The Guiding Hand: Prudence as the Architect of Temperance
Summary: Prudence, often called practical wisdom, is not merely a companion to temperance but its indispensable guide. Without the discerning eye of prudence, temperance risks becoming either rigid asceticism or reckless indulgence. This article explores how prudence directs temperance towards the virtuous mean, ensuring that our appetites and desires are governed by reason, leading to a well-ordered life. It delves into the classical understanding of these virtues, drawing from the profound insights found within the Great Books of the Western World.
The Symphony of Virtues: An Introduction
In the grand tapestry of classical philosophy, virtues are not isolated islands but interconnected strands, each lending strength and meaning to the others. Among these, Prudence and Temperance stand as foundational pillars for a well-lived human existence. While temperance often receives praise for its role in self-control and moderation, its true power and efficacy are unlocked only when it is expertly guided by the sagacious hand of prudence. To truly master one's desires is not merely to suppress them, but to know when, how, and to what extent to engage with them—a knowledge that is the very essence of practical wisdom.
Understanding Prudence: The Navigator of Right Action
Prudence (Greek: phronesis; Latin: prudentia) is far more than mere cautiousness or shrewdness; it is the intellectual virtue that enables us to deliberate well about what is good and advantageous for ourselves, not in some particular respect, but for living well generally. As Aristotle meticulously details in his Nicomachean Ethics, prudence is a true and reasoned state of capacity to act with regard to human goods. It is the ability to see the appropriate course of action in specific situations, bridging the gap between universal moral principles and particular circumstances.
- Practical Wisdom: Prudence is fundamentally practical Wisdom. It is not theoretical knowledge (like knowing mathematics) but knowledge that directs action. It's about knowing what to do, when, and how to achieve a good end.
- The Charioteer of Virtues: Ancient philosophers often depicted prudence as the "charioteer" of the virtues, guiding all others. Without prudence, courage can become recklessness, justice can become harshness, and temperance can become either extreme asceticism or destructive license.
- Discernment and Deliberation: Prudence involves careful deliberation, assessing various options, considering consequences, and ultimately making a sound judgment that leads to a virtuous act.
Understanding Temperance: The Mastery of Desire
Temperance (Greek: sophrosyne; Latin: temperantia) is the virtue concerned with the moderation and rational control of our appetitive desires and pleasures, particularly those related to the body—food, drink, and sexual gratification. It is the harmonious ordering of our lower faculties by reason, preventing us from being enslaved by our passions.
- The Mean Between Extremes: Like all virtues, temperance exists as a Virtue or "mean" between two Vices:
- Vice of Deficiency: Insensibility or Callousness, where one feels too little pleasure or avoids legitimate pleasures to an unhealthy degree. This is rare but possible.
- Vice of Excess: Intemperance or Licentiousness, where one indulges excessively in pleasures, allowing desires to override reason and leading to self-destruction or harm.
- Not Absence, But Right Measure: Temperance is not about denying all pleasure or becoming emotionless. Instead, it is about enjoying pleasures in the right way, at the right time, and to the right extent. It's about self-mastery, where reason governs appetite, as Plato describes in The Republic regarding the harmonious soul.
The Indispensable Partnership: Prudence Guiding Temperance
This is where the profound connection between these two virtues becomes evident. Temperance, left to its own devices, is blind. It knows that it should moderate, but it doesn't inherently know what moderation looks like in every unique situation. This is where Prudence steps in, acting as the discerning eye and steady hand.
- Determining the Mean: Prudence is responsible for identifying the "golden mean" for temperance in specific contexts. For example, temperance dictates moderate eating, but prudence determines what "moderate" means for this individual, this meal, this health condition, or this social occasion. It distinguishes between a healthy indulgence and gluttony.
- Discerning Circumstances: Prudence considers all relevant factors: the individual's constitution, their duties, the social setting, the long-term consequences, and the moral implications. A prudent person understands that what is temperate for one might be intemperate for another, or that what is acceptable at a celebration might be inappropriate during a fast.
- Identifying True Good: Prudence ensures that the control of desires serves a higher rational purpose. It prevents temperance from becoming an end in itself (e.g., asceticism for asceticism's sake) and instead directs it towards human flourishing and the pursuit of genuine goods.
- Foreseeing Consequences: A prudent individual anticipates the potential outcomes of their actions regarding pleasure. They consider not just immediate gratification but also the long-term impact on their health, relationships, and moral character.
Consider the following examples of how prudence refines temperance:
| Aspect of Life | Temperance Without Prudence (Potential Pitfalls) | Temperance With Prudence (Virtuous Outcome) |
|---|---|---|
| Eating & Drinking | Strict, joyless abstinence OR reckless overindulgence | Mindful nourishment, healthy enjoyment, appropriate social consumption |
| Sexual Desire | Repression/avoidance OR promiscuity/exploitation | Expressed within loving, committed relationships; respect for self and others |
| Spending Habits | Avarice/hoarding OR profligacy/debt | Responsible stewardship, wise investment, generous giving |
| Speech & Humour | Silence/dullness OR garrulousness/offensiveness | Thoughtful, appropriate, kind, and timely communication |
(Image: An ancient Greek fresco depicting a serene female figure in flowing robes, holding a small, perfectly balanced scale in one hand, symbolizing Prudence weighing desires and circumstances, while her other hand gently rests on the arm of a second figure, who calmly sips water from a simple goblet, representing Temperance and self-control.)
Why This Interplay Matters: Cultivating a Flourishing Life
The harmonious relationship between prudence and temperance is crucial for living a truly flourishing life, or eudaimonia, as the ancient Greeks conceived it. A life lacking prudent guidance in its pursuit of temperance can lead to:
- Extremes and Rigidity: Without prudence, temperance can devolve into a rigid, unthinking adherence to rules, leading to joylessness or even harmful self-denial.
- Lack of True Freedom: The intemperate person is enslaved by their passions. But even the overly ascetic person might be enslaved by fear or a misunderstanding of the good. True freedom is found in self-mastery guided by reason.
- Regret and Impaired Judgment: Actions born of intemperance, unguided by prudent foresight, often lead to regret, poor health, damaged relationships, and a compromised ability to make sound decisions in other areas of life.
By allowing prudence to inform and direct our temperate choices, we ensure that our desires are integrated into a rational, moral framework. This leads to inner peace, strength of character, and the capacity to pursue higher goods without being constantly derailed by unruly appetites.
Conclusion: The Harmonious Soul
In the grand tradition of the Great Books of the Western World, from Plato's vision of the ordered soul to Aristotle's meticulous analysis of practical wisdom, the message is clear: Prudence is not merely a virtue among others, but the intellectual light that illuminates the path for all virtues, especially Temperance. It is the architect that designs the structure of moderation, ensuring that our self-control is not arbitrary or misguided, but purposeful and conducive to our ultimate good. To cultivate prudence is to cultivate the ability to live well, to navigate the complexities of desire with grace, reason, and an unwavering commitment to a truly virtuous life.
📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics
Video by: The School of Life
💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence; Thomas Aquinas Temperance Virtue"