The Unseen Hand: Desire's Pivotal Role in Virtue and Vice
Desire, often viewed with suspicion or as a mere biological impulse, is in fact a fundamental engine of human action and a critical determinant in the formation of both virtue and vice. Far from being a simple craving, desire — in its multifaceted forms from base appetite to noble aspiration — shapes our character, informs our choices, and ultimately defines our moral landscape. This article explores the role of desire as an indispensable force, which, when guided by reason and Will, can lead to profound virtue, or, when left unchecked or misdirected, can plunge us into vice. Drawing insights from the enduring wisdom contained within the Great Books of the Western World, we shall see that understanding and managing our desires is not merely a psychological task, but the very essence of ethical living.
The Double-Edged Sword of Human Aspiration
At its core, desire is an inclination towards something perceived as good or beneficial. Whether it is the desire for food, companionship, knowledge, or justice, it propels us forward. However, the object of desire and the manner in which we pursue it are what distinguish virtue from vice. The ancient philosophers, particularly Plato and Aristotle, recognized this inherent duality. For them, desire was not to be eradicated but rather understood, educated, and integrated into a harmonious whole guided by reason.
(Image: A detailed classical fresco depicting a charioteer, representing Reason, skillfully guiding two powerful horses; one, spirited and noble, symbolizing the spirited part of the soul, and the other, unruly and driven by base appetites, symbolizing the appetitive part. The charioteer's reins are taut, suggesting a delicate balance of control and direction amidst the horses' divergent pulls, all set against a backdrop of an ascending, winding path.)
Desire as a Catalyst for Virtue
When properly aligned with reason and directed by a strong Will, desire becomes the very impetus for virtuous living.
- Desire for the Good: Many virtues spring from a desire for what is truly good and noble. The desire for justice fuels the just person; the desire for truth motivates the philosopher; the desire for well-being inspires compassion. This is not merely an intellectual assent, but an emotional and volitional pull towards commendable ends.
- Habituation and Pleasure: Aristotle famously argued that to be truly virtuous, one must not only do virtuous acts but also take pleasure in them. This means cultivating desires such that one genuinely wants to act courageously, temperately, or generously. The Will, through repeated virtuous acts, trains our desires to find satisfaction in the right things.
- The Pursuit of Eudaimonia: The ultimate desire for many classical thinkers was eudaimonia, or human flourishing. This comprehensive well-being is not achieved through fleeting pleasures but through a life lived in accordance with virtue. The Will directs our various desires towards this overarching goal, integrating them into a coherent, meaningful existence.
Consider the following examples:
| Virtue | Underlying Desire (Rightly Directed) | Pitfall (Misdirected Desire) |
|---|---|---|
| Courage | To protect what is right; to overcome fear for a greater good | Recklessness; Cowardice |
| Temperance | To enjoy pleasures moderately; to maintain self-control | Gluttony; Asceticism |
| Justice | To ensure fairness and equity; to uphold what is due | Greed; Partiality |
| Wisdom | To understand truth; to live well through knowledge | Ignorance; Sophistry |
Desire as the Root of Vice
Conversely, desires that are untamed, excessive, or directed towards ignoble ends are fertile ground for vice.
- Unchecked Appetites: When our basic desires for pleasure (food, sex, comfort) are allowed to dominate without the guidance of reason or the restraint of Will, they lead to vices like gluttony, lust, and sloth. These desires, though natural, become destructive when they usurp the place of higher goods.
- Misdirected Aspirations: Not all destructive desires are purely physical. The desire for power, recognition, or wealth, while not inherently evil, can become a vice when pursued without ethical considerations. Envy, ambition, and avarice arise from desires that are either excessive or aimed at objects that do not genuinely contribute to human flourishing, or worse, harm others.
- The Weakness of Will (Akrasia): A crucial aspect where desire clashes with Will is akrasia, or incontinence. Here, an individual knows what is right but is overcome by a contrary desire. The Will fails to assert its authority, allowing the immediate gratification of a lesser desire to triumph over reasoned judgment, thus leading to vicious action.
The Interplay of Desire, Reason, and Will
The journey from raw desire to virtuous action is orchestrated by the intricate interplay of desire, reason, and Will.
- Plato's Tripartite Soul: Plato's analogy of the charioteer (reason) guiding two horses (the spirited and appetitive parts of the soul) vividly illustrates this. Reason's role is to understand the true good, the spirited part (our drive for honor, anger, ambition) can be an ally in pursuing it, and the appetitive part (basic desires) must be disciplined and directed. Without the charioteer's skillful Will, the horses would run wild, leading to chaos and vice.
- Aristotle's Practical Wisdom (Phronesis): For Aristotle, phronesis is the intellectual virtue that allows us to deliberate about what is good for us and to act accordingly. It is not enough to desire the good; one must also know how to achieve it. Practical wisdom helps us determine the appropriate measure and object for our desires, steering us away from excess and deficiency.
- Stoic Management of Passions: The Stoics emphasized aligning our Will with nature and reason. They distinguished between natural, rational desires (e.g., for health) and irrational passions (e.g., excessive anger, fear, lust). The goal was not to eliminate desire entirely, but to ensure that our desires are in harmony with what is within our control and conducive to tranquility.
- Augustine's Ordered Love: For Augustine, virtue is ultimately about rightly ordered love (desire). When we desire God above all else, our other loves and desires fall into their proper place. Vice stems from disordered love, where lesser goods (material wealth, worldly power) are loved more than higher goods. The Will plays a central role in directing this love.
- Kant's Good Will: While Kant emphasized acting from duty rather than inclination, even for him, the Will remains central. A good Will is one that acts from respect for the moral law, irrespective of personal desire. However, he acknowledged that a virtuous person might also desire to do their duty, suggesting an ideal alignment between Will and well-formed inclination.
Cultivating Virtuous Desire
The understanding that desire is moldable offers hope and direction for ethical development. Cultivating virtue involves a conscious effort to educate our desires.
- Self-Reflection: Regularly examining the objects of our desires helps us discern whether they lead to genuine good or merely fleeting pleasure.
- Habituation: Repeatedly choosing virtuous actions, even when against immediate inclination, strengthens the Will and gradually reshapes our desires. Over time, we begin to desire what is good.
- Moral Education: Learning from the wisdom of others, engaging with philosophical texts, and seeking guidance can illuminate the path to rightly ordered desires.
- Emulation: Observing and aspiring to emulate individuals who embody virtue can inspire us to cultivate similar desires.
In conclusion, desire is not an extraneous force to be ignored or suppressed, but an intrinsic and powerful component of human nature, inextricably linked to both virtue and vice. The role of desire is to provide the impetus for action, but it is the Will, guided by reason and practical wisdom, that directs this impetus towards flourishing or decay. To understand ourselves and to strive for a good life, we must first understand, and then wisely govern, the profound currents of our desires.
YouTube: "Plato's Chariot Allegory Explained"
YouTube: "Aristotle's Ethics: Virtue and Happiness"
📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics
Video by: The School of Life
💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice philosophy"