The Enduring Riddle: Unpacking the Philosophical Problem of Change and Becoming

The world around us is in constant flux – seasons turn, bodies age, ideas evolve. Yet, amidst this ceaseless transformation, we perceive continuity and identity. How can something be and become simultaneously? This fundamental tension lies at the heart of "The Philosophical Problem of Change and Becoming," a profound inquiry that has captivated thinkers for millennia. It's a question not just about what happens, but about the very nature of reality, Being, and our experience of Time. This article delves into the historical roots and enduring significance of this problem, exploring how great minds from the Great Books of the Western World have grappled with the elusive dance between permanence and transformation.

The Ancient Conundrum: Flux Versus Unchanging Being

The earliest sparks of Western philosophy were ignited by this very dilemma. How can we trust our senses if everything is always changing? Or, conversely, how can we deny the evidence of our senses that points to constant motion?

Heraclitus: The Philosopher of Flux

Around 500 BCE, Heraclitus of Ephesus famously declared, "Panta rhei," or "everything flows." He believed that change was the fundamental reality, the underlying principle of the cosmos. "You cannot step into the same river twice," he asserted, because both the river and the person have changed. For Heraclitus, Being was not static but a dynamic process of becoming, a perpetual tension of opposites. Fire, a symbol of constant transformation, was his chosen element to represent this ever-changing reality.

Parmenides: The Champion of Unchanging Being

In stark contrast, Parmenides of Elea, a contemporary of Heraclitus, argued that change is an illusion. For Parmenides, Being is eternal, ungenerated, indestructible, indivisible, and perfectly uniform. He reasoned that something cannot come from nothing, nor can something become nothing. Therefore, what is must always be exactly what it is. Any perceived change, motion, or plurality is merely a deception of the senses, a deviation from the singular, unchanging truth of Being. This radical monism presented a powerful challenge: if reality is truly unchanging, how do we account for the world we experience?

Plato's Dualism: Forms and the Sensible World

Plato, deeply influenced by both Heraclitus (regarding the sensible world) and Parmenides (regarding ultimate reality), proposed a dualistic solution. He posited a realm of perfect, eternal, and unchanging Forms (or Ideas), which constitute true Being. These Forms—such as Justice, Beauty, or the Good—are apprehended by the intellect and are the ultimate reality. The world we perceive through our senses, the "sensible world," is merely a shadow or imperfect copy of these Forms. This sensible world is precisely where change and becoming occur, a realm of fleeting appearances. Thus, Plato reconciled the two extremes: true reality is unchanging (Forms), while our everyday experience is one of constant flux (sensible world).

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting Plato and Aristotle, with Plato pointing upwards towards the realm of Forms and Aristotle gesturing horizontally, emphasizing the immanent world and empirical observation.)

Aristotle's Synthesis: Potency, Act, and the Nature of Change

Aristotle, Plato's most famous student, offered a more integrated and empirical approach to the problem of change. Rejecting Plato's separate realm of Forms, Aristotle grounded his philosophy in the observable world. He sought to understand change not as an illusion or a mere shadow, but as a fundamental aspect of reality itself.

Potency and Act: The Mechanism of Becoming

Aristotle introduced the concepts of potency (dynamis) and act (energeia or entelecheia) to explain how something can become without violating the principle that something cannot come from nothing.

  • Potency refers to the capacity or potential for something to be or become something else. A seed has the potency to become a tree.
  • Act refers to the actualized state of something. A mature tree is the act of the seed's potential.

Change, for Aristotle, is the transition from potency to act. A block of marble has the potency to be a statue; when a sculptor carves it, that potency is actualized into the act of being a statue. This framework allows for genuine transformation while maintaining the identity of the underlying substance.

The Four Causes: Explaining Change and Becoming

To fully explain change and Being, Aristotle identified four causes (or explanatory factors) that contribute to the existence and nature of anything:

  1. Material Cause: What something is made of (e.g., the bronze of a statue).
  2. Formal Cause: The essence or form of a thing; what it is (e.g., the shape and structure of the statue).
  3. Efficient Cause: The agent or force that brings about the change (e.g., the sculptor).
  4. Final Cause: The purpose or end for which something exists (e.g., the statue's purpose might be to honor a hero).

These causes provide a comprehensive way to understand how things come into being, how they change, and what their ultimate nature is. Aristotle's detailed analysis, found in works like Physics and Metaphysics (cornerstones of the Great Books), laid the groundwork for scientific inquiry and remains profoundly influential in philosophy.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Four Causes Explained"

The Intimate Connection: Time and Change

The problem of change is inextricably linked to our understanding of Time. We perceive change as happening in time, and time itself is often defined by the succession of events, by change.

Saint Augustine, another titan from the Great Books, grappled deeply with the nature of Time in his Confessions. He famously asked, "What then is time? If no one asks me, I know; if I wish to explain it to him who asks, I do not know." Augustine concluded that Time is not a physical dimension but rather a distension of the mind—a "present of things past, a present of things present, and a present of things future." This subjective view highlights how our experience of change shapes our perception of Time, and vice-versa. Without change, would there even be Time?

Identity Through Transformation: The Ship of Theseus

A classic thought experiment, often attributed to Plutarch (another Great Books author), vividly illustrates the problem of identity amidst change: The Ship of Theseus.

Imagine Theseus's ship, preserved in a harbor. Over time, planks rot and are replaced. Eventually, every single plank, mast, and sail has been replaced. Is it still the same ship?

This puzzle forces us to confront fundamental questions:

  • What constitutes the identity of an object over time? Is it its material composition, its form, its function, or something else entirely?
  • How much change can something undergo before it ceases to be itself and becomes something new?

This dilemma extends beyond ships to living organisms, persons, and even societies. How do we remain the same person throughout our lives, despite continuous physical and mental change?

Why Does It Matter? The Enduring Legacy

The philosophical problem of change and becoming is far from an abstract academic exercise. Its implications ripple through various fields:

  • Metaphysics: It defines our understanding of reality and Being.
  • Epistemology: How can we have knowledge of a world that is constantly in flux?
  • Ethics: If a person changes fundamentally, are they still morally accountable for past actions?
  • Science: Modern physics, with its theories of relativity and quantum mechanics, continues to explore the nature of time, space, and fundamental change.

From ancient Greek debates to contemporary scientific theories, the tension between what is and what becomes remains a vibrant and essential inquiry. It challenges us to look beyond superficial appearances and delve into the deeper structures of reality, forcing us to constantly re-evaluate our place within the ceaseless flow of existence.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Ship of Theseus: Identity, Change, and Philosophy"

Share this post