The Concept of Being in Relation to Quality

By Daniel Fletcher

The intricate dance between Being and Quality forms a cornerstone of philosophical inquiry, a fundamental relation that shapes our understanding of existence itself. At its core, this exploration delves into how the inherent characteristics and properties of things — their qualities — are not merely superficial attributes but are inextricably linked to what and how something is. From the ancient Greeks to modern thought, philosophers have grappled with the profound implications of this connection, revealing that to speak of Being without considering Quality is to grasp at an empty concept, and to understand Quality is to illuminate the very nature of Being. This article will navigate the historical and conceptual landscape of this essential philosophical pairing, drawing insights from the venerable texts of the Great Books of the Western World to shed light on their inseparable bond in the realm of Metaphysics.

Unpacking the Fundamentals: What Is Being and Quality?

To truly appreciate the profound relation between Being and Quality, we must first establish a working understanding of each concept. These are not simple definitions but rather vast philosophical landscapes in themselves.

The Enigma of Being

Being is perhaps the most fundamental concept in philosophy, yet it remains one of the most elusive. It refers to existence itself, the simple fact that something is. Parmenides, an early Greek philosopher whose ideas resonate through the Great Books, famously argued that Being is one, eternal, and unchanging, asserting "what is, is." For him, non-being was unthinkable.

However, the question quickly becomes more complex:

  • What kind of Being? Is it the Being of a physical object, a thought, a number, or an abstract concept like justice?
  • How does it manifest? Does everything that is exist in the same way?

Aristotle, in his Categories and Metaphysics, provided a foundational framework. He distinguished between substance (the primary "is," that which exists in itself) and accidents (properties that inhere in a substance, such as quality, quantity, relation, etc.). This distinction immediately places Quality in a vital, albeit secondary, position relative to Substance.

The Nature of Quality

Quality refers to the characteristics, properties, or attributes that define something. It answers the question, "What kind of thing is it?" or "How is it?" Think of the redness of an apple, the hardness of a diamond, the kindness of a person, or the wisdom of a sage. These are all qualities.

Philosophical inquiry into Quality often explores:

  • Objective vs. Subjective Qualities: Are qualities inherent in the object itself (e.g., mass, shape) or are they dependent on a perceiver (e.g., color, taste)? John Locke, in his Essay Concerning Human Understanding, famously distinguished between primary qualities (inherent, measurable) and secondary qualities (mind-dependent).
  • Essential vs. Accidental Qualities: Does a quality define what something is (e.g., rationality for a human), or is it merely a changeable attribute (e.g., hair color)?

The Inseparable Relation: How Quality Defines Being

The philosophical tradition, particularly through the lens of Metaphysics, consistently reveals that Being and Quality are not independent entities but are deeply intertwined.

  • No Being Without Quality: Can we conceive of something that is but has absolutely no qualities? No size, no shape, no color, no internal properties, no external relations? It becomes an empty, featureless void, indistinguishable from non-being. As Aristotle implied, while substance is primary, it is through its qualities (and other accidents) that it is apprehended and particularized. A "thing" without qualities is, effectively, no thing at all.
  • Quality as a Mode of Being: Conversely, qualities don't float independently; they are always the qualities of something that is. Redness doesn't exist in a vacuum; it's the redness of a rose, a car, or a sunset. Kindness is the kindness of a person. This suggests that qualities are not just superficial adornments but are ways in which Being manifests and particularizes itself.

The Platonic Ideal: Forms as Perfect Qualities

Plato's theory of Forms, a cornerstone of the Great Books, offers a powerful perspective on this relation. For Plato, true Being resides in the eternal, unchanging Forms (e.g., the Form of Beauty, the Form of Justice). These Forms are, in essence, perfect qualities. Particular objects in the sensible world "participate" in these Forms, thereby acquiring their qualities. A beautiful person is beautiful because they partake in the Form of Beauty. Here, the ultimate reality (Being) is defined by its perfect qualitative essence.

The Metaphysical Dance: Qualitative Change and Identity

The dynamic interplay between Being and Quality becomes even more evident when we consider change and identity.

Change and Persistence

If qualities are so integral to Being, what happens when qualities change?

  • Does a qualitative change alter the Being of an object? If a green apple turns red, is it still the same apple? Most would say yes.
  • But what if all its qualities change? Consider the Ship of Theseus paradox: if all its original planks are replaced, is it still the same ship? This thought experiment, pondered by philosophers for centuries, highlights the deep connection between a thing's qualities and its enduring identity (its Being).

Table: Qualities and Their Impact on Being

Type of Quality Change Impact on Being/Identity Philosophical Implications
Accidental Change Being generally persists Focus on substance as primary, qualities as secondary.
(e.g., color, location) (e.g., apple changes color) Aristotle's substance-accident distinction.
Essential Change Being may cease or transform Focus on defining properties.
(e.g., fundamental nature) (e.g., seed becoming a tree) Teleology, essence, and potentiality.
Radical Qualitative Change Identity questioned or lost The problem of personal identity, Ship of Theseus.
(e.g., complete overhaul) (e.g., all parts replaced) Continuity vs. constitution.

Hegel's Dialectic of Being and Quality

Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, another titan of the Great Books, posited a profound dialectical relation between Being and Quality in his Science of Logic. For Hegel, "pure Being" is indeterminate and empty, effectively indistinguishable from "pure Nothing." It is only when Quality is introduced that Being gains determination and becomes something specific.

Hegel's key insight is that qualitative change, when pushed to its limits, can lead to a quantitative change that ultimately transforms the Being of a thing. For example, adding drops of water to a vessel is a quantitative change, but at a certain point, the quality of "fullness" emerges, and adding more drops causes it to overflow, fundamentally changing its state. This dynamic interplay underscores that Quality is not just an attribute of Being but an active participant in its becoming and transformation.

Perception, Experience, and the Realization of Being through Quality

Our very experience of the world is mediated through qualities. We perceive objects by their colors, shapes, textures, sounds, and smells. These sensory qualities are the gateways through which we apprehend the Being of things.

  • Kant's Categories: Immanuel Kant, in his Critique of Pure Reason, argued that our understanding imposes categories, including categories of Quality (reality, negation, limitation), onto the raw data of sensation. These categories are essential for us to synthesize our experiences into coherent objects of knowledge. Thus, for Kant, Quality is not just out there, but also a fundamental structure of our knowing apparatus, shaping how we encounter Being.
  • The Subjective Dimension: The recognition that some qualities are mind-dependent (secondary qualities) highlights the role of the observer in constituting reality. The "redness" of an apple might be a product of light reflection and our visual system, yet it is undeniably how the apple is for us, and thus part of its perceived Being.

(Image: A classical Greek marble statue, perhaps of Aristotle or Plato, deeply etched with lines and cracks, representing the enduring but weathered nature of ancient philosophy. One hand is slightly raised in a gesture of contemplation, with a faint, ethereal glow emanating from its head, symbolizing thought and abstract concepts like Being and Quality.)

The philosophical journey through the concept of Being in relation to Quality reveals an indispensable link. From the foundational definitions of Aristotle to the ideal Forms of Plato, and the dialectical transformations of Hegel, the consistent message is clear: Quality is not merely an adjunct to Being but is intrinsic to its very nature and manifestation. To understand what is, we must understand how it is. The Metaphysics of Being and Quality teaches us that reality is not a collection of featureless existences, but a vibrant tapestry woven from the countless characteristics that give form, meaning, and identity to everything that is. This profound relation remains a fertile ground for philosophical exploration, continually challenging us to look deeper into the essence of things.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Categories Substance and Accidents Explained" and "Hegel's Logic: Being, Nothing, Becoming Explained""

Share this post