The intricate dance between conflict and concord, between the destructive force of war and the delicate balance of peace, has captivated thinkers for millennia. At the heart of navigating this complex human endeavor lies a virtue often overlooked in its profound implications: prudence. This pillar page explores the indispensable role of prudence in shaping the outcomes of both war and peace, drawing upon the timeless insights found within the Great Books of the Western World to illuminate its enduring wisdom.

The Guiding Hand: Understanding Prudence in Conflict and Harmony

Prudence, or phronesis as Aristotle termed it, is not mere cautiousness or self-interest; it is the intellectual virtue of practical wisdom, the ability to deliberate well about what is good and advantageous for oneself and for humanity. It involves discerning the best means to achieve a good end, considering all relevant circumstances, and acting appropriately. In the high-stakes arenas of war and peace, prudence becomes the compass for leaders, diplomats, and citizens alike, steering decisions towards justice, stability, and long-term well-being.

Defining Our Terms: Prudence, War, and Peace

  • Prudence (Phronesis): As articulated by Aristotle in his Nicomachean Ethics, prudence is the intellectual virtue concerned with human action, enabling us to make right decisions about what is good or bad in a given situation. It is the capacity to apply universal principles to particular circumstances, to see the future implications of present actions, and to choose the correct course.
  • War: A state of open and often prolonged armed conflict between states, nations, or parties. Philosophically, war is often examined through the lens of its justification, conduct, and consequences, as seen in the works of Thucydides and St. Thomas Aquinas.
  • Peace: A state of tranquility, harmony, and freedom from war or disturbance. Philosophically, peace is not merely the absence of war but often implies a positive condition of justice, order, and flourishing, as envisioned by Immanuel Kant and Plato.

Historical Context: Prudence Through the Ages

From the city-states of ancient Greece to the nascent international order, philosophers have grappled with the necessity of prudence.

  • Ancient Greece: Thucydides' History of the Peloponnesian War offers a stark lesson in the consequences of imprudent decisions driven by hubris, fear, and short-sighted ambition. The Athenian expedition to Sicily, for instance, serves as a monumental example of strategic imprudence. Plato, in The Republic, posits that a just state requires wise rulers—philosopher-kings—whose decisions are guided by reason and a comprehensive understanding of the good, which is a form of prudence.
  • Medieval Thought: St. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, identifies prudence as the "charioteer of the virtues," guiding courage, temperance, and justice. In his Summa Theologica, prudence is essential for determining the justice of war (just war theory) and the right conduct within it, emphasizing proportionality and right intention.
  • Renaissance Realism: Niccolò Machiavelli, in The Prince, redefines prudence within the realm of statecraft. For Machiavelli, prudence (or virtù) is the prince's ability to adapt to circumstances, to foresee dangers, and to act decisively, even if that means employing morally ambiguous methods for the sake of maintaining power and the stability of the state. While distinct from classical virtue, Machiavelli’s prudence is still a form of practical wisdom aimed at effective governance.
  • Enlightenment Idealism: Immanuel Kant, in Perpetual Peace, argues for a system of international relations guided by moral law and rational principles, where prudence would inform the establishment of republican constitutions and a federation of free states to prevent war. His vision is one where long-term peace is a moral imperative, requiring prudent foresight in structuring international agreements and laws.

Prudence in War: Navigating the Abyss

The decision to wage war, the conduct during conflict, and the terms of its cessation demand the highest degree of prudence.

1. Before War: The Calculus of Necessity

  • Just War Theory (Jus ad Bellum): Prudence is paramount in determining whether going to war is just. It requires careful deliberation on factors such as:
    • Just Cause: Is there a grave wrong to be righted (e.g., self-defense against aggression)?
    • Right Intention: Is the goal genuinely peace and justice, not conquest or revenge?
    • Last Resort: Have all peaceful options been exhausted?
    • Proportionality: Will the good achieved outweigh the harm inflicted?
    • Reasonable Chance of Success: Is the endeavor feasible, or will it lead to futile destruction?
    • Legitimate Authority: Is the decision made by a rightful governing body?
    • Example: Aquinas' framework for jus ad bellum is deeply rooted in prudent assessment, aiming to prevent rash or vindictive wars.

2. During War: The Ethics of Engagement

  • Conduct in War (Jus in Bello): Once war has begun, prudence guides the actions of combatants to minimize unnecessary suffering and adhere to ethical boundaries.
    • Discrimination: Distinguishing between combatants and non-combatants, and intentionally targeting only the former.
    • Proportionality: Ensuring that military force used is proportionate to the military objective, avoiding excessive or indiscriminate violence.
    • Necessity: Using only the force required to achieve a legitimate military objective.
    • Example: A prudent military leader, even amidst the chaos of battle, weighs the immediate tactical advantage against the long-term strategic and moral costs of certain actions, understanding that imprudent brutality can undermine ultimate victory and future peace.

3. Ending War: Crafting a Durable Peace

  • Post-War Settlement (Jus post Bellum): Prudence is crucial in establishing the conditions for a lasting peace.
    • Fairness and Justice: Ensuring that peace terms are just and do not sow the seeds of future conflict.
    • Reconstruction and Reconciliation: Prudently planning for the rebuilding of societies and fostering reconciliation between former adversaries.
    • Security Guarantees: Establishing mechanisms to prevent a recurrence of hostilities.
    • Example: The Treaty of Versailles, following World War I, is often cited as an imprudent peace, failing to address underlying grievances and contributing to future conflict.

Prudence in Peace: Cultivating Stability and Flourishing

Peace is not merely the absence of war; it is a dynamic state requiring continuous cultivation and maintenance through prudent action.

1. Maintaining Peace: Diplomacy and Alliances

  • Strategic Alliances: Prudent leaders forge alliances that enhance collective security and deter aggression, understanding the balance of power.
  • Diplomacy and Negotiation: The art of diplomacy is inherently prudent, requiring foresight, patience, and the ability to find common ground. It involves understanding the interests of all parties and seeking mutually beneficial outcomes.
  • Treaties and International Law: Establishing and upholding international agreements and legal frameworks demonstrates a commitment to a stable global order, requiring prudent foresight in their drafting and enforcement.
  • Example: Kant's vision of a "perpetual peace" relies on states prudently establishing republican constitutions and a league of nations, recognizing that cooperation is ultimately in their self-interest.

2. Preventing Conflict: Addressing Root Causes

  • Economic Justice: Prudent governance seeks to mitigate economic disparities that can breed resentment and instability.
  • Social Cohesion: Fostering inclusive societies where diverse groups can coexist peacefully is a long-term prudent strategy against internal conflict.
  • Early Warning Systems: Prudently monitoring potential flashpoints and addressing grievances before they escalate into violence.
  • Example: Hobbes, in Leviathan, argues for a strong sovereign to prevent the "war of all against all," an acknowledgment that prudent governance is necessary to avoid societal breakdown.

3. Building Sustainable Peace: Institutions and Values

  • Strong Institutions: Prudent leaders build robust democratic institutions, independent judiciaries, and fair legal systems that can resolve disputes peacefully and ensure justice.
  • Education and Civic Virtue: Investing in education that promotes critical thinking, empathy, and civic responsibility is a prudent long-term strategy for cultivating a peaceful citizenry.
  • Cultural Exchange: Promoting understanding and respect between different cultures and nations helps to break down prejudices that can lead to conflict.

(Image: A classical painting depicting Minerva, the Roman goddess of wisdom and strategic warfare, in a contemplative pose. She is shown holding a spear, but her gaze is directed away from it, perhaps towards a scroll or an allegorical representation of a city in the distance, suggesting deep thought and planning rather than impulsive action. Her owl companion, a symbol of wisdom, perches on her shoulder, reinforcing the theme of prudence guiding power.)

Challenges to Prudence: The Human Element

Despite its critical importance, prudence faces numerous obstacles:

  • Emotion and Passion: Fear, anger, pride, and vengeance can cloud judgment, leading to impulsive and imprudent decisions. Thucydides masterfully illustrates how these emotions swayed Athenian policy.
  • Ideology and Dogma: Rigid adherence to an ideology can prevent a leader from adapting to changing circumstances or considering alternative solutions.
  • Short-Sightedness: A focus on immediate gains or political expediency often comes at the expense of long-term stability and well-being.
  • Uncertainty and Unpredictability: The future is inherently unknowable, making perfect foresight impossible. Prudence, therefore, involves making the best possible decisions with incomplete information.
  • The Lure of Power: The pursuit and maintenance of power can corrupt the prudent judgment of leaders, leading them to prioritize self-preservation over the common good.

The Interplay of Prudence and Other Virtues

Prudence does not operate in isolation; it is the orchestrator of all other virtues, particularly in the context of war and peace:

  • Prudence and Justice: Prudence guides the application of justice, ensuring that actions taken are fair and equitable, whether in declaring war or negotiating peace. A just war is an outcome of prudent deliberation.
  • Prudence and Courage: Courage without prudence can be reckless; prudence without courage can be timid. Prudence determines when and how courage should be exercised, distinguishing between bravery and foolhardiness.
  • Prudence and Temperance: Temperance (moderation) ensures that decisions are not driven by excessive desires or appetites. Prudence helps to moderate aggressive impulses and promotes restraint.
  • Prudence and Wisdom: While closely related, prudence is practical wisdom, concerned with action, whereas theoretical wisdom seeks understanding for its own sake. Prudence applies wisdom to the concrete challenges of life.

Conclusion: The Enduring Imperative of Prudence

The role of prudence in war and peace is not merely advisory; it is foundational. From the strategic calculations of ancient generals to the delicate negotiations of modern diplomats, the ability to deliberate well, to foresee consequences, and to act appropriately is the hallmark of effective leadership and stable societies. As we continue to navigate a world fraught with conflict and striving for harmony, the wisdom enshrined in the Great Books of the Western World reminds us that prudence is not a luxury, but an absolute necessity—the guiding star for humanity's journey towards a more just and peaceful existence. Cultivating this virtue, individually and collectively, remains our most profound challenge and our greatest hope.

YouTube: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence"
YouTube: "Just War Theory Explained Aquinas"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Role of Prudence in War and Peace philosophy"

Share this post