The Double-Edged Sword: Examining the Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice
Desire, often perceived as a mere impulse, stands as a fundamental force shaping human character. Far from being a simple inclination, its role is profoundly complex, acting as a crucial determinant in the development of both virtue and vice. This article explores how philosophers throughout the Great Books of the Western World have grappled with desire, revealing its potential to elevate us to the highest moral excellences or to drag us into the depths of moral degradation, all mediated by the pivotal faculty of the will. Ultimately, understanding desire is key to comprehending the very essence of human morality and the perennial struggle for self-governance.
The Primal Urge and the Moral Compass
At its core, desire is an inclination towards something perceived as good or advantageous. From the simplest physiological needs to the most complex intellectual aspirations, desire impels us to act. But what distinguishes a virtuous desire from a vicious one? And how does our inner moral compass navigate this powerful current? Ancient philosophers, particularly, recognized that desire itself is neither inherently good nor bad; its moral valence is determined by its object, its intensity, and, crucially, its alignment with reason and the human will.
Desire in Ancient Thought: From Appetites to Aspiration
The earliest philosophical inquiries into ethics placed desire at the heart of their analyses, recognizing its profound impact on human conduct and character.
Plato's Tripartite Soul: Ordering the Inner Realm
In Plato's Republic, the human soul is famously divided into three parts:
- Reason (Logistikon): Seeks truth and wisdom, guides the soul.
- Spirit (Thymoeides): Associated with honor, courage, and indignation, acts as an ally to reason.
- Appetite (Epithymetikon): Encompasses bodily desires such as hunger, thirst, and sexual urges.
For Plato, virtue arises when reason, like a skilled charioteer, guides the spirited and appetitive parts of the soul. Disordered desires—when the appetites dominate reason—lead directly to vice. A soul ruled by unbridled appetites is unjust and chaotic, incapable of true happiness. The will here is implicitly linked to reason's capacity to assert control and direct the soul towards the Good.
Aristotle and the Cultivation of Character
Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, offers a more nuanced view, emphasizing the role of habituation and practical wisdom (phronesis) in shaping desires. He distinguishes between different forms of orexis (desire or appetite):
- Appetite (Epithymia): Desires for pleasure, food, etc.
- Spirit (Thymos): Desires for honor, victory.
- Wish (Boulêsis): Rational desire for the good.
Aristotle argues that humans naturally desire what they perceive as good. The challenge lies in desiring the real good, not just the apparent good. Virtue is not merely knowing what is good, but desiring what is good and acting upon it consistently. This requires the will to be trained through repeated virtuous actions. Over time, our desires themselves become habituated to seek the mean, the virtuous path between excess and deficiency. For example, courage is the mean between the desire for reckless action (excess) and the desire to flee all danger (deficiency).
| Philosophical Perspective | View on Desire | Role of Will | Virtue & Vice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plato | Tripartite soul; appetites (desires) must be governed by reason. | Implicit in reason's control over appetites. | Virtue: Reason controls appetites. Vice: Appetites dominate reason. |
| Aristotle | Natural inclination towards perceived good; needs habituation & practical wisdom. | Crucial for choosing and habituating desires towards the real good. | Virtue: Desires aligned with reason and the mean. Vice: Desires misdirected or excessive/deficient. |
The Christian Perspective: Disordered Love and the Will
With the advent of Christian thought, the concept of desire took on new dimensions, particularly concerning the fallen human condition and the concept of a corrupted will.
Augustine's Confessions and the Fallen Will
Saint Augustine's writings, particularly his Confessions, profoundly explore the struggle between the will and desire. For Augustine, after the Fall, human will is wounded, making it difficult to choose the good consistently. He distinguishes between:
- Caritas (Charitable Love): Rightly ordered love, directed towards God and neighbor.
- Cupiditas (Disordered Love): Selfish, worldly desire, misdirected and leading to sin.
Vice stems from cupiditas, a love of lesser goods over the supreme good (God). The will, though free, often finds itself enslaved by these disordered desires, necessitating divine grace for liberation and proper reorientation towards virtue.
Aquinas and the Rational Ordering of Appetites
Thomas Aquinas, drawing heavily on Aristotle and integrating it with Christian theology, further refined the understanding of desire. In his Summa Theologica, he categorized desires (or passions) into:
- Concupiscible Appetites: Related to simple good or evil (e.g., love, hatred, joy, sorrow).
- Irascible Appetites: Related to difficult good or evil (e.g., hope, fear, anger, daring).
Aquinas asserts that these appetites are natural and can be good or bad depending on their object and whether they are subject to reason and the will. The will, as a rational appetite, has the power to choose to follow or resist these passions. Virtue is achieved when these natural desires are ordered by reason, guided by natural law and divine grace, towards the true human good. Vice occurs when the will assents to disordered desires, allowing them to override reason.
The Will: The Arbiter of Desire's Direction
Across these philosophical traditions, the will emerges as the critical faculty that mediates between raw desire and moral action. It is the power to choose, to assent or dissent, to direct our inclinations.
- In Virtue: The will aligns with reason, choosing to satisfy desires in a proportionate, appropriate, and morally sound manner. It actively cultivates good habits, making virtuous choices easier over time.
- In Vice: The will succumbs to uncontrolled desires, allowing them to dictate action without the guidance of reason or moral principle. This can manifest as weakness of will (akrasia), where one knows the good but fails to act on it due to overwhelming desire, or as a deliberate choice of evil.
The Path to Virtue: Harmonizing Desire with Reason
The journey to virtue is largely a journey of self-mastery, where our desires are not eradicated but rather harmonized and integrated with our rational faculties. This involves:
- Discernment: Using reason to distinguish between true and apparent goods.
- Moderation: Cultivating the ability to feel desires in the right amount, at the right time, and for the right reasons.
- Habituation: Repeatedly choosing virtuous actions until they become second nature, thereby shaping our desires themselves.
The Descent into Vice: When Desire Reigns Unchecked
Conversely, the path to vice is paved by unchecked or misdirected desires. When the will consistently fails to exert its proper control, or actively chooses to indulge destructive desires, the individual becomes enslaved to their appetites. This leads to a disintegration of character, where short-term gratification overrides long-term well-being and moral integrity.
Image: A detailed illustration depicting Plato's Chariot Allegory. Two horses, one spirited and noble (representing Thymos), the other unruly and base (representing Epithymia), are pulling a chariot. A human charioteer (representing Logos or Reason) holds the reins firmly, attempting to guide both horses forward, indicating the struggle and skill required to direct the soul towards virtue.
Conclusion: The Enduring Challenge of Self-Governance
The role of desire in virtue and vice is one of the most enduring and profound themes in philosophy. From the ancient Greeks to the Christian scholastics, thinkers have recognized desire as an indispensable, yet potentially perilous, component of human nature. The ultimate arbiter in this moral drama is the will, which possesses the capacity to either harness desire for the pursuit of the good or surrender to its destructive impulses. The ongoing human project, then, is to cultivate a will strong enough to align our desires with reason, fostering a life of virtue and genuine flourishing.
YouTube: "Plato's Chariot Allegory explained"
YouTube: "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Desire and Virtue"
📹 Related Video: ARISTOTLE ON: The Nicomachean Ethics
Video by: The School of Life
💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Role of Desire in Virtue and Vice philosophy"