The Intricate Dance: Unpacking Desire and Will in Human Choice

In the intricate tapestry of human experience, few threads are as fundamental yet as complex as the interplay between desire and will. This article delves into the dynamic relationship between these two powerful faculties of the mind, exploring how they shape the choices Man makes, drawing insights from the enduring wisdom of the Great Books of the Western World. Far from being simple opposites, desire and will engage in a constant, often nuanced, dialogue within us, defining our character and directing our paths.

Defining the Players: Desire and Will

Before we can appreciate their complex interaction, it's crucial to understand desire and will as distinct, yet interconnected, forces.

Desire: The Heart's Inclination

Desire is often perceived as an innate yearning, an attraction to a perceived good, or a fundamental inclination towards something. It's the pull, the wanting, the impulse that arises from our nature, our senses, or our emotions. From the simple hunger for food to the profound aspiration for love or knowledge, desire fuels much of human activity. It is often spontaneous, immediate, and can be irrational or non-rational.

Characteristics of Desire:

  • Spontaneous: Arises without conscious deliberation.
  • Emotional/Instinctual: Often rooted in feelings, bodily needs, or primal urges.
  • Perceived Good: Directed towards something seen as beneficial or pleasurable.
  • Passive: Can feel like something that happens to us.
  • Varied Intensity: From mild preferences to overwhelming cravings.

Will: The Mind's Command

Will, in contrast, is typically understood as the faculty of deliberate choice, the power to act or to refrain from acting. It is the executive function of the mind, enabling Man to set goals, make decisions, and exert self-control. While desire might present a myriad of options, it is the will that weighs, selects, and commits to a course of action, often in alignment with reason or moral principles.

Characteristics of Will:

  • Deliberate: Involves conscious thought and consideration.
  • Rational/Moral: Often guided by reason, values, or duty.
  • Active Choice: The power to select among alternatives.
  • Self-Control: The ability to resist or pursue desires.
  • Goal-Oriented: Directed towards achieving specific outcomes.

(Image: A classical allegorical painting depicting a struggle between two figures, one representing impulsive desire reaching for a fleeting pleasure, and the other, resolute and stoic, embodying rational will, holding a balanced scale or a compass. The background could feature both chaotic elements and serene, ordered structures.)

Historical Echoes: A Journey Through Thought

The interplay of desire and will has captivated thinkers for millennia, forming a cornerstone of philosophical inquiry across the Great Books of the Western World.

Ancient Roots: Plato and Aristotle on Appetite and Deliberation

Plato, in his Republic, famously articulated the soul as having three parts: reason, spirit, and appetite. Here, desire is largely associated with the appetitive part, the base urges for food, drink, and sex. For Plato, the ideal state of the individual, like the ideal state of the city, required reason (akin to will's guiding hand) to rule over and harmonize the appetites and the spirited element. A life of virtue, therefore, was one where reason held sway, directing desires towards higher goods.

Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, delved deeply into voluntary action and deliberation. He understood will (or prohairesis, "choice") as a deliberate desire – a desire that has been shaped and endorsed by reason. For Aristotle, true moral action stemmed not from raw desire, but from a rational choice following deliberation about the means to an end. The good Man cultivates virtues that align his desires with reason, making virtuous action enjoyable rather than a constant struggle.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato's Republic: Tripartite Soul explained"

Medieval Struggles: Augustine and Aquinas on the Soul's Battle

The Christian tradition brought new dimensions to this interplay. St. Augustine, in his Confessions, vividly depicted the inner struggle of the will against sinful desires. He grappled with the apparent weakness of the will, even when the mind knew what was good. For Augustine, the Fall introduced a radical disharmony, making the will prone to succumb to lower desires, necessitating divine grace for true freedom and spiritual alignment.

St. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, saw the will as an intellectual appetite. For Aquinas, the will naturally desires the good apprehended by the intellect. While desires could be irrational, the will's proper function was to pursue the universal good discerned by reason. The conflict arises when the intellect presents a particular good that clashes with a higher good, or when passions (desires) cloud the intellect's judgment.

Modern Crossroads: Descartes, Kant, and Nietzsche on Autonomy and Power

René Descartes, with his mind-body dualism, explored the interaction between the immaterial mind (the seat of will and reason) and the material body (where passions and desires originate). For Descartes, the will's power lay in its ability to control and redirect the passions through rational thought.

Immanuel Kant, in his Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, presented a stark contrast between acting from desire (inclination) and acting from will (duty). For Kant, true moral worth lay only in actions performed from duty, where the good will chose to act according to a universal moral law, irrespective of personal desires or expected outcomes. The moral Man is one whose will is determined by reason, not by the shifting tides of inclination.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Kantian Ethics: Duty vs Inclination"

Friedrich Nietzsche, challenging many preceding notions, saw the "will to power" as the fundamental driving force of existence. For Nietzsche, desire was not to be suppressed but understood as an expression of this will. The strong individual, the Übermensch, does not deny his desires but channels and sublimates them, transforming them into creative forces that affirm life and overcome conventional morality.

The Crucible of Choice: Where They Meet

The point where desire and will converge is the moment of choice. It is here that Man defines himself.

Conflict and Harmony: The Inner Dialogue

Often, we experience a direct conflict: the desire for immediate gratification versus the will to pursue a long-term goal. The desire for a sugary treat clashes with the will to maintain a healthy diet. The desire to stay in bed conflicts with the will to meet responsibilities. This internal tension is a hallmark of the human condition.

However, desire and will are not always at odds. Ideally, they can work in harmony. When the mind understands a particular desire as genuinely good and aligns it with a rational purpose, the will can powerfully direct energy towards its fulfillment. For instance, the desire for knowledge, when embraced by a disciplined will, leads to profound study and discovery.

The Role of Reason: Guiding the Impulses

Reason acts as the mediator and guide in this interplay. It allows us to evaluate our desires, understand their potential consequences, and determine if they align with our values and long-term goals. The will, informed by reason, then has the capacity to either endorse and pursue a desire, or to restrain and redirect it. This rational deliberation is what elevates human choice beyond mere instinct.

Implications for the Self and Society

Understanding the interplay of desire and will is not merely an academic exercise; it has profound implications for how Man lives his life and shapes his society. Personal mastery, self-discipline, and the pursuit of virtue all hinge on effectively managing this dynamic. A society where individuals are slaves to unbridled desire risks chaos, while one that suppresses all desire might become sterile and lifeless. The ideal lies in a balanced cultivation, where the will, guided by wisdom, directs and refines desire towards flourishing for the individual and the collective.

Conclusion: Mastering the Inner Landscape

The relationship between desire and will is the very core of human agency. It is the ongoing dialogue within the mind that determines the trajectory of our lives. From the ancient philosophers who sought to align appetite with reason, to modern thinkers exploring the depths of our drives, the Great Books of the Western World consistently remind us that true freedom and self-realization come not from the absence of desire, nor from the tyranny of will, but from their thoughtful, deliberate, and harmonious interplay. Mastering this inner landscape is perhaps the greatest journey Man can undertake.

Share this post