The Inescapable Current: Desire as the Prime Mover of Man

Summary: Desire is not merely a fleeting emotion but a fundamental, often primal, driver of human action, shaping our choices, aspirations, and very understanding of the man. This article delves into the profound role desire plays in initiating motion towards perceived goods or away from perceived ills, engaging with the complex relationship between primal urges and the guiding force of the will. Drawing from the rich tapestry of Western thought, we shall examine how desire manifests in both our greatest achievements and our most profound struggles, ultimately revealing its inescapable presence and influence in the human condition.

The Inescapable Current: Desire as the Prime Mover of Man

From the moment of our birth, desire courses through us, an undeniable current propelling us forward. It is the longing for sustenance, the yearning for connection, the ambition for achievement, and the dread of suffering. Indeed, one might argue that without desire, man would be an inert being, devoid of purpose or motion. The role of desire is not merely incidental; it is foundational, acting as the very engine that drives all human action, from the simplest instinctual reflex to the most complex philosophical inquiry. But what exactly is this potent force, and how does it interact with our capacity for reason and will?

Desire's Dual Nature: The Engine of Aspiration and the Chains of Passion

Desire, in its essence, is a reaching out, an inclination towards something perceived as good or away from something perceived as bad. It is a powerful motivator, capable of inspiring monumental feats of creativity, endurance, and love. Yet, it can also be the source of our deepest conflicts, leading to irrationality, vice, and suffering. This dual nature has been a central theme in philosophical discourse for millennia.

The Classical View: Rational and Irrational Desires

Ancient Greek philosophers meticulously dissected the nature of desire. Plato, in his Republic, famously used the allegory of the Charioteer to illustrate the soul's tripartite division: the rational part (the charioteer), the spirited part (the noble horse), and the appetitive part (the unruly horse). The appetitive part represents our base desires—for food, drink, sex, wealth—which, if unchecked by reason and spirit, can pull the soul astray. The role of reason, then, is to guide these powerful horses, directing their energy towards a harmonious and virtuous life.

Aristotle, too, recognized the driving force of desire. For him, all human action is ultimately aimed at some perceived good, with the ultimate good being eudaimonia, or human flourishing. Desires, therefore, are not inherently bad; rather, they are impulses that can be properly ordered by reason to achieve this ultimate goal. A virtuous man is one whose desires are aligned with reason, seeking the right things, at the right time, in the right measure.

Augustine's Inner Conflict: The Soul's Tug-of-War

Moving into the Christian tradition, St. Augustine wrestled profoundly with the role of desire, particularly in the context of sin and redemption. His Confessions lay bare the intense inner struggle between spiritual aspirations and earthly lusts. For Augustine, fallen man is often enslaved by desires that pull him away from God, highlighting a fundamental tension between the will (which ideally seeks God) and the unruly passions of the flesh. This perspective emphasizes that while desire is inherent, its direction and ultimate object are critical for the soul's well-being.

The Will's Dominion: Directing the Torrent of Desire

If desire is the raw power, then the will is often conceived as the steering mechanism, the faculty that allows us to choose, to deliberate, and to act. The relationship between desire and will is complex and has been a battleground for philosophers debating free will versus determinism.

Freedom and Determinism: The Will's Apparent Choice

Does our will truly possess the freedom to override or redirect our desires, or are our choices merely the inevitable outcome of our strongest desires and external influences? Philosophers like Baruch Spinoza, for instance, argued that what we perceive as free will is often just our ignorance of the true causes (our desires, passions, and external forces) that determine our actions. For Spinoza, true freedom lies not in transcending desire, but in understanding its necessity and aligning our understanding with the rational order of nature. Conversely, many philosophers uphold the role of the will as a truly autonomous agent, capable of choosing against even the most powerful desires, thereby asserting man's moral responsibility.

Kant's Categorical Imperative: Duty Beyond Inclination

Immanuel Kant offered a profound distinction between acting from desire (or inclination) and acting from duty. For Kant, a truly moral action is not one performed because it brings pleasure or satisfies a desire, but one performed solely out of respect for the moral law. The will, in Kant's philosophy, is the faculty of acting according to principles, and its highest expression is to choose the good because it is right, irrespective of personal desires or potential outcomes. This places the will in a position of supreme authority over desire, suggesting that true moral worth resides in our capacity to transcend our inclinations.

Modern Perspectives: Reshaping the Understanding of Desire

The understanding of desire continued to evolve, taking on new dimensions in later philosophical thought.

Nietzsche's Will to Power: A Revaluation of Instinct

Friedrich Nietzsche radically re-evaluated the role of desire, particularly in his concept of the Will to Power. For Nietzsche, desire is not merely about lacking something, but about an overflowing energy, a drive to overcome, to grow, and to assert oneself. He critiqued traditional morality for often seeking to suppress or deny these fundamental life-affirming instincts and desires. In Nietzsche's view, the authentic man embraces his desires, channeling them into creative and self-overcoming endeavors, rather than letting a reactive will or external moral codes stifle them.

Given desire's immense power and pervasive influence, how should a man navigate its complex terrain? Various philosophical schools have offered distinct, often contrasting, strategies:

  • Stoicism: Emphasizes control over one's internal reactions to external events and desires. The Stoics teach that while we cannot control what happens to us, we can control our judgments and desires. The goal is apatheia – not apathy in the modern sense, but freedom from disturbing passions, achieved by aligning one's will with reason and accepting what is beyond one's control.
  • Epicureanism: Advocates for a life of moderate pleasure, primarily by minimizing pain and fear. Epicurus believed that the highest good is tranquility (ataraxia) and freedom from bodily pain (aponia), achieved by satisfying only natural and necessary desires, while avoiding those that are unnatural, unnecessary, or lead to greater discomfort.
  • Aristotelian Virtue Ethics: Suggests that the virtuous man is one whose desires are properly habituated and guided by practical reason. Rather than suppressing desires entirely, the aim is to develop virtues that allow one to desire the right things, at the right time, and in the right amount, thereby leading to a flourishing life.
  • Buddhist Philosophy (though outside Great Books, it's a relevant counterpoint): Often highlights the cessation of desire (or craving, tanha) as the path to liberation from suffering. While not directly from the Great Books, its profound influence on Western thought's engagement with desire is undeniable.

Conclusion: The Indelible Mark of Desire on the Human Story

The role of desire in human action is undeniable and multifaceted. It is the fuel that powers our endeavors, the source of our deepest joys, and the root of our most profound sorrows. Whether viewed as an unruly beast to be tamed by reason and will, a natural force to be understood and channeled, or a fundamental expression of life's inherent drive, desire remains an indelible mark on the human story. To understand man is to understand his desires, and to grapple with the philosophical challenge of how to live well amidst their relentless pull. The journey through the history of Western thought reveals that the quest to comprehend and wisely direct our desires is, in essence, the quest for a meaningful and virtuous life.

(Image: A detailed classical painting depicting a robed figure, perhaps a philosopher or a king, seated thoughtfully. Two allegorical figures stand beside him: one, representing Desire, is a winged, impulsive youth reaching eagerly towards a distant, shimmering object; the other, representing Will, is a more stoic, muscular figure with a hand placed firmly on the philosopher's shoulder, gazing intently at a compass or a set of scales. The philosopher's expression is one of deep contemplation, caught between the two forces, with scrolls and ancient texts scattered at his feet.)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato Chariot Allegory explained""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Kant Duty vs Inclination""

Share this post