The Shadow Within: Unraveling the Theological Problem of Evil (Sin)

The question of why a benevolent, omnipotent, and omniscient God would permit the existence of evil has vexed theologians and philosophers for millennia. This is the Theological Problem of Evil, a profound paradox that strikes at the very heart of faith and reason. While evil manifests in many forms – natural disasters, suffering, disease – it is the presence of moral evil, stemming directly from human Sin, that presents perhaps the most acute challenge. If God is perfectly Good, why do we, His creations, choose to commit acts of profound evil? This pillar page will journey through the historical and philosophical attempts to reconcile these seemingly contradictory truths, exploring how thinkers from the Great Books of the Western World tradition have grappled with the nature of evil, the concept of Sin, and God's role in a world marred by human transgression.

The Paradox at the Heart of Faith: Defining the Theological Problem

At its core, the Theological Problem of Evil, often attributed to Epicurus, can be summarized as a dilemma:

  • If God is willing to prevent evil but unable, then He is not omnipotent.
  • If God is able to prevent evil but unwilling, then He is not omnibenevolent.
  • If God is both willing and able, then why does evil exist?

This classic formulation takes on a particularly sharp edge when we narrow our focus to moral evil – the evil that arises from the choices and actions of sentient beings, which in a theological context is often termed Sin. It's one thing to explain why natural disasters occur, but quite another to justify the existence of cruelty, hatred, and deliberate wrongdoing in a world created and sustained by a perfectly Good God. The problem forces us to confront fundamental questions about God's nature, human freedom, and the very meaning of Good and Evil.

Defining Evil and the Profundity of Sin

To grapple with the problem, we must first understand how evil has been defined, particularly in relation to Sin.

Evil as Privation: Augustine's Enduring Insight

One of the most influential perspectives comes from St. Augustine of Hippo, whose profound reflections in Confessions and City of God shaped centuries of theological thought. Augustine argues that evil is not a substance or a positive entity in itself, but rather a privation or absence of Good.

  • Analogy of Darkness: Just as darkness is not a substance but the absence of light, evil is the absence or corruption of Good where Good ought to be.
  • Corruption of Good: When something is evil, it is not utterly devoid of Good, but rather a Good thing that has been corrupted or twisted. A human being, created Good by God, commits Sin by turning away from a greater Good towards a lesser one, not by embracing a positive "evil" substance.

Sin as a Deliberate Turning Away

Within this Augustinian framework, Sin takes on a specific meaning. It is not merely an unfortunate mistake, but a deliberate act of the will, a turning away from God, who is the ultimate Good.

  • Misuse of Free Will: Sin is understood as a misuse of the free will that God bestowed upon humanity. It is the choice to prioritize lesser goods (self-interest, worldly pleasures) over the ultimate Good (obedience to God, love of neighbor).
  • Original Sin: Augustine also famously articulated the doctrine of Original Sin, inherited from Adam's transgression. This concept explains the pervasive human inclination towards evil and the universal struggle with Sin, suggesting that humanity's will is "fallen" and naturally inclined away from God.

Voices from the Great Books on God, Good, and Evil

The intellectual giants of the past have offered profound insights into the problem of Theology, Sin, Good and Evil, and God.

| Thinker | Key Work(s) | Core Contribution to the Problem of Evil (Sin) ## The Shadow Within: Unraveling the Theological Problem of Evil (Sin)

The profound paradox of how an omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent God can coexist with the palpable reality of evil has been a cornerstone of philosophical and theological debate for millennia. This is the Theological Problem of Evil, a challenge that intensifies when we specifically address moral evil – the suffering and injustice wrought by human actions, often termed Sin. How can a perfectly Good God create beings capable of such profound wrongdoing? This pillar page delves into this intricate question, exploring the historical and philosophical attempts to reconcile these seemingly contradictory truths, drawing upon the wisdom of the Great Books of the Western World tradition to understand the nature of evil, the concept of Sin, and ultimately, God's role in a world marred by human transgression.

1. The Paradox at the Heart of Faith: Defining the Theological Problem

The classic formulation of the Problem of Evil, often attributed to Epicurus, posits a direct challenge to the very attributes of God:

  • If God is willing to prevent evil but unable, then He is not omnipotent.
  • If God is able to prevent evil but unwilling, then He is not omnibenevolent.
  • If God is both willing and able, then why does evil exist?

This dilemma is particularly poignant when confronting moral evil, which arises directly from human choices. Unlike natural disasters, which can be attributed to the impersonal workings of the physical world, acts of cruelty, injustice, and hatred demand an explanation for their origin within a divinely ordered cosmos. It is here that the concept of Sin takes center stage, becoming not merely a consequence of evil but its very source in the human realm, forcing us to reconcile human moral failing with divine perfection.

2. Defining Evil and the Profundity of Sin

To navigate this complex terrain, we must first establish a working understanding of evil, particularly as it relates to Sin within a theological framework.

Evil as Privation: Augustine's Enduring Insight

One of the most foundational and enduring perspectives comes from St. Augustine of Hippo. In his seminal works, Confessions and City of God, Augustine meticulously argues that evil is not a positive substance or an entity in itself, but rather a privation or absence of Good.

  • The Analogy of Darkness: Augustine posited that just as darkness is not a substance but merely the absence of light, evil is the absence or corruption of Good where Good ought to be. It has no independent existence but is parasitic upon Good.
  • Corruption of Good: For Augustine, when something is deemed evil, it is not utterly devoid of Good, but rather a Good thing that has been corrupted or twisted. A human being, created fundamentally Good by God, commits Sin by turning away from a greater Good towards a lesser one, not by embracing a positive "evil" substance. This perspective allows for God's creation to be entirely Good while still accounting for the presence of evil as a defect.

Sin as a Deliberate Turning Away

Within this Augustinian framework, Sin is understood with particular gravity. It is not merely an unfortunate mistake or an accidental transgression, but a deliberate act of the will, a willful turning away from God, who is the ultimate Good.

  • Misuse of Free Will: Sin is fundamentally a misuse of the free will that God bestowed upon humanity. It is the conscious choice to prioritize lesser goods (self-interest, worldly pleasures, pride) over the ultimate Good (obedience to God, love of neighbor, divine communion).
  • Original Sin and its Legacy: Augustine also famously articulated the doctrine of Original Sin, inherited from Adam's primordial transgression. This concept explains the pervasive human inclination towards evil and the universal struggle with Sin, suggesting that humanity's will is "fallen" and naturally inclined away from God, making Sin an almost inevitable part of the human condition without divine grace.

3. Voices from the Great Books on God, Good, and Evil

The intellectual giants of the past have offered profound and often agonizing insights into the problem of Theology, Sin, Good and Evil, and God. Their wrestling with this paradox forms a significant portion of Western thought.

| Thinker/Text | Key Work(s) | Core Contribution to the Problem of Evil (Sin)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Theological Problem of Evil (Sin) philosophy"

Share this post