The Universal Principle of Desire and Universal and Particular

The Universal Principle of Desire: A Fundamental Human Drive

Understanding the intricate tapestry of human motivation often leads us back to a single, powerful thread: desire. Far from being a mere fleeting want, philosophical inquiry, particularly within the rich tradition of the Great Books of the Western World, reveals desire as a profound and perhaps universal principle underlying all sentient action and striving. This article delves into the philosophical concept of a universal principle of desire, exploring how this fundamental drive manifests in both universal and particular ways, and its deep connection to the Will.

What is the Principle of Desire?

At its core, a principle implies a fundamental truth, a primary law or doctrine that serves as a basis for other truths. When we speak of a "principle of desire," we are positing that there is an inherent, pervasive force within living beings that propels them towards something perceived as good, beneficial, or fulfilling. It’s not just about wanting a cup of coffee; it's about the deeper impulse that drives us towards comfort, pleasure, or even the pursuit of knowledge itself.

For millennia, philosophers have grappled with this concept:

Plato saw desire (epithymia) as one of the three parts of the soul, driving us towards appetites but also, ideally, towards the Good.
Aristotle linked desire to telos, the inherent purpose or end towards which all things strive, including human flourishing (eudaimonia).
Spinoza famously articulated conatus, the inherent drive of every being to persevere in its own being, which is essentially a form of desire.

This principle suggests that to exist is, in some fundamental sense, to desire. It’s the engine of change, the impetus for growth, and the silent architect of our aspirations.

Universal and Particular Manifestations

The idea of a universal principle of desire doesn't negate the vast diversity of individual wants. Rather, it suggests an underlying pattern to these myriad expressions. Think of it like gravity: a universal principle, yet it manifests differently for an apple falling from a tree versus a planet orbiting a star.

Universal Aspects of Desire:

Survival and Self-Preservation: The most basic and undeniable desire, seen across all species.
Flourishing/Well-being: A drive towards health, comfort, and a good life, however defined.
Knowledge/Understanding: The innate curiosity that propels scientific inquiry and philosophical exploration.
Connection/Belonging: The desire for social bonds, love, and community.
Meaning/Purpose: The search for significance beyond mere existence.

These universal categories provide a framework for understanding the more specific, particular desires that shape our daily lives. My desire for a specific career, for instance, might be a particular manifestation of a universal desire for purpose, recognition, or financial security. Your desire for a philosophical discussion might stem from a universal drive for knowledge and connection.

(Image: A detailed classical painting depicting various allegorical figures representing different human desires – perhaps a figure reaching for a distant star (ambition), another gazing at a mirror (vanity), one embracing a loved one (affection), and another contemplating a scroll (wisdom), all subtly connected by an underlying golden thread or light emanating from a central, abstract source, symbolizing the unifying principle of desire.)

Desire, Will, and Action

The relationship between desire and Will is a cornerstone of philosophical psychology and ethics. Is the Will merely the executive arm of desire, or does it possess an independent capacity to choose against desire?

Desire as Precursor to Will: Many philosophers, from ancient Greeks to figures like Schopenhauer, have argued that desire (or a fundamental "Will to Live" or "Will to Power") is primary. Our Will, in this view, is often seen as the conscious or unconscious striving to fulfill these desires. Schopenhauer, for example, saw the Will as a blind, irrational cosmic force manifesting in all phenomena, with individual desires being its particular expressions.
Will as Arbiter of Desire: In contrast, thinkers like Immanuel Kant emphasized the autonomy of the Will. For Kant, true moral action doesn't stem from inclination or desire (which he saw as heteronomous, or determined by external forces), but from a rational Will acting out of duty. Here, the Will can transcend particular desires, choosing to act according to universal moral laws.
Augustine wrestled with the interplay of desire and free will, particularly in the context of sin and redemption. He explored how corrupted desires could lead the Will astray, yet also posited the Will's capacity for choosing the good with divine grace.

This dynamic interplay highlights a crucial aspect of human experience: we are not simply slaves to our desires, but possess a faculty—the Will—that can direct, restrain, or even cultivate them.

Philosophical Perspectives on Desire (A Brief Overview)

Philosopher/Tradition	Core Concept of Desire	Relationship to Will/Action	Key Idea
Plato	Epithymia (appetitive desire), Thumos (spirited desire), all ideally guided by Reason towards the Good.	Reason (logos) should govern desires and direct the Will.	Desire for the Beautiful and the Good is ultimately a desire for Forms.
Aristotle	Appetites, passions, wishes; tied to telos (purpose) and eudaimonia (flourishing).	Rational choice (prohairesis) directs desire towards virtuous action.	Desire is natural and good when directed towards human flourishing.
Aquinas	Natural appetites (concupiscible, irascible); desire for beatific vision (God).	Intellect apprehends the good; Will moves towards it.	Ultimate desire is for God, the perfect good.
Spinoza	Conatus: the striving to persevere in one's being; joy and sorrow as expressions of fulfilled/frustrated conatus.	The Will is identical with desire; no free will in a traditional sense.	Everything endeavors to persist in its own being.
Kant	Inclinations; distinct from moral duty.	Moral Will acts independently of desire, solely from duty.	Moral action must be free from the determination of desire.
Schopenhauer	Manifestation of the blind, irrational "Will to Live."	The Will is primary; intellect and individual desires are its phenomena.	Desire is endless suffering; liberation comes from transcending the Will.
Nietzsche	"Will to Power": the fundamental drive to overcome, grow, and assert oneself.	The Will creates values and meaning; desire is an expression of this Will.	A life-affirming embrace of desire and striving for self-overcoming.

The Challenge of Universality

While the concept of a universal principle of desire offers a powerful lens through which to view human motivation, it is not without its challenges. Critics might argue that "desire" is too broad a term, or that cultural conditioning shapes our desires so profoundly that a truly universal principle becomes elusive.

However, the strength of the "universal principle" lies not in dictating what we should desire, but in recognizing the act of desiring itself as a fundamental constant. The object of desire may change across cultures and individuals, but the underlying impulse to strive, to seek, to move towards a perceived good, remains a deeply rooted aspect of the human (and indeed, animal) condition. It is this persistent, inherent drive that unites the philosopher's quest for truth with the hungry person's search for food.

Conclusion: The Enduring Impulse

The exploration of "The Universal Principle of Desire" from the vantage point of the Great Books reveals a profound philosophical insight: that desire is not merely an incidental aspect of human experience, but a fundamental engine of existence. From Plato's ascent to the Good to Nietzsche's Will to Power, the Western tradition continually returns to this primal impulse. By understanding desire as a universal principle that manifests in particular ways, and by examining its intricate relationship with the Will, we gain a deeper appreciation for the forces that shape our actions, our societies, and our very quest for meaning. It is the enduring impulse that compels us forward, forever seeking, forever striving.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Philosophical Theories of Desire Explained""