The Enduring Riddle: Grappling with the Problem of Evil (Sin) in the World

The existence of evil in a world often posited as created or governed by a benevolent power presents one of philosophy's most profound and persistent dilemmas. This "Problem of Evil" is not merely an academic exercise; it touches the very core of human experience, challenging our understanding of justice, suffering, and the nature of reality itself. When we speak of Sin, we narrow the focus to a specific category of evil—that which arises from human moral transgression—but this only deepens the problem, for it raises questions about human freedom, divine foreknowledge, and the ultimate accountability for the suffering we inflict upon ourselves and others.

Unpacking the Core Dilemma

At its heart, the Problem of Evil can be succinctly stated: How can an all-powerful (omnipotent), all-knowing (omniscient), and all-good (omnibenevolent) God permit the existence of evil and suffering in the world? If God is truly omnipotent, He can prevent evil. If He is omniscient, He knows about evil. And if He is omnibenevolent, He wants to prevent evil. Yet, evil persists. This logical tension has vexed theologians and philosophers for millennia, from the ancient Greeks to the modern age.

Key Facets of the Problem:

  • Natural Evil: Suffering caused by natural phenomena (earthquakes, floods, disease, etc.) where human agency is not directly involved.
  • Moral Evil (Sin): Suffering caused by the deliberate actions or inactions of moral agents (war, murder, cruelty, injustice, etc.). This is where the concept of Sin becomes particularly salient.

Historical Perspectives on Good and Evil

The Great Books of the Western World are replete with attempts to grapple with this fundamental problem. Philosophers and theologians have approached Good and Evil from various angles, seeking to reconcile the observed reality of suffering with their metaphysical or theological frameworks.

Philosopher/Text Core Idea Regarding Evil/Sin
Plato Evil as a privation of the Good; a deviation from the perfect Forms. Ignorance is often a root cause.
Augustine of Hippo Evil as a privation of good (privatio boni), not a substance in itself. Attributed moral evil (Sin) primarily to human free will and the Fall.
Book of Job Explores the problem of undeserved suffering and divine justice, ultimately concluding with the inscrutability of God's ways rather than a definitive explanation.
Thomas Aquinas Evil as a defect or lack of perfection that ought to be present. God permits evil for the sake of a greater good or to preserve free will.
Fyodor Dostoevsky Through characters like Ivan Karamazov, he powerfully articulates the problem of innocent suffering (especially children) as a reason to reject divine harmony, even if it exists.

Augustine, drawing heavily from Neoplatonism, famously argued in his Confessions that evil is not a positive entity, but rather the absence or corruption of good. This idea was crucial for reconciling the existence of evil with an all-good creator. For him, Sin was the willful turning away from God, a choice made possible by free will, which he considered a great good in itself.

The Role of Sin in the Problem of Evil

When we introduce Sin into the discussion, the Problem shifts somewhat. Sin typically refers to moral transgression, a deliberate act against a divine or moral law. In many theological traditions, particularly Abrahamic ones, Sin is the primary source of moral evil in the world.

Key Arguments Related to Sin:

  1. The Free Will Defense: This is perhaps the most common theological response. It posits that God, in His benevolence, desired to create beings capable of genuine love and moral choice. For such freedom to be meaningful, the ability to choose evil (to Sin) must also exist. Without the freedom to choose wrong, there is no true freedom to choose right. Thus, God permits Sin as a necessary byproduct of granting free will.
  2. The Fall: Many traditions explain the prevalence of Sin and its consequences (suffering, death) through a foundational event, such as the biblical "Fall" of humanity. This narrative attributes the corrupted state of the world and human nature to an original act of disobedience.
  3. Soul-Making Theodicy: This perspective suggests that the world, with its inherent challenges and opportunities for Sin and suffering, is a "soul-making" environment. It is through grappling with moral choices, overcoming adversity, and learning from mistakes (including Sin) that humans can develop virtues like courage, compassion, and resilience.

(Image: A classical painting depicting Adam and Eve's expulsion from the Garden of Eden, with a serpent subtly visible in the background, symbolizing the introduction of sin and suffering into the world.)

However, even with these defenses, the problem is not entirely resolved. The sheer scale and intensity of suffering, particularly innocent suffering, often push the boundaries of these explanations. If free will is so precious, why does its abuse lead to such horrific consequences for the innocent? If Sin is a human choice, why does natural evil also exist? These questions continue to fuel philosophical and theological inquiry.

Enduring Questions and the Human Condition

The Problem of Evil (Sin) remains a potent challenge, not just to religious belief, but to any comprehensive understanding of the world. It forces us to confront the nature of Good and Evil, the limits of human understanding, and the boundaries of divine power or benevolence. Whether one seeks to reconcile evil with a divine plan, or to understand it purely within a secular framework, the problem compels us to examine our values, our responsibilities, and our place in a world often marked by both profound beauty and unbearable suffering. The ongoing dialogue, as evidenced throughout the Great Books, is a testament to humanity's persistent struggle to make sense of this fundamental mystery.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Problem of Evil Philosophy Explained""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Augustine on Evil and Free Will""

Share this post