The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin): Wrestling with God, Good, and Human Folly

The existence of suffering and moral transgression has long been a profound challenge to faith, perplexing theologians and philosophers alike. How can a benevolent, all-powerful God exist in a world rife with evil? While natural disasters and disease pose one facet of this cosmic riddle, the Theological Problem of Evil takes on a unique and particularly thorny dimension when confronted with Sin. Sin, as a deliberate act of moral evil, confronts us directly with human agency and responsibility, forcing a deeper inquiry into the nature of God, Good and Evil, and the very fabric of creation.

This pillar page delves into the theological problem of evil as it pertains specifically to sin. We will explore its classical formulations, examine attempts to reconcile divine attributes with human moral failure, and consider the enduring implications for our understanding of God, humanity, and the perennial struggle between good and evil.

Defining the Theological Problem of Evil

At its heart, the theological problem of evil is a logical dilemma often attributed to Epicurus and later refined by David Hume:

  • If God is all-good (omnibenevolent), He would want to prevent all evil.
  • If God is all-powerful (omnipotent), He would be able to prevent all evil.
  • Evil exists.
  • Therefore, an all-good and all-powerful God does not exist.

This fundamental challenge is amplified when we distinguish between different categories of evil:

  • Natural Evil: Suffering caused by natural processes, such as earthquakes, diseases, and droughts. These are not directly attributable to human choice.
  • Moral Evil (Sin): Suffering and wrongdoing that result from the deliberate actions and choices of moral agents—humans. This category is where the concept of Sin finds its home, presenting a distinct and often more personal challenge to Theology.

Our focus here is on moral evil, specifically as understood through the lens of Sin. This shifts the debate from merely why bad things happen to why people do bad things, and how an omnibenevolent, omnipotent God permits or responds to these wilful transgressions.

Sin: The Human Dimension of Evil

In a theological context, Sin is not merely a mistake or a social faux pas; it is a transgression against divine law, a rebellion against God's will, or a failure to live up to the moral standard set by a divine creator. It represents a deliberate turning away from Good towards evil.

The Concept of Original Sin

One of the most influential theological explanations for the pervasive nature of Sin comes from St. Augustine of Hippo, whose reflections in works like Confessions and City of God (cornerstones of the Great Books of the Western World) shaped Western Christian thought profoundly. Augustine posited the doctrine of Original Sin.

Augustine argued that through the disobedience of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, humanity incurred a "fall" from its original state of grace. This act of Sin introduced a congenital defect, a corrupted will, passed down through generations. Consequently, all humans are born with a propensity to Sin, inherently inclined towards evil and away from God. This doctrine explains why Sin is not just an occasional failing but a fundamental aspect of the human condition, making the problem of evil a deeply internal one.

The Free Will Defense

A primary theological response to the problem of Sin is the Free Will Defense. This argument posits that God, in His infinite wisdom and love, granted humanity genuine free will. The ability to choose between Good and Evil is considered a greater good than a world where beings are merely automatons, programmed to do only Good.

The argument proceeds:

  1. A world with free creatures who can choose Good (and thus Sin) is more valuable than a world with no free creatures, or creatures who are coerced into Good.
  2. For creatures to be truly free, they must have the genuine capacity to choose evil (to Sin).
  3. Therefore, God permits Sin not because He desires it, but because it is an unavoidable consequence of creating truly free moral agents, which is a greater Good.

While compelling, the Free Will Defense raises further questions: Could God not have created free beings who always choose the Good? Or, if not, is the suffering caused by Sin justifiable by the value of free will? These are questions that continue to fuel philosophical and theological discourse.

Classical Theodicies and Their Engagement with Sin

Theologians have developed various "theodicies"—attempts to justify God's ways to humanity in the face of evil. Many of these directly engage with the problem of Sin.

Augustinian Theodicy

As mentioned, Augustine's theodicy is deeply intertwined with Original Sin. For Augustine, evil is not a substance but a privation of Good—like a shadow is a privation of light. Sin is the turning of the will away from the supreme Good (God) towards lesser goods. God did not create evil; rather, free creatures chose to corrupt the Good He created.

Augustine argues that God permits Sin for a greater Good, specifically the demonstration of His justice (in punishing Sin) and His mercy (in offering redemption). The presence of Sin allows for the divine drama of salvation, making the ultimate triumph of God's Goodness even more profound.

Irenaean Theodicy (Soul-Making Theodicy)

Originating with Irenaeus and later developed by John Hick, this theodicy suggests that God intentionally created an "epistemic distance" between Himself and humanity, allowing humans to develop into mature moral beings. In this "soul-making" universe, challenges, suffering, and even the experience of Sin are necessary for character development.

From this perspective, Sin is not merely a fall but an integral part of the human journey towards spiritual maturity. God allows Sin to exist not as a punitive measure but as a catalyst for growth, learning, and freely choosing to love and obey God amidst adversity.

The Book of Job: A Challenge to Simplistic Answers

The Book of Job, a profound work within the Great Books of the Western World, offers a stark and often unsettling perspective on suffering and evil. Job, a righteous man, suffers immensely despite his piety, challenging the simplistic notion that suffering is always a direct consequence of Sin.

While Job's friends repeatedly try to convince him that his suffering must be due to some hidden Sin, Job maintains his innocence, forcing a confrontation with the inscrutability of God's ways. The book doesn't offer a neat theological explanation for evil or Sin but instead emphasizes the limits of human understanding and the ultimate sovereignty of God. It suggests that some aspects of the problem of Good and Evil and God's justice remain beyond human comprehension.

The Paradox of God's Sovereignty and Human Freedom

A persistent tension in Theology concerning Sin is the relationship between God's absolute sovereignty and human free will. If God is truly omnipotent and orchestrates all things, does He not, in some sense, cause or predestine Sin?

This question has historically divided theological camps:

  • Calvinism: Emphasizes God's absolute sovereignty, including His foreknowledge and predestination of all events, even acts of Sin. While God does not cause individuals to Sin in a way that absolves them of responsibility, He permits it within His divine plan, often for His own glory.
  • Arminianism: Stresses human free will and God's desire for all to be saved. God's sovereignty is understood in a way that preserves genuine human choice, meaning Sin is truly a human decision, not divinely predetermined.

The resolution of this paradox often involves concepts like God's "permissive will" versus His "directive will"—God permits Sin to occur without actively willing it, allowing humanity the dignity of genuine moral choice and its consequences.

Consequences and Implications of Sin

The theological understanding of Sin carries profound implications:

  • Separation from God: Sin creates a barrier between humanity and a holy God, disrupting the intended relationship.
  • Impact on Humanity and the World: The cumulative effect of individual and collective Sin leads to brokenness, injustice, and suffering in the world.
  • Need for Redemption/Atonement: The recognition of Sin necessitates a solution, typically found in theological concepts of atonement, forgiveness, and salvation, often through divine intervention (e.g., the sacrifice of Christ in Christian Theology).

The wrestling with Sin is not just an intellectual exercise; it shapes how individuals and communities understand their place in the universe, their relationship with the divine, and their ethical responsibilities.

Key Concepts in The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin)

Here's a quick reference to some core terms:

Term Definition
Theodicy An attempt to reconcile the existence of evil (including Sin) with the attributes of an all-good and all-powerful God.
Sin A transgression against divine law or God's will; a deliberate moral evil originating from human choice.
Moral Evil Evil that results from the deliberate choices and actions of moral agents (e.g., murder, theft, hatred, which are forms of Sin).
Natural Evil Suffering and destruction that result from natural processes, independent of human will (e.g., earthquakes, disease).
Original Sin The theological doctrine, primarily associated with Augustine, that humanity inherited a corrupted nature and propensity to Sin from Adam's first disobedience.
Free Will Defense The argument that God allows evil (including Sin) because free will is a greater good than a world without it.

Image: A classical painting depicting Adam and Eve's expulsion from the Garden of Eden, with an angel pointing away from the tree of knowledge, symbolizing the consequence of original sin and the introduction of moral evil into the world. The figures show expressions of remorse and despair, while the lush garden contrasts with the harsh unknown beyond.

The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin) branches into numerous other philosophical and theological domains:

  • Metaphysics of Good and Evil: Exploring the ontological status of good and evil—are they real entities, privations, or subjective constructs?
  • Ethics and Moral Responsibility: How does the existence of Sin inform our understanding of human accountability, guilt, and virtue?
  • Divine Attributes: Deepening the inquiry into God's omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence in light of a world plagued by Sin.
  • The Problem of Suffering: While distinct from Sin, the broader issue of suffering often intertwines with discussions of moral evil and divine justice.

Real-World Implications and Applications

The theological problem of evil, specifically concerning Sin, is far from an abstract academic exercise. It profoundly impacts:

  • Faith Communities: How religious traditions grapple with the reality of human moral failure, the experience of guilt, and the path to forgiveness and redemption.
  • Individual Spirituality: The personal struggle with one's own shortcomings, the quest for moral improvement, and the search for meaning in a world often marked by injustice caused by Sin.
  • Justice Systems: The philosophical underpinnings of legal codes, punishment, and rehabilitation often reflect theological assumptions about human nature, responsibility, and the possibility of moral reform.
  • Coping with Adversity: Understanding the theological perspective on Sin can provide frameworks for individuals to process personal failures, societal injustices, and the broader presence of evil in the world.

Conclusion: An Enduring Mystery

The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin) remains one of the most formidable intellectual and spiritual challenges to faith. It is not easily resolved with simple answers but demands a continuous, rigorous engagement with the nature of God, the reality of human freedom, and the pervasive presence of Good and Evil in our world.

From Augustine's profound reflections on Original Sin to Job's agonizing questions about undeserved suffering, the Great Books of the Western World bear witness to humanity's enduring struggle with this paradox. While complete comprehension may elude us, the journey through these questions deepens our understanding of divine attributes, the complexities of human moral agency, and the profound significance of Sin within the grand narrative of creation, fall, and redemption. It is a journey that, for many, ultimately strengthens faith by refining it, compelling us to confront the deepest mysteries of existence with humility and persistent inquiry.

YouTube:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""The Problem of Evil Philosophy Debate""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Augustine Original Sin Explained""

Share this post