The Guiding Hand: How Prudence Shapes True Temperance

Summary: In the grand tapestry of human flourishing, Prudence and Temperance emerge as two cardinal virtues, often discussed in the venerable texts of the Great Books of the Western World. While Temperance calls for moderation and self-control over our desires, it is Prudence – practical wisdom – that acts as its indispensable guide, ensuring that our restraint is not merely an act of denial but a path to genuine well-being. Without the discerning eye of Prudence, Temperance risks becoming either a rigid austerity or a misguided compromise, failing to hit the mark of true virtue.

Unpacking the Virtues: Prudence and Temperance

The classical philosophers, from Plato to Aristotle and beyond, consistently championed a life lived virtuously. Among the most foundational virtues are Prudence and Temperance, each playing a critical role in shaping a well-ordered soul and a fulfilling life.

Prudence: The Charioteer of the Virtues

  • Prudence (from the Latin prudentia, translating the Greek phronesis, often rendered as "practical wisdom") is the intellectual virtue that enables us to deliberate well about what is good for us, not in some general sense, but in specific, concrete situations. As Aristotle meticulously details in his Nicomachean Ethics, Prudence is "right reason in action." It is not merely cleverness or cunning, but the ability to discern the appropriate means to a good end.
    • Key Aspects of Prudence:
      • Deliberation: Thoughtfully weighing options and consequences.
      • Judgment: Making sound decisions based on understanding.
      • Foresight: Considering future implications of present actions.
      • Memory: Learning from past experiences.
      • Docility: Openness to learning from others.

Temperance: The Harmony of Desire

  • Temperance (from the Latin temperantia, corresponding to the Greek sophrosyne) is the moral virtue that moderates our appetites and passions, particularly those related to bodily pleasures such as food, drink, and sex. It ensures that these natural desires remain within the bounds of reason, preventing them from overwhelming our capacity for rational thought and action. Plato, in his dialogue Charmides, explores sophrosyne as a form of self-knowledge and harmonious order within the soul.
    • Key Aspects of Temperance:
      • Self-Control: Mastery over one's impulses.
      • Moderation: Avoiding excess and deficiency.
      • Order: Aligning desires with reason and the good life.

While Temperance provides the will to moderate, it is Prudence that provides the wisdom to know how and when to moderate. True Temperance is not simply abstinence or rigid denial; it is the right amount of engagement with pleasure, at the right time, for the right reason. This "rightness" is precisely where Prudence becomes essential.

Consider the act of eating. A person might be temperate by not overeating. But Prudence takes this further:

  • What should I eat for my health and well-being?
  • How much is appropriate for my body and activity level today?
  • When should I eat to maintain energy and avoid lethargy?
  • Why am I eating – for nourishment, enjoyment, or out of boredom/stress?

Without Prudence, Temperance can err in two ways, becoming a Vice:

  1. Excessive Austerity (Vice of Defect): Mistaking Temperance for total denial of legitimate pleasures. This can lead to an unbalanced, joyless life, or even harm, as when someone starves themselves out of a misguided sense of self-control. Prudence helps us recognize that some pleasures are good and necessary for human flourishing.
  2. Blind Adherence (Lack of Wisdom): Following rules about moderation without understanding their underlying purpose or adapting them to specific circumstances. For example, a generalized rule about "no sweets" might be temperate in one context but overly rigid and unnecessary in another, such as celebrating a special occasion.

Prudence, therefore, acts as the internal compass, discerning the "golden mean" – Aristotle's concept of virtue lying between two extremes of excess and defect – for Temperance in every unique situation. It tailors the general principle of moderation to the individual's specific needs, context, and ultimate goals.

The journey towards virtue is often fraught with the dangers of Vice and Vice. Prudence is the master navigator that keeps us on the virtuous path, steering clear of both too much and too little.

Virtue Vice of Excess Vice of Defect Role of Prudence in Temperance
Temperance Gluttony, Lust, Intemperance Insensibility, Apathy, Asceticism (when excessive) Discerns the appropriate measure of pleasure and restraint. It distinguishes healthy enjoyment from destructive indulgence, and necessary self-denial from harmful austerity. It asks, "What is good for me in this situation?"
Courage Rashness, Recklessness Cowardice, Timidity Determines when danger is real, when to stand firm, and when retreat is prudent.
Generosity Prodigality, Wastefulness Stinginess, Avarice Guides us in knowing what, when, and to whom to give, ensuring our giving is beneficial and sustainable.

Wisdom's Guiding Hand

Ultimately, Prudence is a manifestation of practical Wisdom. It is not merely abstract knowledge but knowledge applied to the art of living well. It connects our immediate choices to our long-term good and our understanding of what constitutes a truly flourishing human life. It enables us to see the bigger picture, the telos or purpose, informing our daily decisions about how to regulate our desires.

A genuinely temperate person is not simply one who can deny themselves, but one who wisely understands why and how to regulate their desires to achieve a greater good. This wisdom, this Prudence, is what elevates mere self-control to the realm of virtue, making Temperance a powerful force for personal harmony and ethical living.

(Image: A classical marble statue depicting a graceful female figure, perhaps allegorical of Prudence or Temperance, holding a bridle or a set of scales, symbolizing control, balance, and judicious restraint. The statue is set against a soft, unfocused background of ancient architecture, suggesting timeless wisdom.)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence" and "Plato Charmides Temperance Explained""

Share this post