The Enduring Idea of Temperance in Politics

A Call for Measured Governance in an Unsettled World

In an era often defined by extremes and impassioned rhetoric, the ancient idea of temperance might seem quaint, even outmoded. Yet, for those who delve into the enduring wisdom of the Great Books of the Western World, temperance emerges not merely as a personal virtue but as a foundational pillar for stable and just government. This article explores the philosophical underpinnings of temperance, its critical role in political life, and why this often-overlooked virtue remains profoundly relevant for navigating the complexities of modern governance, offering a crucial bulwark against the destructive forces of vice.

The Philosophical Roots of Temperance: A Virtue of Balance

The concept of temperance, or sophrosyne in ancient Greek, has resonated through Western thought since its earliest articulations. For philosophers like Plato and Aristotle, it was more than just moderation; it was a state of inner harmony and self-mastery.

Plato's Republic and the Harmonious State:
In Plato's Republic, temperance is presented as one of the four cardinal virtues, alongside wisdom, courage, and justice. It is the agreement between the naturally superior and inferior parts of the soul as to which should rule. Applied to the state, temperance signifies a similar harmony among its classes—rulers, auxiliaries, and producers—where each understands and accepts its proper role, preventing internal discord. This idea of balance is crucial; it's not about suppression, but about proper order and proportion.

Aristotle's Golden Mean:
Aristotle, in his Nicomachean Ethics, further refines temperance as a moral virtue, defining it as the "golden mean" between two extremes of vice: insensibility (a deficiency of pleasure) and self-indulgence (an excess of pleasure). For Aristotle, the temperate person finds the right measure in their appetites and desires, guided by reason and practical wisdom. This reasoned approach to desires is not just for individuals but is implicitly vital for the collective life of the polis.

(Image: A classical Greek fresco depicting allegorical figures of "Sophrosyne" (Temperance) and "Hybris" (Hubris), with Sophrosyne calmly holding a bridle or a measuring cup, while Hybris gestures wildly towards excess.)

Temperance as a Political Virtue: Guiding the Hand of Government

When we translate these personal virtues into the realm of politics, temperance takes on a profound significance. It becomes the guiding principle for leaders and citizens alike, shaping the character of government itself.

  • For Leaders: A temperate leader exhibits self-control, not succumbing to the temptations of power, wealth, or popular acclaim. They make decisions based on reasoned judgment rather than impulsive reactions or personal gain. This means exercising restraint in policy-making, avoiding grandstanding, and prioritizing the long-term stability and well-being of the state over short-term political victories.
  • For Citizens: A temperate citizenry understands the limits of their demands on the state, practices civil discourse, and resists the allure of demagogues promising impossible solutions. It fosters a civic culture where reasoned debate is preferred over emotional outbursts, and where individual freedoms are balanced with collective responsibilities.

The absence of temperance in politics often leads to various forms of vice: corruption, authoritarianism, reckless populism, and societal fragmentation.

The Idea of Moderation in Governance

The idea of temperance manifests in practical ways within the structure and function of government. It encourages moderation in all aspects of public life.

Characteristics of Temperate Governance:

  • Fiscal Prudence: Avoiding excessive spending or crippling debt, recognizing the limits of public resources.
  • Measured Policy-Making: Implementing changes incrementally, with careful consideration of unintended consequences, rather than through radical, untested reforms.
  • Checks and Balances: The very structure of many democratic governments, with their separation of powers, is a institutionalized form of temperance, designed to prevent any single branch or individual from exercising unchecked authority.
  • Respect for Law and Tradition: While not static, temperate governance respects the accumulated wisdom of the past and the established legal framework, avoiding arbitrary rule.
  • Dialogue and Compromise: Recognizing that absolute certainty in complex political matters is rare, temperate leaders engage in open dialogue and seek common ground.

Virtue and Vice: The Stakes of Political Temperance

The contrast between virtue and vice in politics is stark. A temperate political body fosters trust, stability, and enduring prosperity. Conversely, a polity devoid of temperance is prone to instability, injustice, and ultimately, decline.

Aspect of Governance Temperate Approach (Virtue) Intemperate Approach (Vice)
Decision Making Reasoned, deliberative, patient Impulsive, emotional, reactive
Power Utilization Restrained, accountable, shared Unchecked, authoritarian, monopolized
Public Discourse Respectful, fact-based, open Divisive, inflammatory, dogmatic
Resource Management Prudent, sustainable, equitable Extravagant, exploitative, self-serving
Social Harmony Inclusive, compromising, unified Fragmented, polarized, conflict-ridden

The historical record, from the decline of republics to the rise of tyrannies, provides ample evidence of the destructive power of vice when temperance is abandoned. The idea of temperance, therefore, is not a quaint philosophical relic, but a vital blueprint for political survival and flourishing.

Conclusion: Reclaiming Temperance for a Resilient Polity

In an age where political discourse often gravitates towards extremes, and the allure of radical solutions can be strong, the ancient idea of temperance offers a compelling counter-narrative. It reminds us that true strength in government lies not in unbridled power or unyielding ideology, but in self-mastery, moderation, and a reasoned approach to collective life. Reclaiming and actively promoting temperance as a core political virtue is essential for building resilient societies capable of navigating complex challenges without succumbing to the divisive forces of vice. It is a timeless call for wisdom, balance, and the steady hand of reason in the affairs of state.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato on temperance and the ideal state"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics and the golden mean in politics"

Share this post