The Problem of Sin and Desire: A Perennial Philosophical Conundrum

Summary: The relationship between sin and desire stands as a foundational problem in Western thought, explored extensively throughout the Great Books of the Western World. This article delves into how human desire, a fundamental aspect of our being, can lead to actions considered sinful, raising profound questions about free will, morality, and the nature of Good and Evil. We will examine how philosophers and theologians have grappled with the inherent tension between our natural inclinations and our ethical responsibilities, seeking to understand where the line between healthy aspiration and moral transgression truly lies.

The Lure of Desire: A Philosophical Inquiry

From the moment of our birth, humans are creatures of desire. We crave sustenance, connection, knowledge, and meaning. This isn't merely a biological imperative; it's a driving force behind civilization, art, and personal growth. Philosophers from ancient Greece to the Enlightenment have recognized desire as central to the human condition. Plato, in works like the Phaedrus and Republic, describes the soul as having an appetitive part, a wellspring of desires for food, drink, and sexual gratification. Aristotle, too, understood human action as directed towards a telos, an ultimate good, often driven by desires for happiness (eudaimonia).

Yet, this very force, so essential for life, is also often implicated in what we perceive as wrong or sinful. The problem isn't desire itself, but its potential for misdirection, its capacity to overwhelm reason and lead us astray.

Defining Sin Beyond Dogma

When we speak of sin, it's easy to fall into purely theological definitions. However, philosophy, particularly in the tradition of the Great Books, offers a broader, more nuanced understanding. Philosophically, sin can be understood not just as a transgression against divine law, but as:

  • A deviation from reason: As articulated by Thomas Aquinas, sin is an act contrary to right reason, a failure to act in accordance with our rational nature.
  • A disorder of the soul: Augustine of Hippo famously viewed sin as a form of "disordered love," where one loves temporal goods more than eternal ones, or loves lesser goods inappropriately.
  • An act contrary to natural law: For many classical thinkers, including Cicero and Aquinas, there exists an inherent moral order discoverable by reason, and sin is a violation of this order.
  • An impediment to flourishing: From an Aristotelian perspective, sin can be seen as anything that hinders our ability to achieve our full human potential or eudaimonia.

The common thread is a departure from an ideal state, a harmony, or a proper ordering of the self and its relationship to the world and others.

The Interplay: When Desire Becomes Sinful

Herein lies the core of the problem: how does a natural, often vital, desire transform into a sinful act? The journey from innocent longing to moral transgression is complex and multifaceted, often hinging on intent, object, and the role of reason.

Consider the desire for food. It's a basic biological need. However, when this desire becomes gluttony—an excessive, uncontrolled consumption—it crosses into what many traditions would deem a sin. Similarly, the desire for love and companionship is natural, but when it manifests as illicit passion, jealousy, or exploitation, it becomes destructive.

The Great Books consistently highlight the critical role of reason and will in mediating this tension. It is through our rational faculties that we are meant to discern between desires that lead to Good and those that lead to Evil. The will, then, is tasked with choosing the path of virtue, even when faced with powerful, unruly desires.

Distinguishing Benign vs. Sinful Desire

Aspect Benign Desire Sinful Desire
Origin Natural human need or inclination Same natural human need or inclination
Object What is genuinely good, appropriate, or neutral What is perceived as good but is ultimately harmful, inappropriate, or excessive
Intent To flourish, achieve legitimate goals, connect To gratify self at the expense of others, disregard reason, or pursue lesser goods exclusively
Outcome Personal growth, societal benefit, harmony Self-destruction, harm to others, moral decay, spiritual disharmony
Reason's Role Governs, directs, and orders Overridden, corrupted, or ignored by passion

(Image: A classical painting depicting the allegory of Hercules at the crossroads, where he must choose between the path of virtue (represented by a serene, modest woman) and the path of vice (represented by a seductive, lavishly dressed woman). The scene captures the internal struggle between competing desires and the moral choice inherent in the human condition.)

Perspectives from the Great Books

The philosophical journey through the problem of sin and desire is a recurring theme across the Great Books of the Western World:

  • Plato's Tripartite Soul: In the Republic, Plato posits a soul divided into three parts: reason, spirit, and appetite. Sin, or injustice in the soul, occurs when the appetitive part, driven by base desires, overrides the rational part. The good life, therefore, is one where reason governs the passions, bringing the soul into harmony.
  • Augustine's Confessions: Saint Augustine provides a deeply personal account of this struggle. His early life was marked by a profound internal conflict between his intellectual pursuit of truth and his powerful carnal desires. He eventually concludes that sin is fundamentally a turning away from God, a misdirection of love (amor sui over amor Dei), and that true freedom lies in rightly ordering one's desires towards the ultimate Good.
  • Aquinas and Natural Law: Thomas Aquinas, synthesizing Aristotelian philosophy with Christian theology in the Summa Theologica, argues that human beings are naturally inclined towards the Good. Sin is thus a deviation from this natural inclination, a failure of reason to guide the will. Desire itself is not evil, but it becomes so when it leads us to choose something contrary to our rational nature and the divine law.
  • Milton's Paradise Lost: While a poetic work, Milton's epic explores the origins of sin through the lens of free will and temptation. Satan's desire for power and equality with God, and Eve's desire for knowledge and to be like God, are presented as the catalysts for the fall, illustrating how even noble-seeming desires, when disordered, can lead to catastrophic Evil.

These diverse perspectives all converge on the understanding that while desire is an intrinsic part of being human, its proper direction and governance by reason and will are paramount to avoiding sin and pursuing a life of Good. The tension between what we want and what is right remains a timeless challenge, requiring constant self-reflection and ethical discernment.

Conclusion: An Enduring Human Challenge

The problem of sin and desire is not a relic of ancient philosophy or religious dogma; it is an enduring human challenge. Every individual confronts the internal struggle between immediate gratification and long-term well-being, between selfish impulse and altruistic action. Understanding this dynamic, as illuminated by the profound insights of the Great Books of the Western World, offers us a framework for self-examination, ethical decision-making, and the pursuit of a more virtuous life. It reminds us that our desires, while powerful, are not our masters, and that through reason and cultivated will, we can strive towards the Good and mitigate the potential for Evil.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Theory of the Soul and Ethics""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Augustine on Sin and Free Will""

Share this post