The Quiet Strength of Temperance in Politics

Summary: In an era often characterized by extremes, the ancient idea of temperance emerges as a foundational, yet frequently overlooked, virtue essential for stable and just government. Far more than mere abstinence, temperance – or sophrosyne – signifies a profound self-mastery, moderation, and rational control over desires, both individual and collective. This article explores temperance as a critical political virtue, drawing from the wisdom of the Great Books of the Western World to understand its role in fostering wise leadership, responsible citizenship, and resilient political systems, thereby safeguarding against the destructive forces of vice.

Defining Temperance: A Philosophical Cornerstone

The concept of temperance, deeply rooted in classical philosophy, transcends a simple call for moderation in personal habits. Philosophically, temperance is the harmonious balance of the soul's desires and reason, ensuring that appetites are guided by intellect rather than dominating it. It is the wisdom to know one's limits and the discipline to adhere to them. When extended from the individual to the political sphere, temperance becomes a vital principle for the functioning of the state itself.

The Idea of Temperance in the Great Books Tradition

The Great Books of the Western World offer a rich tapestry of insights into temperance, highlighting its enduring significance.

  • Plato's Republic: For Plato, sophrosyne (often translated as temperance or moderation) is one of the four cardinal virtues, crucial for both the just individual and the just state. In the ideal city, temperance is not merely found in one class but is a pervasive harmony, a general agreement among all citizens about who should rule. It is the virtue that ensures each part of the soul, and each class in the state, performs its proper function without overstepping its bounds. Without temperance, the appetitive part of the soul (and the corresponding class) would run rampant, leading to chaos and injustice.
  • Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics: Aristotle further refines the idea of temperance, defining it as a "mean" between excess and deficiency. For instance, courage is the mean between rashness and cowardice. Temperance, in this sense, is the appropriate control over bodily pleasures and desires. Applied to politics, it implies a government that seeks balance, avoids extremes, and makes decisions based on rational deliberation rather than impulsive passion or greedy ambition. It is a virtue that enables individuals to achieve eudaimonia (flourishing) and, by extension, allows the polis to thrive.
  • Other Contributions: While Plato and Aristotle provide foundational insights, the Stoics emphasized self-control and apathy towards external pleasures as a path to tranquility, a form of temperance. Later, figures like Montesquieu, in his discussions of checks and balances, implicitly championed a form of institutional temperance, designing systems to prevent any single branch or individual from accumulating excessive power – a political mechanism to enforce moderation.

Temperance as a Political Virtue for Government and Governance

The application of temperance to politics is multifaceted, impacting both those who govern and the structure of government itself.

  1. Leadership Temperance:

    • Prudence and Foresight: A temperate leader is not swayed by immediate gratification or popular whims but considers long-term consequences. They exercise restraint in the use of power, avoiding authoritarianism and overreach.
    • Fiscal Responsibility: Temperance in governance means managing public resources wisely, avoiding excessive debt, and prioritizing sustainable growth over lavish spending.
    • Humility and Self-Awareness: A temperate leader understands their own limitations and biases, fostering an environment of open discussion and critical feedback rather than dictatorial pronouncements.

  2. Institutional Temperance:

    • Checks and Balances: Constitutional frameworks that distribute power and create oversight mechanisms inherently promote temperance by preventing any single entity from becoming excessively powerful.
    • Rule of Law: A commitment to established laws and processes, rather than arbitrary decision-making, reflects a temperate approach to governance.
    • Deliberation over Demagoguery: Political systems that encourage thoughtful debate and compromise over impassioned, divisive rhetoric embody the spirit of temperance.

Virtue and Vice in the Political Arena

The absence of temperance in politics invariably leads to vice, with detrimental consequences for society.

Political Virtue (Temperance in Action) Political Vice (Absence of Temperance) Consequences for Governance
Prudent Decision-making Impulsiveness, Rashness Policy failures, instability
Fiscal Responsibility Profligacy, Greed Economic crises, corruption
Respect for Law and Institutions Arbitrary Rule, Authoritarianism Erosion of trust, tyranny
Compromise and Deliberation Extremism, Polarization Gridlock, civil unrest
Accountability and Transparency Corruption, Secrecy Public distrust, injustice

When leaders succumb to the vice of intemperance – whether through avarice, lust for power, or unchecked ambition – the entire political fabric is weakened. Similarly, a citizenry lacking temperance can be swayed by demagogues, demanding immediate gratification or succumbing to tribalism, thereby undermining the deliberative processes essential for healthy government.

Reclaiming the Idea: Modern Relevance

In contemporary politics, where polarization often dominates discourse and leaders are frequently accused of lacking self-restraint, the idea of temperance holds profound relevance. It calls for a return to fundamental principles of moderation, respect, and long-term vision. Cultivating temperance, both in our leaders and within ourselves as citizens, is not merely an idealistic aspiration but a practical necessity for navigating complex global challenges, fostering constructive dialogue, and building more resilient and just societies.

(Image: A classical Greek marble bust of a serene philosopher, possibly Plato or Aristotle, with a thoughtful, composed expression, symbolizing intellectual calm, self-control, and the pursuit of wisdom.)

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Plato Republic Temperance Politics Explained"

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: "Aristotle Virtue Ethics Moderation Government"

Share this post