The Guiding Hand: How Prudence Shapes Temperance

A Benjamin Richmond Reflection on Virtue

Summary: In the intricate tapestry of classical virtues, Prudence stands as the indispensable intellectual virtue that directs and perfects Temperance. Without the practical wisdom of prudence, temperance risks devolving into either rigid asceticism or reckless indulgence. This article explores how prudence provides the discerning judgment necessary for temperance to achieve its true aim: a harmonious and flourishing life, free from the extremes of both excess and deficiency.

I. Introduction: The Indispensable Nexus of Virtues

For those of us who delve into the profound insights of the Great Books of the Western World, it becomes clear that the virtues are rarely isolated islands. Instead, they form a complex, interdependent ecosystem, each supporting and enhancing the others. Among these vital connections, the relationship between Prudence and Temperance is particularly profound, forming the very bedrock of a well-ordered existence. It's a relationship where one virtue acts as the discerning guide, and the other as the disciplined executor, together charting a course away from the pitfalls of Virtue and Vice.

II. Prudence: The Architect of Right Action and Practical Wisdom

In the Aristotelian tradition, Prudence (or phronesis) is not merely cautiousness or cleverness; it is a profound form of practical wisdom. As Aristotle articulates in his Nicomachean Ethics, prudence is "a true and reasoned state of capacity to act with regard to the things that are good or bad for man." It is the intellectual virtue that enables us to deliberate well about what is good for us, not just in a general sense, but in the concrete circumstances of life.

  • Discerning the Good: Prudence allows us to identify the appropriate means to achieve a virtuous end. It's about knowing what to do, when to do it, and how to do it.
  • Not Mere Cunning: Unlike mere cleverness, which can be used for good or ill, prudence is inherently directed towards the good. It is right reason in action.
  • The Charioteer of Virtues: Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, famously called prudence the "charioteer of the virtues," implying that it guides all other moral virtues, ensuring they hit their mark—the golden mean.

III. Temperance: The Mastery of Desire and the Virtue of Self-Control

Temperance (or sophrosyne in Greek thought) is the moral virtue concerned with the moderation of desires and pleasures, particularly those related to the body—food, drink, sex, and other sensual enjoyments. It is the virtue that prevents us from being enslaved by our appetites, allowing us to enjoy life's pleasures in a healthy and balanced way.

  • Finding the Mean: Temperance seeks the "golden mean" between the extremes of insensibility (a deficiency, e.g., an inability to enjoy anything) and intemperance (an excess, e.g., gluttony, lust).
  • Harmony of the Soul: Plato, in his Republic, saw temperance as a kind of harmony or agreement within the soul, where the rational part rightly governs the appetitive part.
  • Not Repression, but Regulation: The goal of temperance is not to eradicate pleasure, but to regulate it, ensuring that desires serve our overall well-being and rational ends, rather than dominating them.

IV. The Symbiotic Relationship: Prudence as the Compass for Temperance

Here lies the crux of our discussion: temperance cannot truly flourish as a virtue without the guiding hand of prudence. Without prudence, temperance is blind; it lacks the capacity to discern what constitutes true moderation in any given situation.

Consider the following ways Prudence informs and perfects Temperance:

  • Defining the "Just Right" Measure: What constitutes a "moderate" amount of food, drink, or leisure is highly contextual. Prudence assesses the specific circumstances—one's health, goals, social setting, and even the long-term consequences—to determine the appropriate measure. Without this discernment, temperance might default to rigid denial (a form of imprudent asceticism) or easily succumb to indulgence.
  • Distinguishing Healthy Enjoyment from Excess: Prudence helps us differentiate between legitimate, life-enhancing pleasures and those that lead to harm or distraction from higher goods. It asks, "Is this particular pleasure, at this time, in this amount, truly good for me and my flourishing?"
  • Guiding Our Appetites Towards Virtue: Our desires are powerful. Prudence acts as the rational faculty that directs these desires towards ends that align with our overall good. It provides the "how" and "when" for the "what" of temperance. For example, temperance dictates a healthy diet, but prudence helps select which foods, how much, and when to eat them, considering nutritional needs, ethical sourcing, and social context.
  • Preventing Vices of Deficiency and Excess: An imprudent person might either starve themselves out of a misguided notion of purity (a deficiency in enjoyment) or overindulge, leading to ill health and moral degradation (an excess). Prudence helps temperance navigate this narrow path, avoiding both extremes.

(Image: A classical fresco depicting a female figure personifying Prudence, holding a mirror to reflect self-knowledge and a snake representing foresight, gently guiding the hand of another female figure personifying Temperance, who is carefully pouring water from one vessel into another, symbolizing moderation and the mixing of wine with water.)

V. Virtue and Vice: The Perils of Imprudence in Temperance

The absence or corruption of prudence inevitably leads to Vice. If prudence is lacking, temperance cannot find its proper expression, often resulting in one of two extremes:

  • Intemperance (Vice of Excess): This is the more commonly recognized vice. Without prudent deliberation, desires run wild. Gluttony, drunkenness, and lust are direct consequences of a failure in practical reason to guide and restrain appetites. The individual becomes enslaved to immediate gratification, neglecting long-term well-being and higher rational pursuits.
  • Insensibility/Rigid Asceticism (Vice of Deficiency): While often seen as less harmful, a complete denial of all pleasure can also be a vice. An overly strict, imprudent approach to temperance might lead to a life devoid of innocent joys, hindering human flourishing and potentially leading to other psychological or social imbalances. Prudence reminds us that pleasures, when enjoyed in moderation, are a natural and often beneficial part of life.

VI. Wisdom: The Broader Horizon

Ultimately, the synergy between prudence and temperance contributes to a broader sense of Wisdom. Prudence itself is a form of wisdom—specifically, practical wisdom concerning human action. By exercising prudence in areas governed by temperance, we not only achieve self-mastery but also cultivate a deeper understanding of what constitutes a truly good and meaningful life. This integrated approach to virtue brings us closer to the Aristotelian ideal of eudaimonia, or human flourishing.

VII. Conclusion: A Harmonious Life Through Guided Self-Control

The teachings enshrined in the Great Books of the Western World consistently underscore the vital role of reason in shaping our moral character. The relationship between prudence and temperance is a prime example of this. Prudence provides the intellectual compass, guiding our choices and actions, while temperance provides the disciplined will to follow that guidance, especially in the realm of our desires and pleasures. To cultivate temperance without prudence is to navigate without a map; to possess prudence without temperance is to know the right path but lack the will to walk it. Together, they offer a powerful framework for living a life of balance, self-mastery, and genuine human flourishing.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Temperance"
2. ## 📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Thomas Aquinas Virtues Prudence Temperance"

Share this post