The Crucial Nexus: Desire's Role in Virtue and Vice

A Fundamental Force in Human Character

Desire, that persistent and often unruly engine of human action, stands at the very heart of our moral landscape. It is neither inherently good nor evil, but rather a powerful, shaping force whose role in the development of virtue and vice is determined by its alignment with reason and the direction of our will. From the ancient Greeks to the Enlightenment thinkers, philosophers have grappled with how our appetites and longings can elevate us to the highest moral character or plunge us into depravity. This article explores the intricate relationship between desire, reason, and will, illustrating how this dynamic interaction defines our ethical journey.

Desire: The Primal Urge and Its Philosophical Scrutiny

At its most basic, desire is an inclination towards something perceived as good or away from something perceived as bad. It is a fundamental aspect of life, driving us to seek sustenance, comfort, knowledge, and companionship. However, this raw energy requires guidance, for uncontrolled desire can lead to ruin, while properly directed desire can be the fuel for noble pursuits.

Early Philosophical Perspectives on Desire

The Great Books of the Western World offer a rich tapestry of thought on desire:

  • Plato's Tripartite Soul (from The Republic): Plato famously divided the soul into three parts:

    • Reason (λογιστικόν): Seeks truth and wisdom, the charioteer.
    • Spirit (θυμοειδές): Seeks honor and glory, the noble horse.
    • Appetite/Desire (ἐπιθυμητικόν): Seeks bodily pleasures and material goods, the unruly horse.
      For Plato, virtue arises when reason, aided by spirit, controls and directs the appetitive desires. Vice emerges when appetite overpowers reason, leading to a disordered soul.

  • Aristotle's Ethics of Character (from Nicomachean Ethics): Aristotle saw desire not as something to be suppressed entirely, but as raw material to be habituated and refined. He argued that virtue is a state of character concerned with choice, lying in a mean relative to us, determined by reason. This "mean" is not merely about suppressing desires, but about desiring the right things, at the right time, in the right amount, for the right reasons.

    • Right Desire: The virtuous person desires what is good and noble (the kalon).
    • Wrong Desire: The vicious person desires excessive or base pleasures.

  • The Stoic Path to Tranquility: For Stoics like Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius, desires for external things (wealth, pleasure, reputation) were sources of suffering. True virtue lay in aligning one's will with nature and exercising control over one's internal reactions to external events. Desires were to be examined, and only those within one's control (e.g., desires for justice, wisdom) were to be cultivated. Indifference (ἀπάθεια) to desires for externals was key to achieving ataraxia (tranquility).

The Will: The Director of Desire

While desire provides the impetus, it is the will that acts as the crucial intermediary, determining how desires are engaged. The will is our faculty of conscious choice and decision, and its strength and orientation are paramount in the development of virtue and vice.

The Interplay of Desire and Will:

| Aspect | Description | Impact on Virtue

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice philosophy"

Share this post