The Enduring Idea of Temperance in Politics
Summary: In the tumultuous currents of political life, the ancient idea of temperance stands as a beacon of stability and wisdom. Far from mere personal restraint, temperance, as explored by the great minds of the Western tradition, is a cardinal virtue essential for just government and a flourishing society. This article delves into how philosophers from Plato to Aristotle conceived of temperance not just as a check on individual appetites, but as a critical principle for statecraft, preventing the vice of excess and fostering balance, moderation, and prudent governance.
The Enduring Idea of Temperance: A Classical Foundation
The concept of temperance (Greek: sophrosyne, Latin: temperantia) has resonated through the corridors of Western thought for millennia. Often grouped with courage, justice, and wisdom as one of the four cardinal virtues, its significance extends far beyond individual discipline. For thinkers whose works comprise the Great Books of the Western World, temperance was understood as a foundational element for both personal well-being and the very structure of a stable and ethical society.
Grace Ellis here, and I find myself continually drawn back to these foundational texts because they offer not just historical insights, but profoundly practical guidance for our contemporary challenges. The idea of temperance, in particular, offers a powerful lens through which to examine the health and efficacy of our political systems.
Temperance Beyond Personal Restraint: A Political Virtue
While temperance certainly implies self-control over one's desires and pleasures, its political dimension is far more expansive. In the realm of government, temperance manifests as:
- Moderation in Power: A check on the impulse to accumulate and wield unchecked authority.
- Prudence in Policy: The measured consideration of long-term consequences over short-term gains or impulsive reactions.
- Balance in Governance: Ensuring that no single faction, interest, or branch of government dominates to the detriment of the whole.
- Fiscal Responsibility: Restraint in public spending and resource allocation, avoiding extravagance and debt.
- Respect for Law and Order: A willingness to abide by established norms and limits, rather than succumbing to lawlessness or arbitrary rule.
The absence of temperance, conversely, paves the way for a host of vices: tyranny, corruption, demagoguery, and the instability born of unchecked ambition and greed.
Historical Perspectives from the Great Books
To truly grasp the political weight of temperance, we must turn to its most eloquent proponents.
Plato's Vision of the Temperate City
In Plato's seminal work, The Republic, temperance (sophrosyne) is presented not merely as a personal attribute but as a structural principle for the ideal state. Plato argues that a just city mirrors a just soul, and just as temperance brings harmony to the individual by aligning reason with spirit and appetite, so too does it create harmony within the city.
- Harmony and Agreement: Plato describes temperance as a kind of "agreement" or "concord" throughout the entire city, "between the naturally superior and inferior as to which of the two is to rule" (Book IV). This implies a willing submission of the lower elements (the appetitive class – producers) to the higher (the rational class – guardians and rulers), ensuring that reason, embodied by the philosopher-kings, guides the state.
- The Idea of Order: For Plato, temperance is synonymous with order and discipline, ensuring that each part of the city performs its proper function without overstepping its bounds. Without this, the city descends into factionalism and chaos, demonstrating the vice of political intemperance.
(Image: A classical fresco depicting a figure of Sophrosyne (Temperance), often shown holding a bridle or a chalice, symbolizing self-control and moderation, perhaps with other allegorical figures representing wisdom or justice in the background.)
Aristotle's Mean in Politics
Aristotle, building upon Plato, further elaborates on temperance in his Nicomachean Ethics and Politics. For Aristotle, virtue lies in the "mean" between two extremes of vice – excess and deficiency. Temperance, therefore, is the virtuous mean concerning bodily pleasures and desires.
When applied to government, Aristotle's concept of the mean is crucial:
- The Balanced Polity: In Politics, Aristotle champions a "polity" or constitutional government as the best practical form of rule, precisely because it embodies a temperate approach. It seeks a mean between oligarchy (rule by the wealthy few, prone to excess) and democracy (rule by the poor many, prone to mob rule and instability).
- Virtue in Leadership: Leaders who possess temperance are less likely to succumb to the temptations of power, wealth, or flattery. Their decisions are guided by reason and the common good, rather than by personal gratification or partisan zeal. This cultivation of virtue is paramount for good governance.
- Avoiding Extremes: Aristotle warns against the vice of political extremism. An intemperate state, whether it be a tyrannical monarchy, an unchecked oligarchy, or an anarchic democracy, inevitably collapses due to its own internal imbalances and excesses.
Beyond Greece: Roman and Medieval Insights
The idea of temperance continued to evolve. Roman thinkers like Cicero saw it as crucial for public service and the stability of the Republic. Later, Christian philosophers like Aquinas integrated it into a broader theological framework, emphasizing its role in ordering human desires towards divine purpose, and by extension, for the just ordering of human societies and their government. The consistent thread is that temperance is not merely an aesthetic preference but a practical necessity for societal flourishing.
The Vice of Intemperance in Politics
What happens when the idea of temperance is abandoned in political life? The historical record, unfortunately, provides ample evidence of the destructive vice of intemperance:
| Political Vice Arising from Intemperance | Description | Historical Manifestation |
|---|---|---|
| Tyranny | Unchecked lust for power; disregard for law and citizen rights. | Ancient despots, modern authoritarian regimes. |
| Corruption | Greed and self-interest dominating public office; misuse of state resources. | Embezzlement, bribery, cronyism in any era. |
| Demagoguery | Appealing to raw emotions and prejudices rather than reason; inciting division for personal gain. | Populist movements exploiting fear or anger. |
| Fiscal Irresponsibility | Excessive spending, unsustainable debt, prioritizing short-term gratification over long-term stability. | Economic crises fueled by government overreach or lack of discipline. |
| Factionalism/Polarization | Inability to compromise; extreme ideological rigidity; prioritizing party over common good. | Gridlock, civil unrest, breakdown of consensus. |
These examples underscore that the idea of temperance is not an abstract philosophical nicety but a vital bulwark against the forces that undermine justice, stability, and collective well-being.
Cultivating Temperance in Modern Government
In our complex modern world, the challenge of cultivating temperance in government remains as urgent as ever. It requires a multi-faceted approach:
- Education and Civic Virtue: Fostering an understanding of civic virtue, including temperance, from an early age. This involves robust humanities education, drawing lessons from the Great Books, to shape thoughtful citizens and leaders.
- Institutional Checks and Balances: Designing constitutional frameworks that inherently limit power and prevent any single branch or individual from becoming intemperate. This includes independent judiciaries, free presses, and robust oversight mechanisms.
- Ethical Leadership: Encouraging and supporting leaders who demonstrate personal temperance – humility, integrity, and a commitment to serving the common good over personal ambition.
- Public Discourse: Promoting a culture of reasoned debate and respectful disagreement, where moderation and thoughtful engagement are valued over inflammatory rhetoric and ideological purity.
- Policy Design: Crafting policies that are sustainable, equitable, and forward-looking, rather than reactive, short-sighted, or driven by narrow interests.
The idea of temperance reminds us that while progress and innovation are vital, they must be tempered with wisdom, foresight, and a profound respect for limits.
Conclusion: A Timeless Imperative
The journey through the Great Books of the Western World reveals a consistent truth: the idea of temperance is indispensable for sound government. It is the virtue that guards against the vice of excess in all its forms, from the individual leader's hubris to the state's overreach. In an era often characterized by extremes, rediscovering and re-emphasizing temperance offers a powerful path toward more stable, just, and truly flourishing political communities. It is a timeless imperative, calling us to seek balance, practice restraint, and govern with wisdom.
YouTube: "Plato's Republic Temperance"
YouTube: "Aristotle Political Virtues"
📹 Related Video: What is Philosophy?
Video by: The School of Life
💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "The Idea of Temperance in Politics philosophy"