The Nature of The Concept of Being in Relation to Quality

The Interwoven Fabric: Exploring Being and Quality in Metaphysics

Summary

The concepts of Being and Quality stand as twin pillars in the grand edifice of metaphysics, fundamental to understanding not just that something exists, but what it is and how it is. This article delves into their profound and often intricate relation, drawing upon the insights of the Great Books of the Western World. We will explore how Quality is not merely an attribute appended to Being, but an indispensable aspect that defines, differentiates, and makes Being intelligible, demonstrating their inextricable link in the very fabric of reality.

Introduction: The Fundamental Questions of Existence

From the earliest philosophical inquiries, humanity has grappled with the most fundamental questions: What is there? and What is it like? These seemingly simple queries lead us directly to the profound concepts of Being and Quality. To speak of "Being" is to engage with the sheer fact of existence, the ultimate ground of all reality. To speak of "Quality" is to describe the characteristics, attributes, and determinations that make a thing what it is. For millennia, thinkers have understood that these two concepts are not isolated, but rather stand in a deep and dynamic relation, constantly informing and shaping our understanding of the world. Through the lens of metaphysics, we seek to unravel this intricate connection.

I. Unpacking "Being": The Primal Act of Existence

At its core, Being is perhaps the most elusive yet omnipresent concept in philosophy. It is the very act of existing, the ultimate "is-ness" that underlies everything.

Parmenides, in ancient Greece, famously posited a singular, unchanging, and eternal Being, arguing that "what is not" cannot be conceived. For him, Being was an undifferentiated plenum, a stark contrast to the ever-changing world of appearances.
Aristotle, a titan among the Great Books authors, offered a more nuanced view. While acknowledging Being as primary, he also spoke of "Being in many senses." For him, the primary sense of Being was Substance – the independent, underlying reality of a thing (e.g., a specific man, a horse). Other senses included actuality (what a thing is) and potentiality (what it can become).
Thomas Aquinas, building upon Aristotle, distinguished between a thing's essentia (what it is, its essence or nature) and its esse (that it is, its act of existence). For Aquinas, esse was the ultimate perfection, the act by which anything actually is.

The concept of Being, whether conceived as an undifferentiated unity or as the foundational act of existence, serves as the ultimate ground upon which all else rests.

II. Defining "Quality": The Characteristics of What Is

If Being asks that something exists, Quality asks what kind of thing it is, or how it exists. It refers to the inherent characteristics, properties, or attributes that distinguish one thing from another and give it its particular nature.

Aristotle, again, provides a foundational understanding in his Categories, where Quality is one of the ten fundamental ways in which things can be said to be. He defines Quality as "that by virtue of which a thing is said to be such and such."
- Examples of qualities include:
  - Habits and Dispositions: Knowledge, virtue, health, sickness.
  - Capacities or Incapacities: Ability to run, inability to see.
  - Affective Qualities: Hot, cold, sweet, bitter, colors.
  - Form and Figure: Straight, curved, square, round.
Qualities are what we perceive and what allow us to differentiate. A red apple, a wise person, a fast runner – "red," "wise," and "fast" are all qualities that describe the apple, person, or runner.

Qualities are what make Being intelligible, allowing us to categorize, describe, and interact with the diverse entities that populate reality.

III. The Profound Relation: Quality as the Manifestation of Being

The true philosophical challenge lies in understanding how Being and Quality interrelate. Can Being exist without Quality? Can Quality exist independently of Being? The consensus among the great thinkers suggests an undeniable interdependence.

A. Quality as a Mode of Being

Every specific being is something, and in being something, it necessarily has characteristics. These characteristics are its qualities. A being is not just "there"; it is there in a certain way. The vibrant hue of a rose, the intricate pattern of a snowflake, the intellectual prowess of a philosopher – these are not mere superficial additions but integral aspects of what those beings are. Without any qualities, Being would be an undifferentiated, unknowable void, indistinguishable from non-existence.

B. Quality as Differentiation

It is through qualities that we distinguish one being from another. While two objects might share the same fundamental "Being" (i.e., they both exist), their differing qualities (color, shape, size, material) allow us to identify them as distinct entities. This differentiation is crucial for thought, language, and interaction.

C. The Metaphysical Interplay: Insights from the Great Books

The Great Books of the Western World offer diverse yet complementary perspectives on the relation between Being and Quality:

Aristotle's Categories: For Aristotle, Quality is an accident that inheres in a Substance (the primary sense of Being). A substance is what it is, and it has qualities. The substance is primary; the qualities depend on the substance for their existence. You cannot have "redness" floating around independently; it must be the redness of something (e.g., a red apple).
Plato's Forms: Plato presented a different hierarchy. For him, true Being resided in the eternal, unchanging Forms (e.g., the Form of Beauty, the Form of Justice). Particular beings in the sensible world possess qualities (e.g., a beautiful person, a just act) by participating in these perfect Forms. Here, qualities in the phenomenal world are reflections or imperfect instantiations of higher, more perfect Beings.
Aquinas and Scholasticism: Following Aristotle, Aquinas viewed qualities (accidents) as perfections or modifications of a substance. A substance's being is fundamental, and its qualities are determinations that perfect or complete that being. For example, knowledge is a quality that perfects the being of a human person.

The following table summarizes these different perspectives:

Philosopher	View on Being	View on Quality	Relation
Parmenides	Undifferentiated, eternal, unchanging	Not explicitly addressed as distinct	Being is all; no distinct qualities outside of it.
Plato	Divided into Forms (true Being) and particulars	Particulars possess qualities by participating in Forms	Qualities in particulars reflect higher Being (Forms).
Aristotle	Substance as primary Being; actuality/potentiality	One of ten categories, inheres in substance	Qualities are accidents that describe substances (Beings).
Thomas Aquinas	Esse (existence) as act of Being; essentia	Accidents that perfect or modify a substance	Qualities are determinations or perfections of a substance's Being.

IV. The Indispensable Link: Why Quality Matters to Being

The profound and undeniable link between Being and Quality reveals that qualities are not merely superficial add-ons but are intrinsic to how we understand, perceive, and categorize what is. Without qualities, Being would recede into an undifferentiated, abstract void, unknowable and uncommunicable. The very act of perceiving, describing, and communicating about reality is an act of engaging with the qualities of various beings. Our pursuit of knowledge, whether scientific or philosophical, is often a pursuit of understanding the specific qualities of things – their natures, their behaviors, their inherent characteristics. Quality, therefore, renders Being manifest and intelligible.

(Image: An intricate, detailed marble sculpture of a seated philosopher (perhaps Aristotle or Plato) contemplating. One hand rests on a scroll, while the other gestures towards a vibrant, blooming plant beside him, its leaves and petals rendered with lifelike precision. In the background, subtly etched, are abstract geometric forms and a faint, cosmic swirl, representing the underlying structure and vastness of Being. The image beautifully juxtaposes the abstract realm of philosophical thought with the concrete, quality-laden reality of the natural world.)

Conclusion: A Unified Reality

The journey through the concepts of Being and Quality reveals them not as separate entities but as inextricably linked aspects of a unified reality. Metaphysics, in its grand ambition to understand ultimate reality, demonstrates that that which is (Being) is always that which is in a certain way (Quality). Our understanding of existence is fundamentally shaped by the attributes and characteristics that define it. To truly grasp the essence of anything, we must consider both its fundamental act of existing and the rich tapestry of qualities that make it unique and knowable. This ongoing philosophical exploration continues to illuminate the profound and beautiful interplay that weaves the fabric of our world.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle's Categories of Being Explained"