The Double-Edged Sword: The Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice

By Henry Montgomery

Summary: Desire, a fundamental wellspring of human action, stands at the very crossroads of our moral development. Far from being a simple impulse, its intricate relationship with our will and reason determines whether we ascend to virtue or descend into vice. Drawing from the profound insights of the Great Books of the Western World, we explore how desire, when properly cultivated and guided, can be a potent force for good, yet when left unchecked or misdirected, it becomes the architect of our failings. Understanding this dynamic is crucial for anyone seeking to comprehend the human condition and the enduring quest for ethical living.

The Primal Urge: Understanding Desire's Foundation

At the heart of human experience lies desire—the longing, the yearning, the impulse towards something perceived as good or necessary. From the simplest physical cravings to the most complex aspirations of the spirit, desire is an undeniable engine of life. Yet, its very power makes it a complex subject for moral philosophy. Is desire inherently good, bad, or merely neutral, awaiting the imprimatur of our will? The great thinkers have grappled with this question for millennia, revealing its profound role in shaping our character.

Consider the early Greek philosophers, particularly Plato and Aristotle. For Plato, in works like The Republic, the soul is tripartite: the rational, the spirited, and the appetitive. The appetitive part, driven by desires for food, drink, and bodily pleasures, must be kept in check by reason and the spirited part for a harmonious, virtuous individual and state. Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, acknowledges desires as natural components of human nature. They are not inherently vice but become so when they are excessive, deficient, or directed towards inappropriate objects, overriding reason's guidance.

Desire as a Pathway to Virtue: The Cultivation of Aspiration

It would be a grave error to dismiss all desires as impediments to virtue. Indeed, many philosophers argue that certain desires are essential for moral flourishing.

  • The Desire for the Good and Beautiful: Plato posited an innate human yearning for the Good, the True, and the Beautiful. This desire, when properly understood and directed by reason, elevates the soul towards higher forms of knowledge and being, which are inherently virtuous. It is the desire to know, to create, to connect, that propels us beyond mere survival.
  • Habituated Desires: Aristotle emphasized the importance of habituation. A virtuous person isn't merely one who acts virtuously, but one who desires to act virtuously. Through repeated good actions, our appetites themselves become aligned with reason, making it pleasurable to do what is right. For instance, a brave person not only performs courageous acts but also desires to face danger appropriately, rather than being overcome by fear.
  • Love as an Ordered Desire: For figures like Augustine and Aquinas, love is a primary form of desire. When this love is rightly ordered—directed towards God, neighbor, and self in proper measure—it becomes the highest virtue (charity). The desire for justice, for truth, for the well-being of others, are all virtuous desires that drive ethical behavior.

Table: Philosophical Perspectives on Desire's Role

Philosopher/School View of Desire Role in Virtue/Vice Interplay with Will
Plato Appetitive, spirited parts of soul; desire for the Good Properly ordered leads to virtue (harmony); disordered to vice (tyranny) Reason (will) must govern and direct
Aristotle Natural, can be rational or irrational Proper habituation and reason's guidance lead to virtue (the mean); excess/deficiency to vice Will (choice) directs desires towards habituated ends; continence is a struggle
Stoics External, often irrational passions (pathe) Source of suffering and vice if untamed; apathy (freedom from disturbing passions) is virtuous Will (assent/disassent) controls reactions to desires, distinguishing what's in our power
Augustine Love as primary desire; can be ordered or disordered Disordered love (cupidity) leads to sin/vice; ordered love (charity) leads to virtue Will is fallen, struggles to choose good over disordered desire, requiring grace
Kant Inclination, distinct from moral duty Moral action not based on desire (heteronomy); acting from duty (good will) is virtuous (autonomy) Good will acts independently of desire, from duty and universalizable maxims

The Descent into Vice: When Desire Goes Astray

Conversely, the uncontrolled or misdirected desire is a primary architect of vice. This is a recurring theme across the Great Books.

  • Excess and Deficiency: Aristotle's doctrine of the mean directly links vice to desires. Cowardice is a deficiency of the desire for appropriate risk-taking, while recklessness is an excess. Gluttony, lust, and greed are all vices born from unrestrained appetitive desires. The key is moderation, guided by practical wisdom.
  • Disordered Love (Cupidity): Augustine, in Confessions and City of God, vividly portrays how human sin arises from disordered love. When we love lesser goods more than higher goods, or seek goods in inappropriate ways, our desires become distorted, leading to moral corruption. The desire for power, wealth, or sensual pleasure, when elevated above love for God or neighbor, begets all manner of vice.
  • The Struggle of the Will: The internal battle between desire and will is a central drama in human morality. Many philosophers, from Aristotle (discussing akrasia or weakness of will) to Augustine (on the fallen will), acknowledge that we often know what is right but are overcome by strong desires. Immanuel Kant, in his ethical framework, posits that truly moral actions stem from a good will acting out of duty, not from mere inclination or desire. For Kant, acting purely from desire, even if the outcome is good, lacks true moral worth because it is heteronomous (governed by something external to reason).

(Image: A classical marble statue depicting a figure, perhaps Hercules or Atlas, straining under a burden or wrestling with an unseen force, symbolizing the internal struggle of the will against powerful, unruly desires.)

The Interplay of Desire and Will: Directing Our Moral Compass

The crucial pivot point in the role of desire in virtue and vice is the will. It is the faculty through which we choose, decide, and act.

  • The Will as Governor: For many, the will is intended to be the governor of our desires. Reason informs the will, and the will then directs or restrains our appetites. A virtuous person possesses a strong will, aligned with reason, that can guide desires towards appropriate ends.
  • The Will's Vulnerability: However, the will itself can be weak or corrupted. Augustine's profound exploration of sin highlights how the will itself can become enslaved by disordered desires, making it difficult to choose the good. This internal bondage is a significant aspect of vice.
  • Nietzsche's Re-evaluation: Friedrich Nietzsche, challenging traditional morality, viewed desire (or "instincts") and the "will to power" not as something to be overcome, but as fundamental expressions of life. For him, the ascetic denial of desire could itself be a vice, a sign of weakness, whereas a strong will might channel and sublimate desires into creative, life-affirming endeavors, leading to a "master morality." His perspective forces a radical re-evaluation of what constitutes virtue and vice in relation to our deepest drives.

Cultivating Virtuous Desires: A Lifelong Endeavor

Given the profound influence of desire, the path to virtue necessarily involves its cultivation and management.

  1. Self-Knowledge: Understanding the nature of our own desires—where they come from, what they truly seek—is the first step.
  2. Rational Deliberation: Applying reason to evaluate desires: Are they good? Are they proportionate? Do they align with our higher values?
  3. Habituation and Discipline: Through consistent practice, we can train our desires. Just as an athlete trains their body, a moral agent trains their appetites to find pleasure in virtuous actions and aversion to vicious ones.
  4. Moral Education: Exposure to philosophical insights, ethical frameworks, and exemplary lives helps shape our understanding of what is truly desirable and good.

The role of desire in shaping virtue and vice is not a simple matter of good versus evil impulses. It is a dynamic interplay with reason and the will, an ongoing challenge that defines much of our moral struggle and our potential for greatness. By understanding its power, we gain insight into the perennial human quest for a well-lived life.

YouTube Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Desire Virtue Will""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Stoic Philosophy Control Desires Passions""

Share this post