The Unseen Hand: Unpacking the Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice

Desire, often dismissed as a mere impulse or a fleeting emotion, stands as a fundamental force in the human psyche, playing an integral role in shaping our character and directing our moral compass. From the ancient Greeks to modern ethicists, philosophers have grappled with the profound impact of desire on the development of both virtue and vice. This article explores how desire, when understood and managed through the faculty of will, can be a powerful engine for moral excellence or a perilous path to corruption, drawing insights from the rich tapestry of Western thought.

The Inescapable Urge: Defining Desire

At its core, desire is an inclination or an appetite towards something perceived as good or beneficial. It is the driving force behind our actions, the yearning for fulfillment, pleasure, knowledge, or even justice. Without desire, human beings would be inert, lacking the impetus for growth, creation, or even survival. However, the role of desire is not monolithic; its moral quality is determined by its object, its intensity, and, crucially, how it is engaged by our rational faculties and our will.

Ancient Wisdom: Reason's Chariot and Habit's Path

The philosophers of antiquity were acutely aware of desire's power.

  • Plato, in his Republic, famously depicted the soul as a charioteer (reason) guiding two winged horses: one noble and spirited (thumos), the other unruly and appetitive (epithumia). For Plato, virtue lay in reason's ability to control and harmonize these desires, preventing the appetites from leading the soul astray into vice. When reason fails to steer the chariot, the soul descends into disorder, driven by unbridled desires for pleasure or power.

  • Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, offered a more nuanced view. He recognized that desires (orexis) are not inherently bad; indeed, they are necessary for action. The key, for Aristotle, lies in habituating our desires to align with reason. A courageous person, for instance, desires to act bravely, not just because reason dictates it, but because their character has been trained to find satisfaction in such actions. Vice, conversely, arises when desires are excessive, deficient, or directed towards inappropriate objects, overriding rational judgment. The role of practical wisdom (phronesis) is to discern the right desire at the right time, in the right measure.

The Medieval Synthesis: Will, Love, and Divine Order

Christian philosophers integrated classical thought with theological perspectives, placing a greater emphasis on the will.

  • Augustine of Hippo, in Confessions and City of God, explored the concept of "disordered loves." For Augustine, sin is fundamentally a misdirection of desire – loving earthly things more than God, or loving them for their own sake rather than as reflections of divine goodness. The will plays a crucial role here, as it is the faculty by which we choose what to love. Virtue is achieved when the will directs all desires towards their proper end, ultimately God, while vice stems from a will enslaved by lower, temporal desires.

  • Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, distinguished between natural appetites and the rational appetite, or will (voluntas). He argued that while our sensory desires are often aimed at immediate gratification, our rational will seeks the universal good. Virtue involves the will's command over the lower appetites, bringing them into conformity with reason and divine law. Vice occurs when the will assents to disordered desires, choosing a particular, lesser good over the true, ultimate good.

(Image: A classical painting depicting Plato's Chariot Allegory, with a figure of Reason holding reins, struggling to control two horses representing spiritedness and appetite, one noble and the other wild, against a backdrop of celestial and earthly realms.)

Modern Currents: Passion, Duty, and Autonomy

The modern era brought new perspectives on the role of desire and the will.

  • David Hume, a Scottish Enlightenment philosopher, famously argued in A Treatise of Human Nature that "reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions, and can never pretend to any other office than to serve and obey them." For Hume, desires (passions) are the primary motivators, and reason's role is merely to find the most effective means to satisfy them. This view challenges the traditional hierarchy, suggesting that moral judgments arise from sentiments and desires, not from pure reason.

  • Immanuel Kant, conversely, sought to establish morality on a foundation of pure reason, independent of desire. For Kant, truly moral actions stem from a good will acting out of duty, in accordance with universal moral laws, rather than from inclination or desire. An action performed out of desire for happiness or personal gain, even if it aligns with duty, lacks true moral worth. Virtue, in the Kantian sense, is the strength of will to act from duty, overcoming any conflicting desires. Vice is the failure of the will to uphold the moral law, succumbing to self-serving inclinations.

The Dual Nature of Desire: A Path to Both Good and Ill

The historical discourse reveals a consistent theme: desire is a force that requires direction. It is neither inherently good nor evil, but its role in virtue and vice is determined by its alignment with reason and the strength of the will.

Consider the following:

Aspect of Desire Path to Virtue Path to Vice
Courage Desire to protect the innocent; to uphold justice Desire for reckless endangerment; cowardice
Temperance Desire for health and moderation Desire for excessive pleasure (gluttony, lust)
Generosity Desire to help others; to share resources Desire for avarice; selfish accumulation
Justice Desire for fairness and equitable treatment Desire for unfair advantage; exploitation
Knowledge Desire to understand the world and oneself Desire for manipulative power; intellectual vanity

In each case, a rightly ordered desire, guided by reason and a strong will, leads to virtue. Conversely, a disordered or unrestrained desire can quickly degenerate into vice. The will acts as the crucial intermediary, the internal governor that can either assent to unruly impulses or direct our deepest longings towards noble ends.

Cultivating Virtuous Desire: The Will's Paramount Role

The journey towards virtue is, in large part, a journey of shaping and refining our desires. This is not about eradicating desire, which would be impossible and undesirable, but about educating it.

  1. Self-Awareness: Understanding the nature and origin of our desires.
  2. Rational Deliberation: Applying reason to evaluate the objects and consequences of our desires.
  3. Habituation: Through repeated virtuous acts, we train ourselves to desire what is good and shun what is vicious. This is where Aristotle's emphasis on habit truly shines.
  4. Strength of Will: The will is essential for choosing the good even when it conflicts with immediate, lower desires. It allows us to resist temptation and persist in the pursuit of higher values.

Ultimately, the role of desire in virtue and vice is profound and multifaceted. It is the raw material of human motivation, but its moral valence is determined by the guiding hand of reason and the steadfast resolve of the will. To live a virtuous life is to master one's desires, transforming them from potential enslavers into allies in the pursuit of human flourishing.

YouTube: "Plato's Chariot Allegory explained"
YouTube: "Aristotle Ethics Desire Will"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice philosophy"

Share this post