The Interplay of Desire and Will in Choice: Navigating the Inner Landscape of Man

The human experience of choice is often depicted as a rational process, yet beneath the surface, a profound and dynamic tension exists between our desires and our will. This article explores how these fundamental forces within the Mind shape the decisions that define us as Man, drawing insights from the timeless wisdom preserved in the Great Books of the Western World. We will delve into their distinct natures, their intricate interplay, and the philosophical perspectives that illuminate this enduring internal struggle.

The Dual Forces Within: Desire and Will

At the heart of human agency lies a fascinating duality. On one side, we are driven by powerful, often instinctual, impulses; on the other, we possess a faculty for conscious direction and self-control.

Desire: The Primal Urge and Appetitive Force

Desire is the longing, the urge, the inclination that draws us towards something. It originates from our appetitive nature, a fundamental aspect recognized by many ancient thinkers.

  • Plato, in his Republic, famously describes the soul as having a tripartite structure: the rational, the spirited, and the appetitive. The appetitive part, responsible for basic needs and pleasures like hunger, thirst, and sexual urges, is the seat of many desires. It is often portrayed as a wild horse, powerful and potentially unruly.
  • Aristotle, in works such as Nicomachean Ethics, speaks of orexis – a general term for appetite or desire, which can be rational or irrational. He acknowledges that desires, while natural, need to be properly ordered for a virtuous life.
  • Baruch Spinoza, in Ethics, defines desire (cupiditas) as the very essence of Man, his conatus – the endeavor by which each thing, as far as it lies in itself, strives to persevere in its being. For Spinoza, desire is not merely an emotion but the fundamental drive of existence itself.

Desires can be immediate and compelling, often pushing us towards gratification or away from discomfort. They are the raw material of our motivations, deeply rooted in our physical and emotional being.

Will: The Guiding Hand of the Mind

In contrast to the often spontaneous nature of desire, will represents our capacity for deliberate choice, self-direction, and conscious intention. It is the faculty that allows us to assent, dissent, or suspend judgment, often acting as the steering mechanism for our life's course.

  • St. Augustine, in Confessions and City of God, places immense importance on the will, particularly free will. For Augustine, the will is central to human nature and moral responsibility; it is the source of both good and evil choices, capable of turning towards God or away from Him. He grappled profoundly with the struggle of the will against disordered desires.
  • St. Thomas Aquinas, building on Aristotle, saw the will as a rational appetite. It is not blind but follows the apprehension of the intellect. The will is drawn to what the intellect presents as good, but it retains the freedom to choose among various goods or even to choose a lesser good over a greater one.
  • René Descartes, in his Meditations, distinguished the will as an infinite faculty, far broader than the intellect. He saw the will as the source of our ability to affirm or deny, to pursue or avoid, and thus, the origin of our errors when it assents to unclear ideas presented by the intellect.
  • Immanuel Kant, in his Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, elevates the concept of the good will as the only thing unconditionally good. For Kant, moral action stems not from inclination or desire, but from a will acting purely out of duty, guided by universalizable maxims of practical reason.

The will, therefore, is intimately connected with our capacity for reason, self-control, and moral agency. It is the part of the Mind that can reflect, deliberate, and commit to a course of action, even in the face of conflicting desires.

The Dynamic Interplay: Harmony and Conflict in Choice

The relationship between desire and will is rarely static. It is a vibrant, often contentious, interplay that forms the very fabric of our decision-making.

Aspect Desire Will
Nature Instinctual, appetitive, emotional Rational, deliberative, volitional
Origin Bodily needs, sensory input, passions Intellect, reason, moral conviction
Motivation Pleasure, avoidance of pain, gratification Duty, virtue, long-term goals, self-mastery
Direction Often immediate, impulsive, reactive Deliberate, intentional, proactive
Goal Satisfaction of urges Good action, self-realization, moral law

The Mind as the Arena

The Mind serves as the primary arena where these forces contend. When desires align with the dictates of the will, choice feels effortless and harmonious. For instance, Man desires to be healthy, and his will directs him to exercise and eat well. However, true tests of character arise when desire and will clash. The desire for immediate gratification (e.g., eating unhealthy food) often confronts the will's commitment to a long-term goal (e.g., health).

Philosophers have long explored this internal battle:

  • Plato envisioned reason (the will's domain) as the charioteer guiding the two horses of the spirited and appetitive parts of the soul. The ideal state is when reason holds firm control, directing the desires towards noble ends.
  • Augustine's personal struggles, detailed in Confessions, vividly illustrate the agony of a will weakened by sin, often succumbing to desires it knows to be wrong. His famous prayer, "Grant me chastity and continence, but not yet," perfectly captures this internal conflict.
  • Kant's ethical system fundamentally posits that moral worth comes from acting from duty, not merely in accordance with duty or inclination. This implies a constant potential for the will to act against desire when morality demands it.

The ability of Man to exert his will over his desires is often seen as a hallmark of self-mastery and moral strength. It is through this struggle and eventual direction that we cultivate virtues and shape our character.

Cultivating a Harmonious Self

Understanding the interplay of desire and will is not merely an academic exercise; it is crucial for living a meaningful and intentional life. The Mind must learn to discern which desires serve its higher purposes and which merely distract or derail.

  • Self-Knowledge: Recognizing the nature and intensity of one's desires is the first step. What truly moves us? What are our fundamental appetites?
  • Rational Deliberation: The will's power is amplified by careful thought. Weighing the consequences of acting on desire versus adhering to principle allows for informed choice.
  • Habit Formation: As Aristotle emphasized, virtue is developed through habit. Consistently choosing according to reason and will, even when difficult, strengthens the will's capacity to guide desires.

The ongoing dance between desire and will shapes every choice, every action, and ultimately, the kind of Man we become. It is a testament to the complex and rich inner life that has fascinated philosophers for millennia, a testament to the enduring quest for self-understanding and self-governance.

(Image: A detailed classical painting depicting a figure, perhaps a philosopher or allegorical representation of the human soul, seated thoughtfully. Two distinct figures or forces are subtly depicted around them: one representing raw, impulsive energy or passion (Desire), perhaps with flowing drapery and an eager gaze, and the other representing calm, reasoned contemplation or authority (Will), perhaps with a steady posture and a discerning expression. The central figure's gaze or posture suggests an internal struggle or a moment of decision, with the two surrounding forces subtly influencing their thought process, all set within an ethereal or classical architectural background.)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Philosophy of Desire and Will - Great Books"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Augustine's Free Will vs Determinism"

Share this post