The Nature of The Concept of Being in Relation to Quality

The Substance of Existence: Unpacking the Relation Between Being and Quality

Summary

The relation between "Being"—the fundamental fact of existence—and "Quality"—the inherent characteristics that define what something is—is a cornerstone of Metaphysics. This article delves into how, while Being is the primary ground of all reality, our apprehension and understanding of it are inextricably linked to its qualities. Drawing from the profound insights within the Great Books of the Western World, we will argue that Quality is not merely an incidental attribute, but a crucial gateway through which we grasp the very essence of existence itself.

The Elusive Nature of Being

To speak of "Being" is to confront the most fundamental and, paradoxically, the most elusive concept in philosophy. What does it mean to be? This question has haunted thinkers from Parmenides to Heidegger, forming the bedrock of Metaphysics. In the Western philosophical tradition, as chronicled in the Great Books, Being often refers to the sheer fact of existence, the "is-ness" that underpins all things. It is the raw, undifferentiated ground from which everything else emerges.

However, Being in its pure, unadulterated form is incredibly difficult to conceptualize, let alone describe. If Being is simply "that which is," how do we differentiate one thing that is from another? How do we speak of a chair's Being versus a person's Being? This is where the concept of Quality becomes indispensable.

Quality: A Gateway to Understanding Being

While Being provides the existential foundation, Quality provides the descriptive content. A Quality is an attribute, characteristic, or property that helps define and distinguish a particular instance of Being. Without qualities, Being would remain an undifferentiated, inaccessible abstraction. We don't encounter "Being" in its pure form; we encounter beings—things that possess specific qualities.

Consider a tree. Its Being is its existence as a tree. But what makes it a tree? Its qualities:

Color: Green leaves, brown bark
Texture: Rough bark, smooth leaves
Shape: Tall, branching, broad canopy
Function: Photosynthesis, providing shade

These qualities are not separate from the tree's Being; they are how its Being manifests to us and how it is defined.

Aristotle's Categories: Placing Quality in Context

One of the most profound early explorations of the relation between Being and its attributes comes from Aristotle, whose work is foundational in the Great Books of the Western World. In his Categories, Aristotle sought to classify the fundamental ways in which things "are" or can be predicated of a subject. Among his ten categories, "Substance" stands as the primary mode of Being—the individual thing itself. The other nine categories describe various ways in which a substance is qualified or related.

Aristotle's Categories (Selected)	Description	Example (for a human Being)
Substance	That which exists independently; the underlying subject	Socrates
Quantity	How much or how many	Six feet tall
Quality	What kind of a thing it is; its inherent characteristic	Wise, just, pale
Relation	How it stands in regard to something else	Taller than Plato, father of Lamprocles
Action	What it is doing	Speaking, walking
Passion	What is being done to it	Being taught, being honored
Time	When it exists	Yesterday, last year
Place	Where it exists	In the agora, at home

As we can see, Quality is one of the crucial ways in which we understand and describe a Substance (Being). It tells us what kind of a Being something is. Without qualities like "wise" or "just," Socrates's Being as a philosopher would be incomprehensible.

(Image: A detailed classical Greek fresco depicting Aristotle lecturing to a small group of students in an open-air academy, with one student intently taking notes on a scroll, symbolizing the transmission of foundational metaphysical concepts.)

The Intrinsic Relation: Can Being Exist Without Quality?

The question then arises: can Being exist without Quality? And conversely, can Quality exist without Being?

Being without Quality? If we strip away all qualities from a thing—its size, color, shape, function, even its very nature—what is left? An undifferentiated "something" that is almost indistinguishable from "nothing." While some mystical or highly abstract philosophical traditions might posit a pure, unqualified Being, for practical and even most metaphysical inquiries, Being is always apprehended through its qualities. The very act of identifying something as a "thing" implies a set of distinguishing characteristics.
Quality without Being? Can "redness" exist independently without a red object? Can "wisdom" exist without a wise person? Historically, philosophers have debated this. Plato's theory of Forms suggests that perfect, unqualified "Redness Itself" exists in a separate realm, providing the blueprint for all red things. However, for most empirical and Aristotelian perspectives, qualities are inhering properties; they require a subject—a Being—in which to reside. A quality is always the quality of something.

This demonstrates the profound relation: Being provides the substrate, the "that which is," while Quality provides the specific determination, the "what it is." They are two sides of the same coin, mutually dependent for our comprehensive understanding of reality.

The Dynamic Interplay in Our Perception of Reality

The interplay between Being and Quality is not merely an abstract philosophical exercise; it shapes our everyday perception and understanding of the world. When we encounter something new, our minds immediately seek to identify its qualities: "What color is it? How big? What does it do?" These qualities allow us to categorize, understand, and interact with the Being.

Furthermore, the relation is dynamic. Changes in qualities can lead us to perceive a change in Being (e.g., a caterpillar's qualities change so dramatically that we perceive it as a different Being, a butterfly). The persistence of certain qualities helps us recognize the continuity of a Being over time, despite other changes.

Conclusion

The concept of Being, in its fundamental and often elusive nature, finds its tangible expression and our means of comprehension through Quality. As thinkers throughout the Great Books of the Western World have shown, from Aristotle's systematic categorization to later inquiries into the nature of existence, the relation between Being and Quality is not merely one of attribute to substance, but an intrinsic and profound interdependence. Quality serves as the lens through which the raw fact of existence is differentiated, understood, and ultimately, made meaningful. To understand Being, we must inevitably grapple with its qualities, for it is through them that reality reveals itself.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Metaphysics Explained Categories Substance Quality"