The Unseen Architect: The Role of Will in Moral Action and Duty

The will stands as the silent, yet profoundly powerful, architect of our moral lives. It is the faculty through which we navigate the complex landscape of right and wrong, translating abstract principles of duty into concrete actions. This article explores the indispensable role of the will in moral agency, examining how philosophers from the Great Books of the Western World have grappled with its nature, its capacity for choosing between good and evil, and its ultimate responsibility in fulfilling our duties.

The Will: The Engine of Moral Choice

At its core, the will is understood as the human faculty of conscious choice and decision. It's not merely a desire or an impulse, but the active power that directs our intentions and actions. Without a will, moral action, and indeed moral responsibility, would be inconceivable.

Defining the Will in Philosophy

Philosophers have approached the will from various angles:

  • As Rational Appetite: For thinkers like Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas, the will is a rational desire, an appetite for what reason presents as good. It's an informed choice, not a blind urge.
  • As the Seat of Freedom: For many, particularly Augustine, the will is synonymous with free will – the capacity to choose between alternatives, including the choice to follow or defy God's commands. This freedom is what makes us accountable for our actions.
  • As the Source of Moral Law: Immanuel Kant elevates the good will to the highest moral principle, arguing that its determination to act from duty is the sole criterion for moral worth.

Duty and the Imperative of the Will

The concept of duty is inextricably linked to the will. To act from duty means to perform an action not out of inclination, self-interest, or potential consequence, but solely because it is recognized as morally right.

Kant's Categorical Imperative and the Good Will

No philosopher emphasized the role of the will in duty more profoundly than Immanuel Kant. In his Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, Kant argues that the only thing unqualifiedly good is a good will.

Key Aspects of Kant's Philosophy on Will and Duty:

  • Acting from Duty, Not Merely in Accordance with Duty: For an action to have moral worth, it must be performed from duty, meaning the motive is respect for the moral law itself, not for any desired outcome.
  • The Categorical Imperative: The moral law, according to Kant, is expressed through the Categorical Imperative – a universal, unconditional command. The will's duty is to act only on maxims (subjective principles of action) that it could simultaneously will to become a universal law.
  • Autonomy of the Will: Kant posits that a rational being's will is autonomous, meaning it is a law unto itself. We are free because we can give ourselves moral laws and choose to act in accordance with them, rather than being determined by external forces or inclinations. This autonomy is what makes moral action possible and meaningful.

(Image: A detailed drawing of Immanuel Kant, with a quill pen in hand, seated at a desk, surrounded by stacks of books. A subtle ray of light illuminates his thoughtful expression, emphasizing the intellectual rigor and profound contemplation associated with his work on duty and the will.)

The Will's Struggle: Navigating Good and Evil

The will is not merely a passive instrument; it is the battleground where the forces of good and evil contend for supremacy. From ancient Greek philosophy to Christian theology, thinkers have explored the complexities of the will's capacity to choose vice over virtue, or to succumb to temptation despite knowing what is right.

Historical Perspectives on the Will and Morality

Philosopher Key Idea on Will & Moral Action Connection to Good & Evil
Plato The rational part of the soul (reason) should guide the spirited and appetitive parts. The will, driven by reason, seeks the good. Evil arises from ignorance or the appetitive parts overriding reason. A properly ordered soul wills the good.
Aristotle Emphasized prohairesis (deliberate choice), which is the outcome of deliberation by reason and desire aiming at the good. Virtue is a state of character concerned with choice. The will, through habituation, develops virtues or vices.
Augustine The concept of free will (liberum arbitrium) as the cause of sin. The will, though free, is fallen and prone to choose evil. Evil is a privation of good, originating from the will's turning away from God. The will's weakness (akrasia) is central.
Aquinas The will is a rational appetite for the good. It is free but directed towards ultimate happiness (God). Evil is chosen under the guise of some apparent good. The will can err when reason presents an imperfect good.

The struggle often lies in the tension between what our reason dictates as our duty (the good) and what our desires or passions compel us towards (potential evil). The strength of the will, or its weakness (akrasia), determines the outcome of this internal conflict.

The Indispensable Role of Free Will

For moral action to be truly moral, and for duty to be meaningful, the will must be free. If our actions were entirely predetermined by external forces, heredity, or environment, then the concept of praise, blame, responsibility, and indeed good and evil would lose their significance.

The freedom of the will allows us to:

  1. Choose our actions: We are not mere automatons responding to stimuli.
  2. Be held accountable: Our choices, made by our free will, are truly ours.
  3. Act from duty: We can intentionally choose to follow moral imperatives, even when it is difficult or goes against our inclinations.
  4. Strive for moral improvement: The capacity to choose good over evil implies the potential for growth and self-mastery.

Conclusion: The Will as Our Moral Compass

The role of the will in moral action and duty is foundational to Western philosophy. From the ancient Greeks' understanding of choice guided by reason to Kant's elevation of the good will acting from duty, the will remains the central faculty that empowers us to navigate the complexities of good and evil. It is through our will that we assert our moral agency, embrace our responsibilities, and ultimately shape not only our own character but also the moral fabric of the world around us. Understanding the will is not merely an academic exercise; it is an inquiry into the very essence of what it means to be a moral being.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Kant Categorical Imperative Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Augustine Free Will Problem of Evil"

Share this post