The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin): Wrestling with Divine Justice and Human Imperfection

The existence of evil in a world ostensibly governed by an all-powerful, all-knowing, and all-good God presents one of the most enduring and unsettling paradoxes in human thought. This is the heart of the Theological Problem of Evil, a formidable challenge to faith and reason that has occupied philosophers and theologians for millennia. At its core, this problem questions how a benevolent God could permit suffering, injustice, and moral depravity. This pillar page delves specifically into the aspect of moral evil, which Theology often identifies with Sin—a deliberate transgression against divine will. We will explore how thinkers, particularly those within the tradition of the Great Books of the Western World, have grappled with reconciling God's attributes with the pervasive reality of Sin and its consequences, ultimately seeking to understand the nature of Good and Evil itself.

The Unsettling Paradox: Defining The Problem of Evil

Let us begin with a clear articulation of the dilemma. The Problem of Evil, often framed as a logical inconsistency, can be summarized thus:

  1. If God is omnibenevolent (all-good), He would desire to prevent all evil.
  2. If God is omnipotent (all-powerful), He would be able to prevent all evil.
  3. If God is omniscient (all-knowing), He would know how to prevent all evil.
  4. Yet, evil exists.

Therefore, it seems to logically follow that God cannot possess all three of these attributes simultaneously. This challenge gives rise to theodicy, the branch of theology and philosophy that attempts to justify God's justice and goodness in the face of evil.

It is crucial to distinguish between two primary categories of evil:

  • Natural Evil: Suffering caused by natural phenomena, such as earthquakes, floods, diseases, or famines. These are not directly attributable to human will.
  • Moral Evil: Suffering or wrongdoing that results from the free choices and actions of moral agents (i.e., humans). This category is where Sin primarily resides.

While both pose significant challenges, our focus here is on Sin as the wellspring of moral evil, making the problem intensely personal and theological.

Sin: The Theological Root of Moral Evil

From a theological perspective, Sin is far more than a mere mistake or an unfortunate event. It is a deliberate act of disobedience or defiance against the divine will, a turning away from God. It implies a moral failing, a corruption of the individual's relationship with their Creator and, by extension, with creation itself.

The concept of Original Sin, most famously articulated by St. Augustine of Hippo, provides a foundational theological explanation for the pervasive nature of moral evil. Augustine, in works like Confessions and City of God (cornerstones of the Great Books tradition), posited that humanity inherited a fallen nature from Adam and Eve's first disobedience in the Garden of Eden. This act of Sin introduced not only death but also a universal predisposition towards evil, corrupting human will and reason.

Key Characteristics of Sin (Theological Perspective):

  • Transgression: An act that violates God's law or commands.
  • Alienation: Separates humanity from God, self, and others.
  • Corruption: Taints human nature, leading to a propensity for further evil.
  • Responsibility: Implies human agency and accountability for choices.

(Image: A Renaissance painting depicting Adam and Eve's expulsion from the Garden of Eden, with serpents and angelic figures, symbolizing the origin of sin and its immediate consequence.)

Great Minds, Grand Theodicies: Responses to Sin and Suffering

Throughout history, some of the greatest minds have grappled with the Problem of Evil and the concept of Sin. Drawing from the Great Books, we can observe several prominent theological responses:

1. Augustine of Hippo: Evil as Privation and the Free Will Defense

Augustine's most influential contribution to theodicy is his argument that evil is not a substance created by God, but rather a privation of good (privatio boni). Just as darkness is the absence of light, evil is the absence or corruption of the good that ought to be present. God, being supremely good, creates only good things. Sin, therefore, arises from the misuse of free will by created beings. Angels and humans were given the magnificent gift of free will, allowing them to choose Good and Evil. Their choice to turn away from God's perfect order, to love lesser goods more than the supreme Good, is the origin of moral evil. God permits this freedom, for without it, true love, virtue, and moral responsibility would be impossible.

2. Thomas Aquinas: The Permitted Evil for a Greater Good

St. Thomas Aquinas, building upon Augustinian thought in his Summa Theologica, affirmed that God is not the author of evil. He argued that God permits evil not because He wills it, but because He can bring a greater good out of it. The existence of evil, including Sin, allows for the manifestation of divine justice, mercy, and wisdom. For example, without injustice, there could be no justice; without suffering, no compassion. The universe, Aquinas suggested, is more perfect for containing both good and evil, as it allows for a wider range of perfections and virtues to emerge.

3. Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: The Best of All Possible Worlds

In his Theodicy, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz proposed that God, being perfectly rational and good, would have chosen the "best of all possible worlds" to create from an infinite number of possibilities. This world, despite its imperfections and the presence of Sin, contains the optimal balance of good over evil, leading to the greatest overall perfection. Any other world, with less evil, would necessarily be less good in some other, perhaps hidden, way. The evil of Sin, in this view, is a necessary byproduct or component of the most perfect possible cosmic order.

4. The Book of Job: A Narrative of Divine Mystery

While not a systematic philosophical treatise, the biblical Book of Job (a cornerstone of Western literature) offers a profound exploration of suffering and divine justice. Job, a righteous man, suffers immense loss and pain, prompting him and his friends to question God's justice. The narrative ultimately doesn't provide a clear, logical explanation for Job's suffering or the presence of evil. Instead, it emphasizes the inscrutability of God's ways and the limitations of human understanding. Job's experience suggests that sometimes, the answer to the Problem of Evil lies beyond human comprehension, demanding faith and trust in divine wisdom rather than a full rational explanation.

Enduring Debates and Modern Reconsiderations

Despite these profound theological frameworks, the Problem of Evil, especially concerning Sin, continues to provoke debate.

  • The Free Will Defense Revisited: While powerful, critics question whether the gift of free will truly necessitates the immense suffering caused by Sin. Could an omnipotent God not create beings with free will who always choose the good, or at least minimize gratuitous evil?
  • The Problem of Gratuitous Evil: Even if some evil is necessary for a greater good, the sheer quantity and intensity of suffering caused by Sin—genocides, torture, systemic oppression—seems disproportionate to any conceivable benefit. Does God's permission of such widespread moral depravity truly align with His infinite benevolence?
  • The Challenge of Divine Foreknowledge: If God is omniscient, He knows who will Sin before they are even created. Does this foreknowledge compromise human free will, or does it imply God knowingly creates individuals destined for moral evil and its consequences?

These questions highlight the ongoing tension between human reason's demand for logical consistency and faith's embrace of divine mystery.

Conclusion: The Unfolding Dialogue

The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin) remains one of the most profound and persistent challenges to belief in an all-good, all-powerful God. From Augustine's concept of evil as privation and the free will defense, to Aquinas's notion of permitted evil for a greater good, and Leibniz's "best of all possible worlds," the Great Books of the Western World offer a rich tapestry of intellectual and spiritual struggle.

There are no easy answers, but the journey of grappling with these questions deepens our understanding of Theology, human nature, and the intricate relationship between Good and Evil. As Benjamin Richmond, I find that this ongoing dialogue is not a sign of weakness in faith, but rather a testament to the human spirit's relentless quest for meaning, justice, and truth in a complex world. The enduring question of why Sin exists and how it fits into a divinely ordered universe continues to shape our ethical frameworks, our spiritual paths, and our very definition of what it means to be human.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Augustine Problem of Evil Free Will""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Theodicy Leibniz Aquinas""

Share this post