The Philosophical Role of the Citizen: A Journey Through the Polis and Beyond

Summary: The concept of the Citizen is far more profound than mere legal status or residency; it is a deeply Philosophical construct, central to understanding human flourishing within the State. From the ancient Greek polis to the modern nation-state, thinkers have grappled with the obligations, rights, and inherent Duty that define an individual's relationship with their community. This article explores how Western philosophy has shaped our understanding of the Citizen's active, critical, and responsible role in shaping a just and good society.

Beyond Mere Membership: Defining the Philosophical Citizen

To speak of the Citizen is to invoke an ancient and enduring Philosophical inquiry into the nature of human association, the ideal State, and the individual's place within it. It's an exploration that transcends passports and birth certificates, delving into the very essence of what it means to be a participant in a collective endeavor. For Benjamin Richmond, the Citizen is not merely a subject of the State, but an active, thinking agent whose Duty is bound up with the pursuit of justice, the common good, and, ultimately, the good life.

The Great Books of the Western World reveal a consistent thread: the Citizen is perpetually at the heart of political and ethical discourse. From the foundational texts of Plato and Aristotle to the Enlightenment's social contract theorists, the question of what a Citizen is, and what they ought to do, remains paramount.

Ancient Foundations: The Citizen in the Polis

The cradle of Western political thought, ancient Greece, offers our earliest profound insights into the Philosophical Role of the Citizen. Here, the polis, or city-state, was not just a geographical location but a moral and cultural entity where human potential could be fully realized.

Plato's Republic: Duty and the Ideal State

In Plato's Republic, the concept of the Citizen is inextricably linked to the ideal State and the principle of justice. While Plato's vision of citizenship is hierarchical, with specialized roles for guardians, auxiliaries, and producers, it underscores a fundamental Philosophical Duty: each individual contributes their unique talents to the harmony and well-being of the whole. The philosopher-king, though not a Citizen in the conventional sense, embodies the intellectual Duty to guide the State towards truth and the good. For the common Citizen, their Duty was to fulfill their prescribed function, thereby contributing to the overall justice of the polis.

Aristotle's Politics: The Political Animal

Aristotle, in his Politics, famously declared that "man is by nature a political animal" (zoon politikon). For him, the Citizen is defined by their capacity to participate in the deliberative and judicial functions of the State. This is a radical departure from mere residency:

  • Active Participation: An Aristotelian Citizen is one who "shares in the administration of justice and in offices." This isn't passive membership but active engagement in ruling and being ruled.
  • Pursuit of the Good Life: The ultimate purpose of the polis is to enable its Citizens to live a virtuous and good life. The State is not merely for survival but for flourishing, and the Citizen's Duty involves contributing to this collective flourishing.
  • Virtue: A good Citizen is a virtuous one, possessing qualities like courage, temperance, and justice, which are essential for the health of the State.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting philosophers engaged in discourse within an agora, with citizens observing and participating, symbolizing the active intellectual life central to the ancient polis and the Philosophical Role of the Citizen.)

The Social Contract and the Modern Citizen's Duty

With the Enlightenment, the focus shifted from the organic unity of the polis to the individual and the conceptual agreement forming the State. The Philosophical understanding of the Citizen transformed, emphasizing rights, consent, and the basis of legitimate authority.

From Obligation to Rights: Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau

Philosopher Key Concept of the State Citizen's Primary Duty Citizen's Rights/Role
Thomas Hobbes Leviathan (Absolute Sovereign) To obey the sovereign absolutely for security. To preserve one's life by surrendering natural rights.
John Locke Limited Government (Consent) To uphold the law and respect natural rights. Natural rights (life, liberty, property); right to resist tyranny.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau General Will (Direct Democracy) To obey the General Will, which is one's own true will. To participate in forming the General Will; freedom found in obedience to self-imposed law.

These thinkers, foundational to the Great Books, redefine the Citizen's relationship with the State. For Locke, the Citizen possesses inherent rights that even the State cannot infringe upon, and their Duty includes holding the government accountable. Rousseau's vision is more demanding, where the Citizen is simultaneously the subject and the sovereign, their true freedom found in active participation and adherence to the "General Will." This places a profound Philosophical Duty on the Citizen to engage in civic life and prioritize the collective good.

The Enduring Philosophical Duties of the Citizen

Despite the evolution of political structures, certain Philosophical Duties of the Citizen remain timeless, echoing through the ages from Athens to modernity. These are not merely legal obligations but moral imperatives for a thriving society.

  • Active Participation: More than just voting, this involves informed engagement in public discourse, community involvement, and contributing to the deliberative processes of the State. It's the Aristotelian ideal of sharing in ruling and being ruled.
  • Critical Engagement and Reason: Following the Socratic tradition, the Citizen has a Duty to question, to think critically about the actions of the State and the prevalent norms of society. This involves using reason to discern truth and justice, rather than blindly accepting authority.
  • Upholding Justice and the Rule of Law: A fundamental Duty is to respect and uphold the laws of the State, provided they are just. When laws are unjust, the Citizen's Philosophical Duty may extend to principled dissent, civil disobedience, or advocating for reform, as seen in the Lockean tradition.
  • Civic Virtue and Public Reason: Rooted in both ancient and Enlightenment thought, civic virtue implies a commitment to the common good over narrow self-interest. This includes the Duty to engage in public reason, offering arguments that are accessible and justifiable to all fellow Citizens, fostering a shared understanding of societal goals.
  • Cultivation of Self: An often-overlooked Duty is the ongoing cultivation of one's own intellectual and moral capacities. A well-educated, reflective Citizen is better equipped to contribute meaningfully to the State and uphold its ideals.

The Challenge of Modern Citizenship

In the contemporary world, the Philosophical Role of the Citizen faces new complexities. Globalization, digital communication, and diverse societies challenge traditional notions of the State and national identity. Yet, the core questions remain: What is our Duty to the collective? How do we ensure justice and the good life for all Citizens? The answers still lie in a commitment to philosophical inquiry, active participation, and the enduring virtues that make a society truly free and just.

Conclusion: The Ongoing Dialectic of Citizen and State

The journey through the Great Books of the Western World reveals that the Philosophical Role of the Citizen is not a static concept but a dynamic, evolving dialogue between the individual and the State. It is a constant negotiation of rights and responsibilities, freedom and order, individual flourishing and the common good. To be a Citizen is to be an inheritor of this profound philosophical legacy, tasked with the ongoing Duty of shaping a world worthy of human dignity and potential.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato Aristotle Citizenship Philosophy Ancient Greece""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Social Contract Theory Explained Locke Rousseau Hobbes""

Share this post