In the bustling arena of modern politics, the ancient Idea of Temperance often feels like a forgotten whisper. Yet, as explored across the Great Books of the Western World, this cardinal virtue remains indispensable for stable and just government. Far from mere personal restraint, political temperance signifies a collective moderation, a balanced approach to power, policy, and public discourse, acting as a crucial bulwark against the destructive forces of extremism and unbridled ambition. It is the wisdom to know limits, the courage to seek balance, and the commitment to the common good over partisan excess, transforming potential vice into enduring societal virtue.

Reclaiming an Ancient Virtue: Temperance in the Political Sphere

Greetings, fellow travelers on the intellectual journey! Grace Ellis here, inviting you to delve into a concept as ancient as philosophy itself, yet profoundly relevant to our contemporary political landscape: the Idea of Temperance. Often relegated to personal ethics, temperance, or sophrosyne as the Greeks knew it, possesses a formidable political dimension. From the foundational texts within the Great Books of the Western World, we uncover how this virtue is not just about individual self-control, but about the very equilibrium and health of the state, guiding the actions of leaders and the collective spirit of the citizenry. Let us explore how temperance stands as a critical counterpoint to the vices that plague government and society, shaping the pursuit of a more harmonious political order.

Defining Temperance: A Political Virtue

At its core, temperance is the virtue of moderation, self-control, and balance. It is the disciplined command over one's desires and appetites, ensuring they serve reason rather than overwhelm it. While initially conceived for the individual soul, classical thinkers quickly extended this idea to the body politic. For a government to be temperate means it exercises power judiciously, avoids excess, respects limits, and seeks equilibrium. It is the opposite of tyranny, demagoguery, and unchecked ambition. Where vice leads to imbalance and destruction, temperance fosters stability and flourishing.

(Image: A detailed depiction of Plato's allegory of the Chariot, with the charioteer (reason) guiding two winged horses, one noble (spirit) and one unruly (appetite), symbolizing the soul's internal struggle for balance and temperance, set against a backdrop of an ancient Athenian city-state.)

Temperance in the Great Books: Foundations of Political Prudence

The wisdom of the ages, distilled in the Great Books, consistently champions temperance as a cornerstone of legitimate political authority and societal well-being.

  • Plato's Harmonious City:
    In his Republic, Plato famously argues that a just city mirrors a just soul. Just as the individual soul achieves temperance when reason governs spirit and appetite, so too does a city become temperate when its various classes—rulers, auxiliaries, and producers—each perform their proper function without overstepping. The idea is one of internal harmony, where each part of the government and society understands its limits, preventing the vice of factionalism or tyranny. Plato posits that temperance is not merely a characteristic of a single class but a virtue diffused throughout the entire city, a shared agreement on who should rule and who should obey.

  • Aristotle's Golden Mean:
    Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics and Politics, further refines the idea of temperance as the "golden mean" between extremes. For a leader, this means avoiding both excessive indulgence and extreme asceticism, finding the right measure in all actions. In government, this translates into a balanced constitution, avoiding the vices of pure democracy (which can lead to mob rule) and oligarchy (which can lead to tyranny). Aristotle advocated for a mixed constitution, blending elements of aristocracy, oligarchy, and democracy, precisely because such a structure embodies temperance by balancing competing interests and preventing any single faction from gaining unchecked power.

  • Roman Prudence and Civic Virtue:
    Roman thinkers like Cicero, drawing heavily on Greek philosophy, emphasized prudence (practical wisdom) as intrinsically linked to temperance in public life. For the Roman Republic, civic virtue demanded moderation in ambition, respect for law, and a commitment to the common good above personal gain. The idea of a government tempered by tradition, law, and the wisdom of its senators was central to their long-lasting stability, a stark contrast to the vices of corruption and imperial overreach that eventually contributed to its decline.

  • Aquinas and the Cardinal Virtues:
    In the medieval period, Thomas Aquinas integrated classical virtues into Christian theology. Temperance, alongside prudence, justice, and fortitude, became one of the four cardinal virtues. For Aquinas, a just government must embody these virtues, with temperance guiding rulers to use their power for the good of the community, avoiding the vice of selfish rule and ensuring that laws are reasonable and conducive to human flourishing.

The Absence of Temperance: The Path to Political Vice

When the idea of temperance is abandoned, the political landscape becomes fertile ground for various vices that erode stability and justice.

  • Tyranny and Despotism: Unchecked ambition and a complete lack of self-restraint in a ruler lead directly to tyranny. The pursuit of absolute power, devoid of moderation, transforms government into an instrument of oppression.
  • Demagoguery and Populism: When leaders exploit public passions without appealing to reason or long-term consequences, they engage in demagoguery. This lack of temperance in public discourse prioritizes immediate gratification or partisan fervor over considered judgment, often leading to societal division and instability.
  • Corruption and Excess: A government lacking temperance is prone to corruption, where public office is used for private gain. This reflects an absence of self-control and an overindulgence in material or power-driven desires, turning public service into personal enrichment.
  • Extremism and Polarization: In contemporary politics, the absence of temperance manifests as ideological extremism and severe polarization. The inability to compromise, to see merit in opposing viewpoints, or to seek common ground leads to gridlock and an inability to address pressing societal challenges effectively.

Cultivating Temperance in Government: Institutionalizing Moderation

How can the idea of temperance be woven into the fabric of modern government? It requires both institutional design and a commitment to civic virtue.

  • Constitutionalism and Rule of Law: A strong constitution that limits power, establishes checks and balances, and ensures the rule of law is the institutional embodiment of temperance. It prevents any single branch or individual from exercising unbridled authority.
  • Deliberative Democracy: Encouraging robust, reasoned debate and compromise, rather than mere majoritarianism, promotes temperance. It requires leaders and citizens to listen, consider alternative perspectives, and seek solutions that serve the broader public interest.
  • Education for Civic Virtue: Cultivating temperance starts with education. Citizens who understand the importance of moderation, critical thinking, and civic responsibility are better equipped to demand temperate leadership and resist the allure of demagoguery.
  • Independent Institutions: A free press, an independent judiciary, and robust civil society organizations act as crucial checks, providing external pressure for government to remain temperate and accountable.

The Enduring Relevance of Temperance in Politics

In an era often characterized by rapid change, ideological fervor, and the relentless pursuit of power, the idea of temperance might seem quaint. Yet, its absence is precisely what fuels many of our most pressing political problems. From the vices of short-sighted policymaking driven by immediate polls to the polarizing rhetoric that divides nations, the call for political temperance resonates louder than ever. It is an appeal for leaders to exercise restraint, for citizens to demand reason, and for institutions to foster balance, ensuring that the government serves the enduring good of the people rather than succumbing to fleeting passions or unchecked ambition.

Conclusion

The journey through the Great Books of the Western World unequivocally reveals that temperance is not merely a personal adornment but a foundational virtue for any thriving political order. It is the idea that power, left unchecked, inevitably leads to vice and instability. By embracing temperance—in our leaders, our institutions, and ourselves—we cultivate a government capable of wisdom, justice, and enduring peace. Let us, therefore, reclaim this ancient wisdom, embedding the spirit of moderation and balance into the heart of our political endeavors, transforming the abstract idea into a tangible political reality.

YouTube Video Suggestions:

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Plato's Republic Temperance" or "Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Golden Mean Politics""

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""The Virtue of Moderation in Leadership" or "Political Philosophy Temperance""

Share this post