultimately to the love of the Forms themselves—the ultimate Good. Aristotle, too, grounds human action in a desire for eudaimonia, or flourishing, seeing all particular desires as steps towards this ultimate, universal end. These ancient thinkers understood that while the objects of our desires might be countless and varied, the underlying impulse to seek something perceived as good or lacking is a shared, universal human trait.

(Image: A classical sculpture of Eros or Cupid, wings outstretched, aiming an arrow. The figure is depicted with a thoughtful, almost yearning expression, surrounded by subtle allegorical elements suggesting human aspiration and the pursuit of ideal forms, rendered in soft, warm light.)

The Interplay of Universal and Particular Desires

The concept of a Universal Principle of Desire doesn't negate the vast spectrum of individual, particular desires we experience daily. Instead, it suggests an underlying structure or framework within which these specifics operate. Think of it as a river: the universal principle is the unceasing flow of water, while particular desires are the individual eddies, currents, and tributaries that form within it, each unique yet part of the larger movement.

  • Universal: The inherent human drive towards well-being, happiness, knowledge, connection, or meaning. This desire often remains implicit, guiding our broader life choices.
  • Particular: The specific objects, experiences, or states of affairs we believe will satisfy that universal craving. This could be a desire for a new car, a specific career, a loving relationship, or a delicious meal.

Immanuel Kant, for instance, distinguished between inclinations (particular desires based on sensory experience or personal preference) and the moral law (a universal, rational principle that dictates duty). While inclinations might prompt us to act for personal gain, the will, guided by reason, can align itself with a universal moral principle, overriding particular desires for the sake of duty. This highlights the tension and interaction between the pervasive force of desire and the rational capacity to direct it.

From Desire to Will: The Act of Choice

If desire is the engine, then the will is the steering wheel—or perhaps, the navigator. Desire identifies what is wanted; the will determines whether and how to pursue it. This relationship is a cornerstone of philosophical inquiry, particularly within the Great Books.

For Augustine, the will is paramount, intimately tied to love and the direction of the soul towards God or away from Him. He saw the will as the driving force behind moral action, capable of choosing between good and evil, thereby shaping one's destiny. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, viewed the will as a rational appetite, guided by the intellect. We desire the good, and our intellect presents various goods to the will, which then chooses.

Later, philosophers like Baruch Spinoza presented a more deterministic view, where the will is not a separate faculty but the mind's affirmation of its desires (or conatus, its striving to persevere in its being). Arthur Schopenhauer, however, elevated the Will to a blind, irrational, cosmic force underlying all reality, with individual desires merely its particular manifestations. Friedrich Nietzsche, in his concept of the "Will to Power," saw desire and will as inextricably linked in a fundamental drive towards growth, overcoming, and self-mastery.

The common thread across these diverse perspectives is the recognition that the transition from a mere want to a deliberate action involves the faculty of the will. It is through the will that a universal principle of desire translates into concrete, particular choices, shaping not only our individual lives but also the collective human story.

Philosophical Perspectives on Desire and Will

The journey through the Great Books reveals a rich tapestry of thought on desire and will. Here’s a brief overview of how some key thinkers have approached this fundamental principle:

Philosopher Key Concept of Desire Role of Will Universal/Particular Link
Plato Eros (desire for beauty/good), striving for Forms Intellect guides the will towards the Good Universal desire for the Good/Forms manifests in particular attractions to beauty.
Aristotle Telos (purpose), desire for Eudaimonia Rational choice (prohairesis) directs actions towards the ultimate good All particular desires ultimately aim at the universal good of human flourishing (eudaimonia).
Augustine Love, directed towards God or self Central to moral choice, capable of choosing good or evil; tied to grace Universal desire for blessedness can be directed by the will towards particular, often sinful, earthly goods.
Aquinas Rational appetite, seeking the good Rational faculty that chooses among goods presented by the intellect Universal desire for ultimate good (God) is served by the will choosing particular goods that align with reason.
Spinoza Conatus (striving to persevere in being) Not a free faculty; the mind's affirmation of its desires Universal striving for self-preservation manifests in particular desires for things that enhance one's power of acting.
Kant Inclinations (empirical desires) Practical Reason, capable of acting from duty regardless of inclination Universal moral law (duty) can override particular desires, guiding the will towards universalizability.
Nietzsche Will to Power (fundamental drive to overcome) Embodiment of the will to power, asserting and creating values The universal "Will to Power" expresses itself through particular desires for strength, mastery, and self-overcoming.

Conclusion: The Enduring Quest

The Universal Principle of Desire, as illuminated by the profound insights of the Great Books, is far more than a simple psychological observation. It is a cornerstone of metaphysics, ethics, and our understanding of human nature. From Plato's ascent to the Forms to Nietzsche's assertion of the Will to Power, philosophers have consistently sought to understand this fundamental impetus that propels us.

Recognizing this principle allows us to see beyond the surface of our immediate wants and appreciate the deeper, often unconscious, drives that shape our character and civilization. It challenges us to reflect on how our will directs these desires—whether towards fleeting pleasures, destructive ends, or noble aspirations for truth, beauty, and justice. The ongoing philosophical quest to understand desire and its relationship to will remains as vital today as it was in ancient Athens, continually inviting us to examine the very essence of what it means to be human.

YouTube: "Plato Symposium desire philosophy explained"
YouTube: "Nietzsche Will to Power explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Universal Principle of Desire philosophy"

Share this post