The Guiding Hand: The Role of Prudence in Temperance

Summary: This article explores the profound and often underestimated relationship between Prudence and Temperance, arguing that the former is the indispensable intellectual virtue that guides and perfects the latter. Drawing upon the rich tradition of the Great Books of the Western World, we will see how Prudence (or practical wisdom) provides the necessary foresight, judgment, and right reason to achieve the balanced, self-controlled state that defines Temperance, thereby helping us navigate the treacherous waters between virtue and vice.

In the grand tapestry of human virtues, few are as frequently discussed, yet as subtly misunderstood, as Temperance. Often reduced to mere abstinence or self-denial, its true essence — a harmonious balance in our desires and appetites — is far more nuanced. But how does one achieve this delicate equilibrium? The answer, as the great philosophers from Aristotle to Aquinas have illuminated, lies in the guiding light of Prudence. Without Prudence, Temperance remains a blind aspiration, prone to misdirection or excess.

Unpacking the Virtues: Prudence and Temperance Defined

Before we delve into their intricate dance, let us clearly define our terms.

  • Temperance (Sophrosyne): At its core, Temperance is the moral virtue that moderates our natural appetites and desires, particularly those related to pleasure (food, drink, sex, comfort). It is not the suppression of these desires, but their right ordering, ensuring they serve our overall well-being and rational nature, rather than dominating us. It seeks the "mean" between the vice of excess (intemperance or gluttony) and the vice of deficiency (insensibility or asceticism).

  • Prudence (Phronesis/Prudentia): Often translated as practical wisdom, Prudence is an intellectual virtue. It is the ability to discern the appropriate course of action in a given situation, to deliberate well about what is good and bad for human life, and to execute that judgment effectively. Prudence is the charioteer of the virtues, guiding them all towards their proper end. It involves foresight, circumspection, and caution.

The Intertwined Nature: Prudence as the Charioteer of Temperance

Imagine Temperance as a ship navigating a vast ocean. Without a skilled navigator – without Prudence – the ship, no matter how well-built, is at the mercy of currents and storms, likely to run aground or drift aimlessly.

  • Discerning the Right Measure: Temperance calls for moderation, but what constitutes "moderation" in any given circumstance? This is where Prudence steps in. It is Prudence that assesses the specific context – my health, my resources, the social setting, my long-term goals – and determines what amount of food, drink, or leisure is appropriate, beneficial, and aligned with my overall good. It prevents Temperance from becoming rigid asceticism on one hand, or slipping into indulgence on the other.

  • Foresight and Consequences: A hallmark of Prudence is its capacity for foresight. When considering an indulgence, Prudence doesn't just evaluate the immediate pleasure; it weighs the potential long-term consequences – health impacts, financial strain, reputational damage, or the erosion of discipline. This forward-looking aspect is crucial for sustaining Temperance, as it helps us resist immediate gratification for greater, more enduring goods.

  • The Mean Between Excess and Deficiency: Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, famously described virtue as a mean between two extremes of vice. For Temperance, these extremes are profligacy (excess) and insensibility (deficiency). It is Prudence that identifies this virtuous mean, not as a mathematical midpoint, but as a "relative to us" point, tailored to the individual and the situation.

    Virtue/Vice Spectrum Description Role of Prudence
    Excess (Vice) Unrestrained indulgence; letting appetites dominate reason. Identifies the dangers of overconsumption; guides towards restraint.
    Temperance (Virtue) Balanced moderation; appetites aligned with reason and good. Discerns the appropriate measure; judges the right time and place.
    Deficiency (Vice) Insensitivity to pleasure; undue suppression of natural desires. Prevents Temperance from becoming harmful asceticism; recognizes legitimate needs.

Wisdom in Action: How Prudence Guides Temperate Choices

Prudence is not merely theoretical wisdom; it is wisdom applied to action. It is the bridge between knowing what is good and actually doing it.

  • Deliberation and Judgment: When faced with a choice that engages our desires, Prudence orchestrates a process of careful deliberation. It gathers information, considers various options, and consults past experiences. From this deliberation, it forms a sound judgment, directing the will towards the temperate choice. This is the very essence of practical wisdom.

  • The Perils of Imprudence: Without Prudence, Temperance is fragile. An imprudent person might attempt to be temperate through sheer willpower, but without understanding the underlying reasons for moderation, or without the foresight to avoid tempting situations, their efforts are likely to fail. They might swing from extreme indulgence to extreme self-deprivation, never finding the true mean.

(Image: A classical fresco depicting a female figure, personifying Prudence, holding a mirror to reflect foresight and a serpent to symbolize wisdom, gently guiding the reins of a horse or chariot representing the passions, which are being moderated by a second figure, Temperance, who holds a cup from which water is being poured, symbolizing control over desires.)

Cultivating Prudence for a Tempered Life

The good news is that both Prudence and Temperance are cultivable virtues. They are not innate, but developed through habit, reflection, and intentional practice.

  1. Self-Knowledge: Understand your own desires, weaknesses, and triggers. Prudence requires an honest assessment of oneself.
  2. Learning from Experience: Reflect on past choices – both successes and failures – to refine your judgment.
  3. Seeking Counsel: Consult those who exhibit Prudence and Wisdom. Their perspective can illuminate paths you might not see.
  4. Practice Deliberation: Before making choices, especially those involving pleasure, pause and consider the short-term and long-term implications.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Prudence Phronesis""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Thomas Aquinas Cardinal Virtues Prudence Temperance""

Conclusion

The pursuit of a well-lived life, one marked by balance and self-mastery, is a timeless endeavor. As we navigate the complexities of modern existence, the ancient insights from the Great Books of the Western World remain profoundly relevant. Temperance, far from being a grim denial of life's pleasures, is a vibrant virtue that allows us to enjoy them rightly. But this virtue cannot stand alone. It requires the constant, discerning guidance of Prudence – that practical wisdom which illuminates the path, distinguishes virtue from vice, and ensures our appetites serve our highest good. To cultivate Temperance is to cultivate Prudence, for in their harmonious interplay lies the true art of living.

Share this post