The Indissoluble Dance: Being in Relation to Quality

The very fabric of our reality, the Metaphysics that underpins all existence, hinges upon a profound and often overlooked relation: that between Being and Quality. Simply put, nothing can be without possessing certain qualities, and no quality can exist without something being to embody it. This article delves into this fundamental philosophical pairing, exploring how the Great Books of the Western World illuminate their intricate connection, revealing that to understand one is to necessarily engage with the other. We will uncover how Quality gives form and meaning to Being, transforming abstract existence into the rich, differentiated world we perceive and comprehend.

The Metaphysical Ground: What Does it Mean to Be?

At the heart of philosophy lies the question of Being. From Parmenides' assertion of an unchanging, undifferentiated One to Aristotle's intricate categories of existence, philosophers have grappled with what it means for something to exist or to be. Being is the most fundamental concept, the very condition of possibility for anything else. It is the raw, unadorned fact of existence, prior to any specific characteristic or attribute.

However, a Being devoid of all Quality is an abstract concept, perhaps useful for theoretical contemplation but ultimately unknowable and indescribable. How would we differentiate one "being" from another if they shared no distinguishing features? This is where Quality steps onto the stage.

Unpacking Quality: The Attributes of Existence

Quality refers to the characteristics, attributes, properties, or features that define and differentiate individual instances of Being. It is what makes something what it is beyond its mere existence. Aristotle, in his Categories, famously lists Quality as one of the ten fundamental ways in which something can be predicated of a subject. He further breaks it down into subcategories:

  • Habits and Dispositions: Knowledge, virtue (e.g., being learned, being just)
  • Capacities and Incapacities: Being able to run, being unable to see
  • Affective Qualities and Affections: Warmth, coldness, sweetness, bitterness, being red, being sick
  • Figure and the Form of Each Thing: Straightness, curvedness, squareness, roundness

These qualities are not mere decorations; they are integral to how we identify, understand, and interact with Being. A "tree" is not just being; it is being green, being tall, being woody, being rooted.

The Essential Relation: Being and Quality Intertwined

The relation between Being and Quality is one of profound mutual dependence.

  1. Quality Presupposes Being: Nothing can possess a quality unless it first is. A non-existent unicorn cannot be "white" or "mythical." The very notion of a characteristic requires a subject to which that characteristic belongs.
  2. Being is Illuminated by Quality: Conversely, Being without quality is a philosophical cipher. We grasp Being precisely through its qualities. To say something "is" becomes meaningful only when we can ask "what kind of being is it?" or "what are its qualities?" The abstract concept of "existence" gains substance and specificity through the attributes that manifest it.

Consider the notion of "human Being." What makes us human is not merely our existence, but the qualities we possess: rationality, morality, capacity for language, emotional depth. These qualities are not separable from our Being; they constitute what it is to be human.

Philosophical Perspectives on the Relation

Throughout the Great Books, various thinkers have explored this intricate relation:

  • Plato: For Plato, the Forms themselves are perfect qualities (e.g., the Form of Beauty, the Form of Justice) that bestow Being upon particulars in the sensible world. A beautiful object is beautiful by participating in the Form of Beauty.
  • Aristotle: As noted, Quality is one of his fundamental categories. He distinguishes between essential qualities (those necessary for a thing to be what it is, e.g., rationality for a human) and accidental qualities (those that can change without altering the thing's fundamental Being, e.g., hair color).
  • Medieval Scholastics (e.g., Aquinas): Building on Aristotle, they understood qualities as accidents inhering in a substance. The "transcendentals" (unity, truth, goodness), however, were seen as qualities co-extensive with Being itself, applying to everything that is.
  • Early Modern Philosophers (e.g., Locke): Locke distinguished between primary qualities (inherent in the object, like extension, solidity) and secondary qualities (powers to produce sensations in us, like color, taste). This highlights how the relation between Being and Quality can be perceived differently depending on the observer.

(Image: A classical depiction of Aristotle in his study, contemplating a scroll, with various objects around him – a sphere, a plant, a tool – each representing a distinct form of Being differentiated by its inherent qualities.)

The Significance of the Being-Quality Relation

Understanding the profound relation between Being and Quality is not merely an academic exercise; it is central to our comprehension of reality, our acquisition of knowledge, and even our ethical considerations.

  • Knowledge: We come to know Being through its qualities. To learn about an object, a person, or a concept is to identify and understand its defining characteristics.
  • Differentiation: Qualities allow us to differentiate between distinct instances of Being. Without them, the world would be an undifferentiated blur.
  • Identity: A thing's identity is inextricably linked to its qualities, particularly its essential ones. To lose all defining qualities is, in a sense, to cease to be what one was.
  • Value: Our assessment of value often hinges on quality. We speak of "high-quality" products, "good quality" of life, or the "moral quality" of an action. These judgments presuppose a foundational Being that can possess such attributes.

In essence, Being provides the canvas, and Quality paints the picture. Together, they create the rich tapestry of existence, making the abstract concrete and the fundamental intelligible. The ongoing philosophical inquiry into this relation continues to shape our understanding of Metaphysics and the very nature of reality.

Further Exploration:

  • YouTube: Aristotle's Categories Explained
  • YouTube: Metaphysics of Substance and Qualities

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Concept of Being in Relation to Quality philosophy"

Share this post