The Evolution of Moral Customs and Evolution

The landscape of human morality, often perceived as an unyielding bedrock of eternal truths, is in fact a dynamic, ever-shifting terrain. This article explores the profound concept of "The Evolution of Moral Customs," tracing how our collective understanding of right and wrong, Virtue and Vice, has undergone continuous Change throughout history. Drawing upon the rich tapestry of thought found in the Great Books of the Western World, we will examine how Custom and Convention shape our ethical frameworks, and how philosophical inquiry itself contributes to this ongoing Evolution. From ancient Greek ethos to Enlightenment critiques, the journey reveals that morality is not static but a living, evolving construct, perpetually re-negotiated by human societies.

The Shifting Sands of Ethical Life: An Introduction

For many, the idea that morality evolves can be unsettling. We often cling to the notion of universal, immutable principles that guide our actions and define our character. Yet, a cursory glance across different cultures, or even through the annals of a single society over centuries, reveals a startling truth: what was once considered a Virtue can become a Vice, and vice versa. This is not to say that all morality is relative, but rather to acknowledge the undeniable Change in the specific Customs and Conventions that embody our ethical ideals. Philosophers, from the earliest chroniclers of human nature to the most incisive critics of societal norms, have grappled with this phenomenon, seeking to understand its origins, its mechanisms, and its implications for human flourishing.

Custom as the Cradle of Virtue: Ancient Perspectives

Long before written laws, Custom and Convention served as the primary architects of moral order. In ancient societies, ethical life was deeply embedded in the practices, traditions, and shared habits of a community. The very word "ethics" derives from the Greek ethos, meaning custom or habit.

Aristotle and the Habituation of Virtue: In his Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle famously argued that moral virtues are not innate but acquired through habit. We become just by performing just acts, courageous by performing courageous acts. This process of habituation is intrinsically linked to the prevailing Customs and Conventions of one's society. A child growing up in a Spartan society would cultivate different virtues (e.g., discipline, martial prowess) than one in an Athenian democracy (e.g., civic participation, rhetoric). For Aristotle, the good life was inseparable from the ethical framework provided by the polis, where customs helped shape individuals into virtuous citizens. The Evolution here is generational, a refinement of practices passed down and adapted.
Plato's Ideal State and Moral Education: While Plato, in works like The Republic and The Laws, sought a more rational, ideal basis for justice and morality, he too recognized the power of societal structures and education in shaping character. His vision of a perfectly ordered state relied heavily on specific laws, customs, and an educational system designed to instill particular virtues, thereby preventing moral decay and ensuring societal stability. The Change here is often prescriptive, an attempt to guide moral evolution towards a perceived ideal.

(Image: A detailed classical Greek frieze depicting a philosopher, perhaps Aristotle, engaged in discourse with several younger students, set within an Athenian stoa. The students are listening intently, some taking notes, while others gesture in thoughtful contemplation. The background shows architectural elements like columns and an open sky, suggesting an outdoor learning environment. The scene emphasizes the transmission of knowledge and moral principles through teaching and custom.)

The Enlightenment's Scrutiny: Questioning Established Norms

The philosophical landscape underwent a profound Change during the Enlightenment, as thinkers began to critically examine the foundations of inherited Custom and Convention. Reason, rather than tradition, became the touchstone for evaluating moral claims.

Hume and Moral Sentiment: David Hume, in his Treatise of Human Nature and Enquiries, challenged the idea that reason alone dictates morality. Instead, he argued that moral judgments arise from sentiment, from feelings of approbation or disapprobation. However, these sentiments are not arbitrary; they are often shaped by shared social experiences and the utility of certain actions for the common good. Custom and Convention play a significant role in establishing what is deemed useful or agreeable, and therefore virtuous. Hume's work highlights how the Evolution of moral customs can be driven by a collective, albeit non-rational, sense of what benefits society.
Social Contract Theorists and Legitimate Authority: Philosophers like John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, while differing in their conclusions, both posited that legitimate political and moral authority stems from a social contract. This implied that Customs and Conventions were not divinely ordained or immutable, but rather agreements that could be re-evaluated and altered if they no longer served the common good or upheld natural rights. The very idea of the "general will" (Rousseau) or government by consent (Locke) inherently allows for the Change and Evolution of moral and legal frameworks.

The Dynamic Interplay of Virtue and Vice Across Eras

The most striking evidence of moral Evolution lies in how definitions of Virtue and Vice themselves transform. What was once celebrated can become condemned, and what was once taboo can become acceptable.

Consider the following historical shifts:

Slavery: Once a widely accepted Custom and Convention across numerous civilizations, including those discussed in the Great Books (e.g., ancient Greece, Rome), slavery is now almost universally condemned as an extreme Vice. The Evolution of this moral stance involved centuries of philosophical critique, religious arguments, and social movements.
Usury (Lending at Interest): In medieval Christian thought (e.g., Thomas Aquinas), usury was considered a serious Vice, a sin against justice. Today, it is a fundamental Custom and Convention of modern economies, largely stripped of its moral opprobrium, though debates about predatory lending persist.
Gender Roles and Rights: The Customs and Conventions surrounding the roles of women have undergone immense Change. Historically, many societies confined women to domestic spheres, denying them political or educational rights. The Evolution towards gender equality has redefined Virtues like independence and leadership as applicable to all, challenging long-held Vices of subjugation.

These examples underscore that Change is not merely incidental but intrinsic to the human moral experience. New circumstances, new knowledge, and new empathetic insights continually challenge and refine our ethical frameworks.

Mechanisms of Moral Evolution

The Evolution of moral Customs and Conventions is a complex process, driven by a confluence of factors:

Philosophical Reflection: Critical inquiry, as demonstrated by the thinkers in the Great Books, pushes societies to examine their foundational beliefs and practices.
Scientific and Technological Advancements: New knowledge (e.g., understanding of psychology, climate science) or capabilities (e.g., genetic engineering, artificial intelligence) introduce novel ethical dilemmas and necessitate new moral considerations.
Economic and Political Shifts: Changes in modes of production, governance structures, or global power dynamics often lead to corresponding adjustments in social norms and moral expectations.
Cross-Cultural Contact: Exposure to different ethical systems can lead to re-evaluation of one's own Customs and Conventions, fostering both adoption and rejection of foreign ideas.
Social Movements and Advocacy: Organized efforts by groups challenging existing injustices or advocating for new rights often catalyze significant moral Change.
Religious Reform and Interpretation: reinterpretations of sacred texts or theological developments can reshape moral codes within religious communities and influence broader society.

Conclusion: The Enduring Flux of Ethical Inquiry

The journey through the Evolution of Moral Customs reveals that morality is not a static edifice but a continuously constructed and reconstructed human endeavor. From Aristotle's emphasis on habituation within a community's Customs and Conventions to Hume's analysis of moral sentiment and the Enlightenment's call for rational scrutiny, philosophers have consistently illuminated the dynamic nature of our ethical lives.

Understanding this ongoing Change is crucial. It reminds us that our present moral codes, while deeply ingrained, are themselves products of a long history of Evolution. It challenges us to remain intellectually humble and ethically vigilant, constantly questioning whether our current Virtues and Vices truly serve justice, compassion, and human flourishing, or if they are merely echoes of outdated Customs and Conventions awaiting their own transformation. The philosophical task, therefore, is not just to define morality, but to participate consciously in its endless, fascinating Evolution.

Video by: The School of Life

💡 Want different videos? Search YouTube for: ""Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics custom virtue habit""