The Unseen Hand: Exploring the Role of Desire in Human Action

Human action, at its core, is rarely a spontaneous eruption; rather, it is almost invariably the outward manifestation of an inner impetus. This impetus, often profound and complex, is what we broadly term desire. From the simplest biological urge to the most sophisticated intellectual aspiration, desire acts as the fundamental engine driving the will and shaping the very nature of man. It is the initial spark, the magnetic pull that sets us on a course, compelling us to seek, to achieve, to avoid, and ultimately, to become. Without desire, the landscape of human endeavor would be barren, devoid of purpose and motion. This article delves into the indispensable role of desire as chronicled and debated by the philosophical giants within the Great Books of the Western World, revealing its intricate dance with reason and will in defining the human condition.

The Primal Urge: Desire as the Origin of Movement

Throughout philosophical history, thinkers have grappled with the origins of human motivation. Long before modern psychology, ancient philosophers understood that an internal longing or aversion preceded action.

  • Plato's Tripartite Soul: In The Republic, Plato famously describes the soul as having three parts: the rational, the spirited, and the appetitive. The appetitive part (epithymia) represents our basic desires for food, drink, and sensual pleasure. While often seen as base, it is nonetheless a powerful motivator. The spirited part (thymos) drives ambition and honor, another form of desire. It is the role of the rational part to guide and harmonize these desires, but the desires themselves are the initial drivers.
  • Aristotle's Orexis and the Good: Aristotle, in works like Nicomachean Ethics, posits that all action aims at some good. This striving for the good is rooted in orexis, or appetite/desire. He distinguishes between rational and irrational desires, but both serve to move the individual. For Aristotle, the will (prohairesis) is a "deliberate desire" – a desire that has been subject to reason and choice, demonstrating the inseparable link between desire and the rational faculty in the man of virtue.

These early observations firmly establish desire not merely as an emotion, but as a fundamental teleological force, directing beings towards an end, whether that end is immediate gratification or ultimate flourishing.

The Dynamic Duo: Desire and the Will

The relationship between desire and the will is one of the most enduring subjects in philosophy. Is the will merely a slave to desire, or can it exert mastery?

  • Augustine's Restless Heart: St. Augustine, in his Confessions, eloquently speaks of the human heart's restless desire for God. For Augustine, love itself is a form of desire, and the will is the instrument through which this love (or lack thereof) is directed. He explores the profound struggle when the will is weak and succumbs to lower desires, highlighting the internal conflict inherent in man.
  • Aquinas' Rational Appetite: St. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, defines the will as a "rational appetite." This means the will is naturally inclined towards the good, as apprehended by the intellect. While sensory desires (concupiscible and irascible appetites) can pull us in various directions, the intellect presents objects to the will as good, and the will then moves towards them. Here, the role of desire is to provide the initial inclination, but the will, guided by reason, makes the ultimate choice, affirming the potential for self-direction in man.

This interplay suggests that while desire provides the initial impetus, the will, particularly when informed by reason, possesses the power to choose which desires to pursue, which to temper, and which to reject.

The Spectrum of Desire's Influence

Philosophical Viewpoint Primary Role of Desire Relationship with Will Outcome for Man
Plato Fundamental appetitive force; energetic driver. Needs rational control; can lead to imbalance. Internal harmony or discord; virtue or vice.
Aristotle Striving for the good; basis for all action. Will is "deliberate desire"; reasoned choice. Flourishing (eudaimonia) through virtuous action.
Augustine Source of love/longing (even for God); restless. Will directs love; can be weak against sin/lower desires. Spiritual salvation or damnation; internal struggle.
Aquinas Rational appetite; inclination towards the good. Will chooses the good presented by intellect. Moral action; attainment of ultimate good (God).
Kant Inclination; distinct from duty. Will acts from duty, not from desire, for moral worth. Autonomy; moral law as the guide for rational beings.

Desire, Duty, and the Modern Man

The Enlightenment brought new perspectives on the role of desire, particularly with Immanuel Kant. For Kant, true moral action stems not from desire or inclination, but from duty, from adherence to the moral law discovered by reason. Acting from desire, even for a good outcome, does not carry moral worth in itself. This sharp distinction highlights the potential for tension between what man wants and what man ought to do. Kant's philosophy underscores the idea that the will must be autonomous, free from the dictates of empirical desires, to act morally.

However, even in Kant, desire is not eradicated; rather, its role is redefined. It becomes something to be overcome or, at the very least, not to be the primary motivator for moral action. This demonstrates the enduring philosophical challenge: how to reconcile the powerful, inherent force of desire with the demands of reason, morality, and self-mastery.

(Image: A detailed classical painting depicting Plato's Chariot Allegory. A charioteer (representing reason) holds the reins of two winged horses: one white and noble (representing the spirited element or righteous indignation) and one black and unruly (representing the appetitive desires). The charioteer struggles to guide the horses towards the heavens, symbolizing the soul's ascent towards truth and virtue through the mastery of its disparate parts.)

The Enduring Significance of Desire for Man

Ultimately, desire is an inescapable aspect of human existence. It is the wellspring of our ambitions, the fuel for our creativity, and the yearning that pushes us beyond our current limitations. From the desire for knowledge that drives scientific inquiry to the desire for beauty that inspires art, and the desire for connection that fosters communities, its role is pervasive.

However, the Great Books also serve as a profound warning: unchecked or misdirected desire can lead to chaos, suffering, and moral degradation. The struggle to understand, manage, and elevate our desires is a central theme in the human journey. It is through this struggle, through the exercise of will and reason, that man truly defines himself and shapes his destiny. The very essence of human freedom often lies not in the absence of desire, but in the intelligent and virtuous direction of it.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato's Chariot Allegory Explained Philosophy"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle on Desire and Will in Nicomachean Ethics"

Share this post