The Guiding Hand: How Prudence Elevates Temperance from Mere Abstinence to True Virtue

Summary

Temperance, often misunderstood as mere self-denial or asceticism, is in fact a sophisticated virtue that requires the constant guidance of prudence. This article explores how prudence, or practical wisdom, acts as the intellectual compass for temperance, enabling individuals to navigate desires and pleasures with discernment. Without prudence, temperance risks becoming a vice of excess or deficiency, highlighting their indispensable bond in achieving a truly virtuous and flourishing life as understood within the Great Books of the Western World.

Understanding Temperance Beyond Simple Denial

When we speak of temperance, many minds immediately conjure images of strict abstinence, puritanical restraint, or perhaps even a degree of suffering. Yet, this narrow interpretation misses the profound depth of this ancient virtue. As explored by thinkers from Plato to Aristotle and beyond, temperance is not about the eradication of pleasure or desire, but rather their harmonious ordering.

  • Plato, in his Republic, conceptualizes temperance (or sophrosyne) as the agreement among different parts of the soul about who should rule, leading to internal harmony and self-mastery. It is the rational part guiding the appetitive.
  • Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, presents temperance as a "golden mean" concerning bodily pleasures, particularly those related to food, drink, and sex. It's the sweet spot between the vice of gluttony or profligacy (excess) and the vice of insensibility or asceticism (deficiency).

True temperance, therefore, is not about not enjoying life's pleasures, but about enjoying them rightly—at the right time, in the right measure, and for the right reasons. But how does one determine what is "right"? This is where prudence steps onto the stage.

Prudence: The Charioteer of Virtues

Prudence (phronesis in Greek), often translated as practical wisdom, is considered by many philosophers, most notably Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas, to be the "charioteer of the virtues." It is an intellectual virtue that enables us to deliberate well about what is good and bad for human beings, and to act effectively towards those goods.

Prudence is distinct from mere cleverness or cunning. A clever person might find effective means to any end, good or bad. Prudence, however, is always directed towards genuinely good ends. It involves:

  • Deliberation (Euboulia): The ability to think through a situation thoroughly.
  • Judgment (Synesis/Gnome): The capacity to grasp the particular circumstances and apply universal principles.
  • Decisiveness (Deinotes): The ability to translate good judgment into effective action.

Without prudence, other moral virtues would be blind. Courage without prudence becomes recklessness. Justice without prudence can become rigid dogma. And temperance without prudence can quickly devolve into something unvirtuous.

(Image: A classical marble sculpture depicting a robed figure, possibly Athena or a philosopher, with a thoughtful, serene expression, holding a compass or a scroll, symbolizing wisdom and careful deliberation.)

The Indissoluble Bond: Prudence Guiding Temperance

The relationship between prudence and temperance is symbiotic. Prudence provides the intelligence for temperance to be truly virtuous, while temperance offers the self-control necessary for prudence to be effectively implemented.

Consider the following:

Aspect of Temperance Role of Prudence Potential Vice Without Prudence
Desire Management Determines which desires are appropriate and healthy to pursue. Suppression of all desires (insensibility) or uncontrolled indulgence (gluttony).
Pleasure Enjoyment Ascertains the right amount, time, and context for pleasure. Excessive pursuit of pleasure (hedonism) or rejection of all pleasure (asceticism).
Self-Control Directs self-control towards truly good and rational ends. Rigid adherence to arbitrary rules or self-harming denial.
Moderation Defines the "golden mean" specific to the individual and situation. Misjudgment of what constitutes moderation, leading to excess or deficiency.

For example, a person might deny themselves all sugar (an act of temperance). But is this truly prudent? If it leads to obsessive anxiety about food, social isolation, or nutritional deficiencies, then what appears to be temperance might actually be a vice of insensibility or an unhealthy obsession. Prudence would weigh the health benefits against the psychological and social costs, seeking a balanced approach that promotes overall well-being. It is prudence that discerns the appropriate level of self-restraint for this person, in this situation, for this end.

The journey towards virtue is fraught with the dangers of vice, which lie on either side of the virtuous mean. Prudence acts as our internal GPS, constantly recalibrating our course.

  • Excessive Indulgence (Vice): Without prudence, an individual might succumb to every impulse, believing "living in the moment" is temperate, when it is, in fact, self-destructive.
  • Excessive Self-Denial (Vice): Conversely, a lack of prudent judgment might lead someone to believe that any pleasure is inherently bad, resulting in a life devoid of joy and potentially harming their physical or mental health. This is not temperance, but a distorted form of it.

Wisdom, in its practical application through prudence, allows us to understand that temperance is not about suffering, but about flourishing. It's about freedom from the tyranny of unbridled desires and also freedom from the tyranny of unnecessary self-punishment. It is the intelligent management of our inner life, leading to external harmony.

The Wisdom of Balanced Living

Ultimately, the role of prudence in temperance underscores a fundamental truth about human flourishing: it is achieved not through rigid rules, but through thoughtful, context-aware application of principles. The Great Books of the Western World consistently remind us that a life well-lived is a life guided by reason, where intellectual virtues like prudence guide the moral virtues.

A truly temperate person is not merely someone who can say no, but someone who knows when and why to say no, and equally, when and why to say yes. This discerning capacity is the hallmark of prudence, making it utterly indispensable for temperance to shine as the profound and life-affirming virtue it truly is.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Temperance"
2. ## 📹 Related Video: PLATO ON: The Allegory of the Cave

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Cardinal Virtues Explained Plato Aquinas"

Share this post