The Guiding Hand: How Prudence Perfects Temperance

Summary: Prudence, often called practical wisdom, is not merely another virtue but the indispensable architect and guide for all others, especially temperance. It is the intellectual virtue that discerns the appropriate means to achieve a good end, transforming raw self-control into a truly virtuous act. Without the discerning eye of prudence, temperance risks becoming rigid asceticism, weak indulgence, or simply misapplied effort, failing to achieve the balanced virtue necessary for human flourishing.

Prudence: The Charioteer of Virtues

In the grand tapestry of classical philosophy, particularly as laid out in the Great Books of the Western World, prudence (Greek: phronesis) stands as a towering intellectual virtue. Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, describes it not as theoretical wisdom concerned with immutable truths, but as practical wisdom – "right reason in action." It is the ability to deliberate well about what is good and advantageous for oneself, not in some particular respect, but for living well generally.

Prudence is the virtue that:

  • Discerns: It sees the particular circumstances, understanding what is truly good in a given situation.
  • Deliberates: It weighs options, considering consequences and the appropriate course of action.
  • Directs: It issues commands, guiding the will and other virtues towards their proper end.

Often depicted as the "charioteer of the virtues," prudence doesn't merely ride alongside; it holds the reins, guiding the horses of courage, justice, and temperance along the right path. Without its steady hand, these powerful forces could easily veer into vice – recklessness, injustice, or intemperance.

Temperance: The Mastery of Desires

Temperance (Greek: sophrosyne) is the moral virtue concerned with moderating our appetites and desires, particularly those related to bodily pleasures such as food, drink, and sexual gratification. It is the beautiful balance between excess and deficiency, the sweet spot of self-control.

However, understanding temperance requires more than mere abstinence. It is not the denial of pleasure but its proper regulation. As explored by Plato and later by Aquinas, the temperate person enjoys pleasures rightly, in the right amount, at the right time, and for the right reasons.

Consider the spectrum of this virtue and its corresponding vices:

Virtue/Vice Spectrum Description
Vice (Deficiency) Insensibility: A lack of desire for necessary pleasures, an unhealthy aversion.
Virtue (Mean) Temperance: Enjoying pleasures appropriately, with moderation and self-control.
Vice (Excess) Intemperance: Overindulgence in pleasures, lacking self-control, leading to harm.

A truly temperate individual avoids both the vice of gluttony and the vice of asceticism for its own sake, instead finding the healthy and appropriate middle ground.

The Indispensable Partnership: How Prudence Guides Temperance

Here lies the crux of our discussion: prudence is absolutely essential for temperance to be a true virtue. Temperance without prudence is blind; prudence without temperance is weak.

  1. Setting the Right Measure: Temperance aims for moderation, but prudence defines what that moderation is in any given context. How much food is "moderate"? When is it appropriate to indulge in a celebratory drink? Prudence assesses the individual, the circumstances, the goals, and the potential consequences to arrive at the wise answer.
  2. Discerning True Good: An intemperate person might believe that unbridled pleasure is good. A person lacking prudence might mistakenly believe that complete denial is always the highest good. Prudence helps us understand that true good lies in rightly ordered desires and actions that contribute to overall flourishing.
  3. Avoiding Extremes: The path of virtue is a narrow one between two vices. Prudence is the internal compass that steers temperance away from both the siren call of excess and the barren landscape of deficiency. It prevents temperance from becoming a rigid, joyless denial or a flimsy, easily broken resolution.
  4. Adapting to Circumstances: What is temperate for one person or in one situation may not be so for another. A marathon runner's diet differs from a scholar's. A feast day calls for different moderation than a fast day. Prudence provides the situational wisdom to adapt the general principle of temperance to specific realities.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting a sage or philosopher, perhaps Plato or Aristotle, seated in deep contemplation, with allegorical figures of 'Reason' gently guiding 'Desire' or 'Appetite' away from excess or deficiency, symbolizing the internal struggle and the prudent guidance required for virtuous self-mastery.)

Wisdom in Action: The Prudent, Temperate Life

Consider the individual who embodies both prudence and temperance. This person doesn't just refrain from overeating; they wisely choose nutritious foods in appropriate portions, understanding their body's needs and the long-term benefits of such choices. They don't merely avoid drunkenness; they prudently enjoy social gatherings, knowing their limits and valuing clear thought and respectful interaction over fleeting intoxication.

This integrated approach, where prudence informs and perfects temperance, leads to a life of greater freedom and inner peace. It's not about self-denial for its own sake, but about self-mastery for the sake of a richer, more meaningful existence. It is the practical application of wisdom to our most basic human desires, elevating them from mere biological urges to components of a well-lived, virtuous life.

Ultimately, the role of prudence in temperance is akin to that of a skilled sculptor refining raw marble. Temperance provides the material – the inclination to moderate – but prudence shapes it, smooths it, and gives it its perfect form, transforming a basic human capacity into a shining virtue that contributes to a truly flourishing life.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Temperance Virtue"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Sophrosyne Self Control Philosophy"

Share this post