The Guiding Hand: How Prudence Perfects Temperance

Summary: Prudence, often called practical wisdom, is not merely a companion to temperance but its indispensable guide. While temperance aims to moderate our desires and pleasures, it is prudence that discerns the right measure, the appropriate time, and the proper context for such moderation. Without prudence, temperance risks becoming an unthinking asceticism or a misguided restraint, failing to hit the mark of true virtue and instead veering into vice. It is the foresight and good judgment of prudence that allows temperance to achieve its virtuous ideal, leading us toward a balanced and well-ordered life.

Unveiling the Virtues: A Symbiotic Relationship

In the grand tapestry of human character, virtues are the threads that weave together a life of excellence and fulfillment. Among these, Prudence and Temperance stand as pillars, frequently discussed by the ancient philosophers whose insights continue to illuminate our understanding of the human condition, particularly within the pages of the Great Books of the Western World. While each virtue possesses its unique domain, their relationship is deeply symbiotic, with prudence serving as the wise counselor that enables temperance to flourish authentically.

Prudence: The Charioteer of Virtues

Often regarded as the "mother of all virtues" or the "charioteer of the virtues" by figures like Aristotle and Aquinas, Prudence is fundamentally practical wisdom. It is the intellectual virtue that enables us to deliberate well about what is good for us, not in some abstract sense, but in the concrete circumstances of daily life. Prudence involves:

  • Deliberation (Boulē): The ability to consider various courses of action and their potential consequences.
  • Judgment (Synesis): The faculty of making sound decisions based on that deliberation.
  • Execution (Gnōmē): The capacity to act effectively on those judgments.

Prudence is not merely cleverness or cunning; it is directed towards a good end. It is the virtue that helps us navigate the complexities of ethical choice, ensuring our actions align with our ultimate well-being.

Temperance: Moderating Our Desires

Temperance (or sophrosyne in Greek) is the virtue concerned with the moderation of our appetites, desires, and pleasures, particularly those related to bodily satisfactions like food, drink, and sex. It is about finding the right measure between excess and deficiency. A temperate person is not one who denies all pleasure, but one who enjoys pleasures in a rational, healthy, and appropriate way.

Without temperance, we risk falling into the vice of self-indulgence (excess) or, conversely, insensibility (deficiency), both of which detract from a flourishing life. The temperate individual masters their desires, rather than being enslaved by them, allowing reason to guide their appetites.

Here lies the critical connection: temperance, without the guiding hand of prudence, can falter. It is prudence that provides the intelligence necessary for temperance to be truly virtuous.

Consider the following:

  • Defining the "Right Measure": What constitutes "moderation" is rarely a fixed quantity. Prudence assesses the specific context – my health, my circumstances, the social setting – to determine what is temperate here and now. For instance, a small celebratory drink might be prudent for one, while complete abstinence is prudent for another with a history of addiction.
  • Distinguishing Virtue from Vice: Without prudence, one might mistake extreme asceticism for temperance, believing that any pleasure is inherently bad. Prudence, informed by Wisdom, understands that pleasures are natural and good when enjoyed appropriately, and helps us avoid the vice of insensibility. Conversely, it prevents temperance from sliding into self-indulgence by clearly delineating boundaries.
  • Foresight and Consequences: Prudence allows us to foresee the potential consequences of our desires if left unchecked. A prudent person understands that excessive indulgence, even in otherwise harmless pleasures, can lead to long-term harm to health, relationships, or financial stability. This foresight strengthens the resolve of temperance.
  • Alignment with Higher Goods: Prudence ensures that our temperate actions align with our broader life goals and ethical framework. It prevents temperance from becoming an isolated act, instead integrating it into a cohesive pursuit of the good life.

How Prudence Shapes Temperance

Aspect of Temperance Role of Prudence Example
Defining Moderation Determines the appropriate amount in specific situations. Deciding how much food to eat at a banquet based on hunger, health, and social grace.
Timing and Context Identifies the right time and suitable place for pleasure or restraint. Choosing to abstain from alcohol before an important meeting, despite social pressure.
Avoiding Extremes Distinguishes true virtue from the vices of excess (self-indulgence) and defect (insensibility). Recognizing that enjoying a dessert in moderation is not a vice, nor is rigid fasting always a virtue.
Long-term Well-being Considers the future consequences of immediate desires and choices. Opting for a healthy diet and regular exercise to maintain long-term health, despite immediate cravings.
Integration with Other Virtues Ensures temperate actions support, rather than hinder, other virtues like justice or courage. Moderating one's desire for wealth so as not to compromise one's commitment to fairness.

Virtue and Vice: The Spectrum of Human Action

The interplay of prudence and temperance highlights the delicate balance inherent in virtue. A lack of prudence can transform what might seem like a virtuous act into a vice. An individual might abstain from all pleasures, believing it to be temperate, but without prudence, this could be an act of insensibility, leading to an impoverished life and alienating others. Conversely, someone might justify excessive indulgence by claiming it's "living life to the fullest," failing to apply prudent judgment to the long-term consequences.

True temperance, therefore, is not a blind adherence to rules but a reasoned, flexible, and context-aware moderation, constantly guided by the sagacity of prudence.

Wisdom in Action

Ultimately, the role of prudence in temperance is a profound demonstration of wisdom in action. It is the application of intellectual insight to the practical challenges of living well. It is the understanding that true freedom comes not from unrestrained desire, but from the rational ordering of our desires towards a greater good. By allowing prudence to direct our temperance, we move beyond mere self-control to achieve genuine self-mastery, cultivating a character that is both disciplined and deeply human.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting a serene figure of Athena, embodying wisdom and prudence, gently placing a guiding hand on the arm of a younger, slightly restless figure representing Temperance. Athena holds a small, balanced scale, symbolizing judgment and measure, while Temperance looks thoughtfully at the scale, her expression shifting from desire to contemplation. The background shows a balanced landscape with both lush growth and disciplined architecture, reflecting harmony and order.)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? [Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Temperance"
(YouTube: "Thomas Aquinas Virtues Prudence Temperance""](https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query="Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Temperance" (YouTube%3A "Thomas Aquinas Virtues Prudence Temperance")

Share this post